Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Ms. Toad

(38,558 posts)
30. While I agree that Dr. Fauci is, on the whole, fantastic -
Wed Apr 27, 2022, 02:05 PM
Apr 2022

Some of his actions as to COVID have fallen below that standard.

Formal medical and/or public health credentials are not necessary to understand the near-certain impact of announcing that certain people no longer need to wear masks - or of an announcement that the pandemic is over . Formal medical and/or public health credentials are not necessary to understand the science behind masks (initially - whether they are effective at all, and later whether they protect both the wearer and those around them).

I have coped for more than 3 decades with family illnessess which are both deadly and rare. Dealing with rare illnesses is not that much different from dealing with a new disease: In both cases, for different reasons, at the time decisions need to be made there are rarely solid peer-reviewed, double-blind studies to guide the decision. The skills I have developed in the past 3 decades have allowed me to (1) efficiently ferret out the relevant research which is available, (2) discard the trash research, (3) and make relatively quick extrapolations from teh relevant, solid, research.

I used those skills here. I have agreed with most of his work on COVID - but not all, and, on every issue with which I differed from Dr.A Fauci as to COVID, time has proven me right - and him wrong. As a general rule, where we differ, is is because I am more willing to make decisions on less information. I determined early on that masks were more likely to provide protection than not - at the time Dr. Fauci was announcing there was no reason for healthy individuals to wear masks. I determined early on that masks protect not only those around an individual, but the individual as well - at the time Dr. Fauci was promoting the "wear a mask to protect others" line. Subsequently, he acknlowedged he was wrong on those two issues. I determined early on that COVID was being spread by aerosolized matter (meaining masks were more critical than social distancing or excessive hand-washing because the aerosolized matter can spread far more than 6', and lingers long after the ill person leaves the room; so it matter far less whether you are 3' or 6' (the droplet distance) - and far more that you are wearing masks to protect against/prevent the spread of the invidible and lingering aerosolized threat) - again, at the time Fauci was touting 6' (and masking if less than 6' was possible).

I don't worship individuals - I evaluate their actions and the information they are providing against what I know or can learn from reviewing the medical literature. Fauci is human, with flaws. As to COVID, at least as to public pronouncement, his flaws are showing more than (for example) in his work with AIDS.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

I'll believe him over any GQP . . .. Lovie777 Apr 2022 #1
According to his definition Dr. Shepper Apr 2022 #2
That's my take on the statement as well. Hugin Apr 2022 #4
Yes Zeitghost Apr 2022 #15
Currently. Hugin Apr 2022 #17
I've been on a number of fights in the last two years Zeitghost Apr 2022 #21
"I'm not sure the lifting of the mask requirement will have much an effect" BumRushDaShow Apr 2022 #24
Masks can certainly slow the spread Zeitghost Apr 2022 #26
"Masks can certainly slow the spread" BumRushDaShow Apr 2022 #29
Thanks for the meaty posts, BR. Hugin Apr 2022 #38
Sorry for the BumRushDaShow Apr 2022 #39
Omicron was spread globally in less than a month due to air travel. Hugin Apr 2022 #37
Yes. And I am extremely disappointed in Dr. Fauci Ms. Toad Apr 2022 #23
Many of us have come to deeply respect Dr. Fauci Zeitghost Apr 2022 #27
While I agree that Dr. Fauci is, on the whole, fantastic - Ms. Toad Apr 2022 #30
So none then? Zeitghost Apr 2022 #31
Then be prepared to be late to the party, Ms. Toad Apr 2022 #35
I'm still waiting for your all's clear, Ms. T. Hugin Apr 2022 #40
If you don't like my credentials, Ms. Toad May 2022 #44
A couple of points Doc Sportello Apr 2022 #32
It's not either/or. It's and. Ms. Toad Apr 2022 #34
So much wrong here Doc Sportello Apr 2022 #41
"Because business and political leaders would prefer it that way." WhiskeyGrinder Apr 2022 #3
+1 Hugin Apr 2022 #5
Nailed it. nt BlackSkimmer Apr 2022 #18
We have been below 200,000 new infections/day for the vast majority of the pandemic. Blues Heron Apr 2022 #6
Let's all buckle up and not become complacent. I'm sure that something worse is abqtommy Apr 2022 #7
If you're boosted, Covid is no longer a significant threat Johnny2X2X Apr 2022 #8
... until the next variant comes along. speak easy Apr 2022 #9
its a virus you just dont want even if you dont get hospitalized Blues Heron Apr 2022 #10
+1 n/t area51 Apr 2022 #11
It's not the flu Johnny2X2X Apr 2022 #12
This. SoonerPride Apr 2022 #13
It's almost like we have two different viruses Doc Sportello Apr 2022 #14
I cannot agree more Johnny2X2X Apr 2022 #16
Kids younger than 5 still aren't vaxxed. WhiskeyGrinder Apr 2022 #19
Vaxxed people are 12-20 times less likely to get long Covid symptoms Johnny2X2X Apr 2022 #20
Thanks for the true numbers Doc Sportello Apr 2022 #22
Very good recap Johnny2X2X Apr 2022 #25
Also, other viruses can result in longer term post-infection viral injury greenjar_01 Apr 2022 #33
Excellent news! Time to get back to 2019 normal. beaglelover Apr 2022 #28
He had to walk that statement back: gldstwmn Apr 2022 #36
I would like to remind people that a Trump appointed judge stopped the mask mandate. Maggiemayhem Apr 2022 #42
We are not out of it as others pointed out above Meowmee Apr 2022 #43
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Dr. Fauci on why the U.S....»Reply #30