Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Celerity

(43,330 posts)
31. I'm Sorry for Creating the 'Gerasimov Doctrine'
Sun May 1, 2022, 04:33 PM
May 2022
I was the first to write about Russia’s infamous high-tech military strategy. One small problem: it doesn't exist.

BY MARK GALEOTTI | MARCH 5, 2018

https://foreignpolicy.com/2018/03/05/im-sorry-for-creating-the-gerasimov-doctrine/

https://archive.ph/832SB#selection-1353.0-1387.23

Everywhere, you’ll find scholars, pundits, and policymakers talking about the threat the “Gerasimov doctrine” — named after Russia’s chief of the general staff — poses to the West. It’s a new way of war, “an expanded theory of modern warfare,” or even “a vision of total warfare.” There’s one small problem. It doesn’t exist. And the longer we pretend it does, the longer we misunderstand the — real, but different — challenge Russia poses.

I feel I can say that because, to my immense chagrin, I created this term, which has since acquired a destructive life of its own, lumbering clumsily into the world to spread fear and loathing in its wake. Back in February 2013, the Russian newspaper Military-Industrial Courier — as exciting and widely read as it sounds — reprinted a speech by Gen. Valery Gerasimov. It talks of how in the modern world, the use of propaganda and subversion means that “a perfectly thriving state can, in a matter of months and even days, be transformed into an arena of fierce armed conflict, become a victim of foreign intervention, and sink into a web of chaos, humanitarian catastrophe, and civil war.”

It largely passed unnoticed, but Robert Coalson of Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty, the U.S. government-funded TV and radio service broadcasting to Russia and other unfree countries, picked up on it and translated it. He sent it to me and, with his permission, I published the translation on my blog, with my own comments. A blog is as much as anything else a vanity site; obviously I want people to read it. So for a snappy title, I coined the term “Gerasimov doctrine,” though even then I noted in the text that this term was nothing more than “a placeholder,” and “it certainly isn’t a doctrine.” I didn’t think people would genuinely believe either that he came up with it (Gerasimov is a tough and effective chief of the general staff, but no theoretician), less yet than it was a “programmatic” blueprint for war on the West.

But then came the annexation of Crimea, when “little green men” — commandos without insignia — seized the peninsula with scarcely a shot fired. This was followed by the Donbass war, fought initially by a motley collection of local thugs, separatists, Russian adventurers, and special forces, accompanied by a barrage of lurid Russian propaganda. Suddenly, it seemed that Gerasimov had indeed been describing what was to come, had we but realized it. Prone, as ever, to overcompensation, Western mainstream opinion swung from ignoring Gerasimov’s pronouncements to enshrining them as some kind of bleeding-edge blueprint for a new way of war.

snip
He is lucky that he is still alive. Thank You for Posting K and R Stuart G May 2022 #1
Just updated. Tomconroy May 2022 #2
Thank You for the Update. Stuart G May 2022 #4
Awwwww....I'm a sucker for happy endings! Rot in hell war criminals. Comfortably_Numb May 2022 #3
Yeah! I love happy endings too! calimary May 2022 #22
Well, it might be available at some resale shop soon Bucky May 2022 #35
That second guy, Simonov, looks like wnylib May 2022 #51
20 confirmed killed? Cracklin Charlie May 2022 #5
Gerasimov was only wounded the article says. Irish_Dem May 2022 #6
Wounded can mean a lot of things in russian...... getagrip_already May 2022 #8
The article states he took shrapnel to his leg but it did not break any bones GregariousGroundhog May 2022 #40
Other posts.... getagrip_already May 2022 #45
Yes, the articles have been somewhat contradictory peggysue2 May 2022 #58
If it were just a flesh wound of his lower leg.... getagrip_already May 2022 #62
Well now, there's been another report peggysue2 May 2022 #65
he's not dead, he's just resting. Ray Bruns May 2022 #47
Beautiful plumage...n/t bluecollar2 May 2022 #49
Beautiful plumage...n/t bluecollar2 May 2022 #50
'Tis but a scratch! 11 Bravo May 2022 #66
I'm greedy BeyondGeography May 2022 #7
Here's to no recovery KS Toronado May 2022 #21
No arguments here BeyondGeography May 2022 #25
Woopsies, we're those YOUR most senior leaders we hurt? getagrip_already May 2022 #9
War Karma. Who'd a thunk it. LakeArenal May 2022 #10
... Nevilledog May 2022 #11
These made me laugh! Thank you, my dear Nevilledog! ♥ CaliforniaPeggy May 2022 #13
... Nevilledog May 2022 #32
I love that meme... Johnyawl May 2022 #39
LOL. Igel May 2022 #42
Is it me or does that military dress gear look as cheaply made as Chinese prom dresses from Alibaba? TheBlackAdder May 2022 #57
I see a lot of Russian uniforms.... SergeStorms May 2022 #63
Rts🤷‍♂️💕TY Cha May 2022 #12
Read that the first general was transported to Russia for medical treatment .... Lovie777 May 2022 #14
So, *he* was transported to Russia. Igel May 2022 #44
Dead. Fertilizing Ukrainian soil. wnylib May 2022 #53
Pushing up sunflowers. ChazInAz May 2022 #59
🌻🌻🌻🌻🌻🌻🌻🌻🌻🌻 Hekate May 2022 #15
Now that's what I call a surprise party! Native May 2022 #16
R&K 💙💛 MerryBlooms May 2022 #17
Ok the question is...who left their "find my iPhone" setting on???😏.. nt mitch96 May 2022 #18
If accurate, that's quite a hit on the Russian military hierarchy. Fla Dem May 2022 #19
Keep it up, Ukraine!!! COL Mustard May 2022 #20
uhh didn't that last guy's face melt when they opened the Ark??? lapfog_1 May 2022 #23
I thought he looked familiar. niyad May 2022 #41
I just posted a reference to him up thread wnylib May 2022 #52
K&R n/t AntiFascist May 2022 #24
And in other news, Putin had a stroke because of the Ukraine crisis (Don't I wish this was true).... COL Mustard May 2022 #26
GOOD ONE! bif May 2022 #29
"Hryvnia" - unit of Ukrainian money. SergeStorms May 2022 #64
Thanks! COL Mustard May 2022 #67
Just think of the savings the oligarchs can steal from the brass's deaths! erronis May 2022 #27
He wasn't sent to save the day, he was exiled Warpy May 2022 #28
Looks like "The Big Eye In The Sky" spotted where their HQ was... Justice matters. May 2022 #30
I'm Sorry for Creating the 'Gerasimov Doctrine' Celerity May 2022 #31
the second guy... all hat... Demovictory9 May 2022 #33
From the OP subject line, I thought it was gonna be about General Steven Seagal Bucky May 2022 #34
Sadly, it appears to have been just a flesh wound. Crunchy Frog May 2022 #36
From the photo, he appears to be on a permanent bender. Nt spooky3 May 2022 #37
He looks like a caricature of a an old time Soviet officer... Rhiannon12866 May 2022 #38
He is. They are. Igel May 2022 #43
It's as sad as it gets that the old time Soviets have regained power Rhiannon12866 May 2022 #46
Seems more like tsarist rule. wnylib May 2022 #55
This is great news to start my day! Thank you! Glory to Ukraine!!! liberalla May 2022 #48
I'm sure US Intelligence is providing the details DenaliDemocrat May 2022 #54
As the Butcher of Syria its the least he has coming to him. ancianita May 2022 #56
Sing along....'Don't stand so close to me....' flying_wahini May 2022 #60
Lot of room for promotion in the Russian Army lately ZonkerHarris May 2022 #61
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»This was the guy the Russ...»Reply #31