Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

General Discussion

PTWB

(4,131 posts)

24. I'm curious to see what new requirements New York decides on

Reply to Sympthsical (Reply #23)

Thu Jun 23, 2022, 01:46 PM

Jun 2022

This ruling really seems to open the door wide for any number of requirements as long as they are objective and not subjective.

I expect to see a laundry list of requirements that licensees must do, and that the requirements will be so burdensome that few people will actually have the time or money to satisfy them.

This will likely be back in front of SCOTUS in a few years.

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

24 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

The SCOTUS ruling on concealed carry is not unexpected [View all] PTWB Jun 2022 OP

Correct. roamer65 Jun 2022 #1

SCOTUS decisions often have nuance that gets ignored in the rush to complain about them AZSkiffyGeek Jun 2022 #2

Miranda ruling is used in other countries. Historic NY Jun 2022 #10

But the ruling related to suing the police for not Miranda-ing AZSkiffyGeek Jun 2022 #13

True but it seem to been a sput to push it elsewhere. Historic NY Jun 2022 #15

The decision said the requirements were an undue burden in NewYork. So that's not a given. onecaliberal Jun 2022 #3

That's because they were subjective. PTWB Jun 2022 #5

This is not the best argument. IMO. onecaliberal Jun 2022 #7

I'm not sure what you're saying. PTWB Jun 2022 #14

I hear you, I'm just telling you this is what they'll argue and drag out every one of these issues onecaliberal Jun 2022 #18

I don't like that sheriffs control this in CA. David__77 Jun 2022 #4

SCOTUS can EABOD. Voltaire2 Jun 2022 #6

👆🏻👆🏻 onecaliberal Jun 2022 #19

I suspect NYS will tax and regulate the fuck out of guns and gun owners BeyondGeography Jun 2022 #8

I hope so. Scrivener7 Jun 2022 #11

Shhh.... sarisataka Jun 2022 #9

Sure. Because who can tell the difference between a bus and a gun? Scrivener7 Jun 2022 #12

As I indicated it is an imperfect analogy sarisataka Jun 2022 #17

There's the rub though. Nothing stopping states from trimming their... brush Jun 2022 #16

Many states don't have any requirements at all to carry a gun. PTWB Jun 2022 #21

Yeah, this just means more guns in a nation awash in them. brush Jun 2022 #22

Thank you for clarifying this! Native Jun 2022 #20

The Court basically thought New York was doing an end-run around Heller Sympthsical Jun 2022 #23

I'm curious to see what new requirements New York decides on PTWB Jun 2022 #24