General Discussion

ITAL

(1,247 posts)

51. I'm saying

Mon Nov 14, 2022, 11:40 AM

Nov 2022

If in theory the House should be approximately representative of the nation at large, if more people in the country voted for Republicans they should probably hold the House. If the GOP lost by 4 million and won the House by 2-3 seats, then sure gerrymanders are the reason. If they win by 2+ million, then that isn't the story.

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

78 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

Democrats should be livid about losing the House [View all] Johnny2X2X Nov 2022 OP

Yes, But DarthDem Nov 2022 #1

Bravo! BlueIdaho Nov 2022 #27

actually, after what republicans have done with tfg and abortion it shouldn't have been close, even certainot Nov 2022 #54

and bdamomma Nov 2022 #75

Just this morning, Joe Scarborough tried to make the claim that gerrymandering bullwinkle428 Nov 2022 #2

Well, the GOP so far is up by over 4 million votes ITAL Nov 2022 #5

Millions of votes in California to still be counted. onecaliberal Nov 2022 #11

I'm in California ITAL Nov 2022 #15

You need to look at what the court did in Texas and Florida. States ignored rulings on maps onecaliberal Nov 2022 #41

I'm saying ITAL Nov 2022 #51

You can't apply national totals to districts; people are not uniformly distributed across the land. Hermit-The-Prog Nov 2022 #67

And districts are not uniformly distributed by area Zeitghost Nov 2022 #71

I just woke up. Baitball Blogger Nov 2022 #3

I don't think so, not yet. Nothing has babylonsister Nov 2022 #4

Thank you! Baitball Blogger Nov 2022 #6

Not a done deal, but our chances took big hits last night Johnny2X2X Nov 2022 #7

I'm still in it to win it! William Seger Nov 2022 #29

Nope...still in the hunt...the usual doom and gloom...but we took two seats last night. Demsrule86 Nov 2022 #28

Thank you! Baitball Blogger Nov 2022 #30

Two (2) seat pickup last night?? Garibaldista Nov 2022 #43

We also lost two since last night (NY and OR) Polybius Nov 2022 #61

And just lost one more Polybius Nov 2022 #60

Reality is not "doom and gloom" brooklynite Nov 2022 #73

I don't think there is a strong path for us. LeftInTX Nov 2022 #69

It's no coincidence better maps...Democratic win...4 decades MiHale Nov 2022 #8

Michigan is the shining example Johnny2X2X Nov 2022 #10

I wish we had that in Texas. Until we get a majority in yellowdogintexas Nov 2022 #36

Something has to be done about district map jerrymandering. honest.abe Nov 2022 #9

Jerrymandering? You're blaming the Germans? FSogol Nov 2022 #12

Right? Elbridge's family came from England! NullTuples Nov 2022 #24

Why not blame the Germans? markodochartaigh Nov 2022 #32

That's one explanation for East Prussia and West Berlin. Marcuse Nov 2022 #37

I thought it was Jerry Stiller's fault, everyone knows that. nt Carlitos Brigante Nov 2022 #44

Is there any legal recourse to their refusal Quakerfriend Nov 2022 #13

They should be livid at Cuomo and the New York Democratic Party. Beautiful Disaster Nov 2022 #14

Pundits and pollsters had Republicans gaining as many as 50 seats in the House. sop Nov 2022 #16

Agree Johnny2X2X Nov 2022 #17

THANK YOU !!! uponit7771 Nov 2022 #18

We lost a lot of winnable seats in blue NY IronLionZion Nov 2022 #19

Tennessee republicans split up the blue district of Nashville four ways Docreed2003 Nov 2022 #20

yes and that district has not sent a Republican to Congress yellowdogintexas Nov 2022 #26

If the District of Columbia had Congressional representation... LeftinOH Nov 2022 #21

Losing the 3 wonderful women running for state Supreme Court because they would have overseen ... Botany Nov 2022 #22

Sadly, you are correct lonely bird Nov 2022 #35

Ryan and the 3 women running for Supreme Court would have won if it wasn't for Nan Whaley's run ... Botany Nov 2022 #39

She really f'd it up for us. Demsrule86 Nov 2022 #49

She was not really running Dayton as its mayor that was done by a city manager, she had never .... Botany Nov 2022 #53

It is stunning to me... lonely bird Nov 2022 #78

Michigan DownriverDem Nov 2022 #23

Why did Black Democratic candidates sue the state then? MichMan Nov 2022 #56

"Fair" redistricting divided Detroit, merging bits with suburban areas, so ... JustABozoOnThisBus Nov 2022 #59

So the countries largest Black majority city no longer has Black representatives MichMan Nov 2022 #63

How can this happen? Well, for example, District 13: ... JustABozoOnThisBus Nov 2022 #65

We had a state supreme court that was mostly Dems. JustABozoOnThisBus Nov 2022 #57

NY was the right decision Polybius Nov 2022 #62

I find it odd... appmanga Nov 2022 #25

Countering the maps Traildogbob Nov 2022 #31

As long as gerrymandering is legal, Elessar Zappa Nov 2022 #33

That is exactly what we need to do. If Ohio can ignore the court so can we in New York...change the Demsrule86 Nov 2022 #48

I agree. I'm only anti-gerrymander if Republicans are too In It to Win It Nov 2022 #50

California has a committee that does it Zeitghost Nov 2022 #66

WI lost Dem. Ron Kinds seat [he did not run but we had a good Dem in place]. riversedge Nov 2022 #34

A real bummer LeftInTX Nov 2022 #76

Ohio governor's SON is on the OH. Supreme Court Marthe48 Nov 2022 #38

People don't realize how our hands are tied. n/t Hope22 Nov 2022 #40

i agree. next time a repug talks of illegal voting - hit them in the face with this samsingh Nov 2022 #42

Talk is cheap...you think they give a damn? We need to fight fire with fire...we gerrymander. Demsrule86 Nov 2022 #46

We will not stop the gerrymandering with this court. Thus we need to gerrymander the fuck Demsrule86 Nov 2022 #45

Cheating eQuals Winning? czarjak Nov 2022 #47

Thugs mostly lost bigly. While they are still pissed, install robotic overlord election masters. usonian Nov 2022 #52

Huh inthewind21 Nov 2022 #55

"Conservative judges deemed their map illegal" Polybius Nov 2022 #58

For me, being a Floridian, that's the most infuriating part that NY has a court that worked In It to Win It Nov 2022 #64

We need to outlaw partisan gerrymandering LetMyPeopleVote Nov 2022 #68

I know....It sucks that it went nowhere.... LeftInTX Nov 2022 #70

I agree Zeitghost Nov 2022 #74

"Conservative judges deemed their map illegal" brooklynite Nov 2022 #72

We have not lost the House...we could still win. Demsrule86 Nov 2022 #77