Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Bernardo de La Paz

(60,320 posts)
28. It was a tool for near-earths, but not the best tool and far from the only tool
Wed Nov 16, 2022, 10:51 AM
Nov 2022

First and foremost, it is good that you are sharing your fears and your funk and I hope this post helps you.

The reason it is not being rebuilt is because there are better tools now, especially for near-earth objects. Back in its heyday, the Arecibo observatory was one of very few tools and it was used to find NEOs. But now, since you follow the news, there are NEOs found every few months that hit the news. They are being found by better more modern tools and more of them are being found than ever back in the heyday.

That's the first false premise, that it was needed.

The second false premise is the idea that devastating NEO impacts are so frequent that it is going to happen in a generation or two. There is a teeny weeny tiny vanishingly small chance one could happen in my lifetime and yours. Multiply that by a dozen generations and the chance is still tiny and vanishingly small. Worth searching for, but teeny tiny.

And the speculation in your second last paragraph is just wrong, unwarranted, unreasonable, not true.

I'm sorry you are feeling this way but you have worked yourself into a state on two false premise. Personally, the science deniers worry me much more, but there I have a strategy that I apply to science deniers and asteroids and earthquakes and pandemics.

It goes like this:

I worry about the things that I might actually be able to do something about and I accept the things that I can't do anything about. If it were me, I would study NEOs, as you have a little bit, learn more. That is something to do. But let go of worrying about it hitting. Maybe keep a bug-out get-out-town kit handy, which is a good idea for earthquakes, forest fires, hurricanes, etc. That is something you can do. But you can't stop an earthquake and you can't personally stop an NEO impact, however unlikely as they are. So let go of worrying about an actual hit.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

I've got a couple of decades on you, and there is a teaching I learned along the way Otto_Harper Nov 2022 #1
The other half is I'm not going to be around anyway. TXPaganBanker Nov 2022 #6
I'm sorry that you are dealing with so much UniqueUserName Nov 2022 #10
F*ck cancer! True Dough Nov 2022 #11
So sorry to hear this TPB. 😞😓😩 Celerity Nov 2022 #16
Very sorry to hear that Meowmee Nov 2022 #20
Aw gee 😟 Raine Nov 2022 #27
Terrible news, so sorry to hear. Enjoy whom and what u love now. AND you still migh beat the odds. electric_blue68 Nov 2022 #30
What Meowmee said. Duppers Nov 2022 #33
But we are not dead yet. UniqueUserName Nov 2022 #2
Wow, you sure are in a funk. Mister Ed Nov 2022 #3
It's from a pair of sources TXPaganBanker Nov 2022 #5
My wish here is to reassure you rather than quarrel with you. Mister Ed Nov 2022 #8
Yet as I watched the NASA channel last night, I heard them talk about future moon flights and BlackSkimmer Nov 2022 #24
The 60 year old radio dish has been superseded marybourg Nov 2022 #4
I'm basing it on statements from the National Science Foundation and NASA... TXPaganBanker Nov 2022 #9
Extinction of our species (and many many others) might very well happen vlyons Nov 2022 #7
What do you think NJCher Nov 2022 #13
I'm not confident that human beings can overcome the greed of the fossil fuel industries vlyons Nov 2022 #15
I know they think that. I read a recent article by a guy who was asked to talk to a group of billionaire ... Hekate Nov 2022 #36
Everyone has exactly the same amount of time -- this moment. Hermit-The-Prog Nov 2022 #12
+1 NJCher Nov 2022 #14
Happy Birthday youngster malaise Nov 2022 #17
Keep on keepin' on. Happy B day. twodogsbarking Nov 2022 #18
This article says nsf Meowmee Nov 2022 #19
Good morning and Happy Birthday Goddessartist Nov 2022 #21
Happy Birthday! It's mine too. I'm 66! LeftInTX Nov 2022 #22
Happy Birthday! BumRushDaShow Nov 2022 #26
I mean, that isn't at all what happened Sympthsical Nov 2022 #23
I crunched many many many WUs of SETI@Home's data from Arecebo BumRushDaShow Nov 2022 #25
It was a tool for near-earths, but not the best tool and far from the only tool Bernardo de La Paz Nov 2022 #28
On the upside BannonsLiver Nov 2022 #29
I think the environmental factors are hurricanes and earthquakes... JHB Nov 2022 #31
Don't get discouraged my friend FakeNoose Nov 2022 #32
In my 70s now & am worried for my 35yo Duppers Nov 2022 #34
I'm sorry.... some DUers might think that you are 'too old' DemocraticPatriot Nov 2022 #35
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Turning 49 today. I've go...»Reply #28