Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Sympthsical

(11,161 posts)
13. One never says never
Thu Mar 9, 2023, 02:23 PM
Mar 2023

However, when employing rhetoric of this kind, I'm going to need some evidence that such a thing is imminently likely.

I do not see evidence that it is likely, nor has any attempt been made to do so outside of rhetoric.

I do pay attention. What I do not do is emotionally invest in narrative nor let rhetoric and media prey upon my limbic system to get me all riled up and an anxiety-ridden, fearful mess. I see Florida. It's a thing. What I found funny this week is something people have been slamming Florida for as "Totally fascism!" was then celebrated when California did it. Like, not a single person made a single comment going, "Wait. Isn't that the same exact thing?" Maybe a lot of perception is being colored by where one is situated politically.

So maybe it's not objectively true that things are going the Hitler route. Maybe - just maybe - the narrative that it is has been deployed in order to keep people in an emotional, politically-useful state.

I cannot predict what will be true in 50 years, but I do know our current times are not "Just like the 1930s!" so I'm going to react to this sort of thing accordingly. Which is usually an eye roll.

As I said, there is work to do, bad policies, ideas, and politics to swat down.

But genocide, no. And it devalues actual genocides that have occurred to throw around the word so cheaply for a bit of rhetorical theater to get the blood pumping.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Hate to be a fellow downer ChicagoRonin Mar 2023 #1
I don't think those incidents are really genocide ITAL Mar 2023 #20
Yes, not the best comparisons ChicagoRonin Mar 2023 #27
I was supposed to be in FEMA camps by 2006. Sympthsical Mar 2023 #2
So why are you convinced that it couldn't happen here? Chainfire Mar 2023 #9
One never says never Sympthsical Mar 2023 #13
The desperation in Weimar treestar Mar 2023 #30
I agree, but one big man-made or natural disaster could change everything. Chainfire Mar 2023 #32
I generally agree with you, Mr.Bill Mar 2023 #33
I understand what you are saying, but lets just spin one scenario that is in the realm of Chainfire Mar 2023 #35
The thing is, the financial disaster Mr.Bill Mar 2023 #36
The point is not the problems it would cause in China, but the problems it would Chainfire Mar 2023 #37
What stands out as a difference between us and 30s Germany Mr.Bill Mar 2023 #34
So you really believe "It Can't Happen Here." Cyrano Mar 2023 #10
People have to know the past in order to learn from it Sympthsical Mar 2023 #14
Interesting word salad Cyrano Mar 2023 #15
Yeah, but mine was more brief Sympthsical Mar 2023 #21
Personally, I have read the history of the first half of the last century extensively. Chainfire Mar 2023 #28
They will use their political power to persecute their enemies.... TheRealNorth Mar 2023 #3
If it was a possibility sarisataka Mar 2023 #4
What's your point? Die in silence??? Cyrano Mar 2023 #11
If I believed I was a member of a group sarisataka Mar 2023 #16
Too late. Being on DU with a star makes you a "THEM." Cyrano Mar 2023 #17
Yes it does sarisataka Mar 2023 #22
Maybe because some of us have already decided.... TheRealNorth Mar 2023 #12
There is a difference between sarisataka Mar 2023 #18
As soon as they can figure out how to get away with it, there will be blood. czarjak Mar 2023 #5
They keep pushing the social boundaries Cosmocat Mar 2023 #23
Genocide is as American as apple pie. HardPort Mar 2023 #6
It's certainly going in that direction now. ananda Mar 2023 #7
Reminds Me NowISeetheLight Mar 2023 #8
Obviously one can never be sure about the future. BlueCheeseAgain Mar 2023 #19
"When do we get to use the guns?" Kid Berwyn Mar 2023 #24
I was in a 200+ post Facebook talk with an uber Catholic about Knowles' eradication speech at CPAC. Efilroft Sul Mar 2023 #25
I have no doubt that if Desantis or Trump got back into power... Initech Mar 2023 #26
sadly i know some folks who would throw the switch without any hesitation dembotoz Mar 2023 #29
No. nt LexVegas Mar 2023 #31
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Is genocide in America's ...»Reply #13