Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Hamlette

(15,556 posts)
22. what?
Wed Mar 22, 2023, 05:31 PM
Mar 2023

you said "There was no "replacement of the word mother"". The article says the document replaced the word "mother" with "birthing person".

In some of the other articles I read to provide you with a source, the reason given by some, like Rep Bush and the article from Harvard, for using the term is to be more inclusive of trans men and non-binary people who give birth, not because of adoption. Birth mom works great for adoption.

I hate to quote a republican but I tend to agree with Ann Romney who said she is not the birthing person of 5 boys, she is their mother.

Maybe in a few decades the term birthing person will take on the same meaning as mother but then what do we call the birthing person who is not the person who raised the child? The adopting person?

I'm just not there on the need for the change and some have made the argument that these kinds of changes dehumanize women.

It's probably old dog new tricks sort of deal with me and I'll come around.

I understand that the right picks BS crap to criticize. It appears that woke might not be working for them yet but you pile on a bunch of outrages and the "not really paying all that much attention to politics" people start to sour. One example for that is Hillary Clinton. We let the right destroy her over complete BS. Not sure what we could have done but it still burns me.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

The problem is that quite a few Americans like the PutinGOP crime syndicate. Irish_Dem Mar 2023 #1
There's another contingent EYESORE 9001 Mar 2023 #2
Sounds like the fable about the curmudgeon who eleased a genie soldierant Mar 2023 #14
Yes that is the point of the GOP demonizing various groups. Irish_Dem Mar 2023 #26
True dat Marcuse Mar 2023 #32
True. But some Americans still love democracy. Funtatlaguy Mar 2023 #3
Only real Americans. James48 Mar 2023 #12
Yes they do. "We The People" or power held by the people, is a basic human right. Irish_Dem Mar 2023 #27
The opportunity for that scenario has always been there with free and fair elections. Boomerproud Mar 2023 #4
Wasn't something along these lines what Susan Sarandon ... Whiskeytide Mar 2023 #5
Susan Sarandon is an idiot. hippywife Mar 2023 #6
I misread the OP in my haste. I thought it was suggesting ... Whiskeytide Mar 2023 #24
I would like to see barbtries Mar 2023 #7
Believe to get and keep a majority rule for us KS Toronado Mar 2023 #8
Love these ideas! ShazzieB Mar 2023 #16
Thanks Shaz, meant to mention "Especially in red states." KS Toronado Mar 2023 #28
Thank you KS...it's unfortunate that great ideas like yours Funtatlaguy Mar 2023 #20
In the 2022 election KS Toronado Mar 2023 #29
birthing person Hamlette Mar 2023 #9
Link? Effete Snob Mar 2023 #11
sorry Hamlette Mar 2023 #17
So, here's the thing Effete Snob Mar 2023 #19
what? Hamlette Mar 2023 #22
No Effete Snob Mar 2023 #23
I prefer the term reproductive unit. efhmc Mar 2023 #35
I think we function best as a country when we have a healthy opposition. Unfortunately that is... NNadir Mar 2023 #10
Futile. Our side lacks messaging that reaches where it is worst needed. lambchopp59 Mar 2023 #13
Ridiculous Wibly Mar 2023 #15
Good points but it only works if there is a LOYAL opposition grantcart Mar 2023 #21
Well, FDR was elected 4 times and had wnylib Mar 2023 #36
You're thinking 1977-78 paleotn Mar 2023 #18
What burns my bacon: Democratic president and small majority in Congress for two years betsuni Mar 2023 #25
It has been said that the GOP today is incapable of governing by design. That they groom, recruit, Ford_Prefect Mar 2023 #30
4 years is just a trip to the store in the car. live love laugh Mar 2023 #31
The US oligarchs would never have it dlk Mar 2023 #33
I literally thirst for the day when one could ..... jaxexpat Mar 2023 #34
As someone posted above, this is precisely what happened in 1932. thucythucy Mar 2023 #37
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Just once I'd love a medi...»Reply #22