Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

jmowreader

(53,326 posts)
13. Eight problems come immediately to mind
Tue Jun 6, 2023, 01:03 PM
Jun 2023

First, what aircraft are you going to put this on? Boeing 737s and single-aisle Airbuses don’t have enough room between the floor and ceiling to hold this. A Boeing 777 or an A350 will hold it, but those jets already have enough seats.

Second problem: maximum takeoff weight. Anything that flies has one. This thing looks extremely heavy, you’ve got to fill it with people to make buying it worthwhile, and all those people have luggage.

Problem 2a: most of the people in this problem have carry-on luggage on normal aircraft. This seating plan ensures everyone’s going to have to check all their bags, so airports’ baggage handling systems will become even more overloaded than they already are.

Problem 3: cargo holds on most planes aren’t big enough to deal with this.

Problem 4: airlines make a lot of their profit hauling cargo. A half-full flight can still be profitable if you’ve got the cargo to make up for it. With the cargo holds full of passenger bags, there won’t be any room for that.

Problem 5: load factors. If you have a route that regularly fills 325 seats, do you want to fly it in a plane that used to hold 200…or do you want to fly it in a 777 and have all that extra room in the holds for cargo? Yeah, that’s what I thought. Alternately, do you want to remove a flight per day from your schedule so you can fill this plane…and have even less room for cargo?

Problem 6: exploding pax. Dude, airliners don’t have enough lavatories NOW! Stuff a bunch of extra passengers on a plane with one latrine at the front and one at the back and you’re really going to have problems.

Problem 7: customer satisfaction. This guarantees there will be even less than there is now.

Problem 8: what happens when you hit a patch of turbulence and half the passengers smack their faces against the backs of the seats in front of them?

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

And immediately back into mothballs it should/will go. Tommy Carcetti Jun 2023 #1
Mooooooo! roamer65 Jun 2023 #2
You get what you pay for jimfields33 Jun 2023 #6
39 dollars is one thing. Marius25 Jun 2023 #22
I'm not even going to speak aloud my first thought upon seeing that pic. BlackSkimmer Jun 2023 #3
I bet it was my first thought too and I'm embarrassed! Raven Jun 2023 #8
Lol! BlackSkimmer Jun 2023 #39
I'll say it: TxGuitar Jun 2023 #49
Great minds think alike. :-) Raven Jun 2023 #51
Yep. Better hope that the guy in front of you didn't have atomic bean burritos for lunch Trailrider1951 Jun 2023 #52
Which means they will charge more for it. Solomon Jun 2023 #64
Stacked ass to face lame54 Jun 2023 #4
Does face get a discount? sarcasmo Jun 2023 #16
Just hope the person in front of you doesn't have gas Yo_Mama_Been_Loggin Jun 2023 #23
Airport Taco Bell NowISeetheLight Jun 2023 #25
Airport Taco Hell Hekate Jun 2023 #40
1st and 2nd class ... definitely UpInArms Jun 2023 #5
I'd take it for the leg room! Dreading a cross-county moonscape Jun 2023 #31
No way! Sogo Jun 2023 #7
Nope! mentalsolstice Jun 2023 #9
Zero recline in at least the lower seats. Ms. Toad Jun 2023 #10
Who doesn't love a fart directly in their face? zappaman Jun 2023 #11
depends in the "brand" waddirum Jun 2023 #43
I am sorry to be gross MuseRider Jun 2023 #12
Eight problems come immediately to mind jmowreader Jun 2023 #13
Problem 9: Safe ingress and egress to/from the upper seats. KY_EnviroGuy Jun 2023 #33
Agree With Everything You Wrote ProfessorGAC Jun 2023 #34
It's also going to be hard to get into the bottom seats jmowreader Jun 2023 #44
Jmow and KYEnviro -- excellent analysis Hekate Jun 2023 #46
Still beats the new AA seats which seem to be made for 5'5" people JCMach1 Jun 2023 #59
I will NEVER again take AA overseas DFW Jun 2023 #65
Exactly, DFW as well soooo ... Will just take a muscle relaxant JCMach1 Jun 2023 #66
Since they pulled their nasty little stunt on us in 2021 DFW Jun 2023 #68
Airlines will never be happy until they can stack passengers like cord wood and palletize them. FSogol Jun 2023 #14
What you said Hekate Jun 2023 #45
Only dogs seeking to sniff the butt of others would find this appealing... hlthe2b Jun 2023 #15
There is another plan in the works, it looks something like this: Chainfire Jun 2023 #17
Good visual -- and it stinks pretty quick Hekate Jun 2023 #47
Farting in your face....How wonderful. spanone Jun 2023 #18
I'm tall. If I was unfortunate enough to be The Unmitigated Gall Jun 2023 #19
No first class anymore? Yonnie3 Jun 2023 #20
Nooooooooooooooope. Initech Jun 2023 #21
Easier to make everyone lie down and pack them together like sardines - in two layers dalton99a Jun 2023 #24
Standup Airline Seat NowISeetheLight Jun 2023 #26
I was going to mention the saddle seats newdayneeded Jun 2023 #37
I thought the OP might be a rerun of that gem. But no, it's a whole new fresh hell. Hekate Jun 2023 #48
Gas or Worse NowISeetheLight Jun 2023 #50
Another young girl used treestar Jun 2023 #62
Not only no, but HELL NO! 3catwoman3 Jun 2023 #27
Airlines respond to incentives like any other business Shrek Jun 2023 #28
I can't imagine that those seats would pass FAA certification, or that Ocelot II Jun 2023 #29
+1 maybe these ideas are treestar Jun 2023 #63
I actually like it, lower seats you can stretch your legs all the way out Snooper9 Jun 2023 #30
Wow. What an opportunity to have a stranger's butt in your face for 9 hours. sinkingfeeling Jun 2023 #32
No. Just no. How does one even get in the top seat? brush Jun 2023 #35
Spilled liquids, falling objects, and a range of vision no more than one foot. taxi Jun 2023 #36
Does the top deck pay extra for the ability to put their seat back? At least there will no more ... marble falls Jun 2023 #38
Why stop at two levels? Earth-shine Jun 2023 #41
What happens if you have to pee? SYFROYH Jun 2023 #42
The fart-smeller seats should be free. Talitha Jun 2023 #53
I showed this to my retired pilot husband. 3catwoman3 Jun 2023 #54
The people that designed this forgot to take one very important thing into consideration. Angleae Jun 2023 #55
That looks safe. LudwigPastorius Jun 2023 #56
this man must be stopped ZonkerHarris Jun 2023 #57
Many Americans are just too big for that kind of thing GenThePerservering Jun 2023 #58
No thanks! Emile Jun 2023 #60
I would go berserk and starting screaming sitting in a flying cattle car Raine Jun 2023 #61
Hope they instal charcoal fart filters. Hassin Bin Sober Jun 2023 #67
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»The double-decker airplan...»Reply #13