Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
General Discussion
Showing Original Post only (View all)Who died and made the Supreme Court a Congress? [View all]
Who died and made the Supreme Court a Congress?June 24 marked one year since the Supreme Court, in the landmark Dobbs case, overturned Roe v. Wade, shockingly reversing almost 50 years of precedent to strip away what had been a constitutional right to an abortion.
You see, the conservative justices in the majority of that 5-4 decision argued the Roe decision was egregiously wrong because the Constitution never mentioned abortion. That meant, the justices said, abortion couldnt possibly be a constitutional right and must be left to the states.
Doing anything else would amount to activist judges making things up, or as the phrase goes, legislating from the bench. To hear Republicans talk, thats pretty much the worst thing a federal judge could do.
Its one of Republicans' longest-running talking points: Dont legislate from the bench.
Now that Republican appointees are a supermajority on the Supreme Court, you would think that this majority would steer clear of anything that might look like it was writing laws and thereby undermining the peoples representatives in Congress.
But youd be wrong.
Todays conservative justices are happily imposing their reactionary legislative vision on America, not just by interpreting laws, but by effectively rewriting them, in order to implement unpopular policies that could never get passed through Congress. Separation of powers be damned.
You see, the conservative justices in the majority of that 5-4 decision argued the Roe decision was egregiously wrong because the Constitution never mentioned abortion. That meant, the justices said, abortion couldnt possibly be a constitutional right and must be left to the states.
Doing anything else would amount to activist judges making things up, or as the phrase goes, legislating from the bench. To hear Republicans talk, thats pretty much the worst thing a federal judge could do.
Its one of Republicans' longest-running talking points: Dont legislate from the bench.
Now that Republican appointees are a supermajority on the Supreme Court, you would think that this majority would steer clear of anything that might look like it was writing laws and thereby undermining the peoples representatives in Congress.
But youd be wrong.
Todays conservative justices are happily imposing their reactionary legislative vision on America, not just by interpreting laws, but by effectively rewriting them, in order to implement unpopular policies that could never get passed through Congress. Separation of powers be damned.
48 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
What bothers me most is that the states have taken away the right to medical abortions
MiniMe
Jul 2023
#5
Mental & physical health of the mother was taken into account, as well as rape & incest...
Hekate
Jul 2023
#29
I recall reading an article where John McCain said something to that effect also
In It to Win It
Jul 2023
#19
I believe the SC has set some dangerous precedents with recent decisions--precedents that will
Lonestarblue
Jul 2023
#33
SCOTUS needs a complete overhaul on how judges are chosen and how long they serve.
cstanleytech
Jul 2023
#34