Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

harumph

(3,286 posts)
56. In post #29 Ms. Toad states:
Sun Aug 6, 2023, 12:19 PM
Aug 2023

"...as much as I hate the concept of him becoming president again - if he actually wins and we prevent him from taking office by unlawful means, we are just like him." which I disagree with for reasons already stated.

Firstly, implicit in the foregoing statement is the assumption that a Trump "win" would be legitimate - meaning a majority of the electoral count - without significant (e.g., enough to sway election) interference by the right wing officials and apparatchiks. That must be the interpretation - no? Otherwise, the statement implies that we merely accept a Trump win as legitimate even when right wing officials throw out legitimately cast Democratic votes. Just because you know.

Second, what you interpret as being rude is merely asking the essential question of whether there is any circumstance under which resistance would be reasonable when given an unlawfully elected executive wielding power in such a way as to cement a permanent minority rule.

Third, when you initially accused me of being rude it was my response to William769 post #37 wherein William769 stated: "I believe in the rule of law and that will never change. If you don't then shame on you." Shame on me indeed. Implicit is the suggestion that I don't believe in the rule of law and I should be ashamed. All this assumes that a Trump win would be necessarily legitimate. Yet I have already provided concrete examples that would call into question a Trump victory by illegitimate means. What then?

At the end of the day and much to the consternation of our local legal professionals, adherence to law depends on its credibility. Credibility comes BEFORE the law. Law drafters need to have a provenance of legitimacy. If government is seen by the people to institute laws that make a mockery of fairness, those laws will be considered no law at all. This is a recognizable concept (Aquinas, MLK). A concept rightfully scary to legal professionals who are smart people and have worked very diligently learning to apply and argue the law. If the laws become meaningless, what is there to argue?

I submit our "legal system" that is so revered and which is frequently pointed to as '...the best looking horse in the glue factory' is showing its age. The OP is correct that our condition is preposterous. I take him at his word that he served in the military as have members of my immediate family and maybe just maybe we get something that others don't. Perhaps we will dodge this bullet of Trump and the experience of having to dodge will prompt new laws/guardrails to inoculate our country from fascism. However, I'm not optimistic as the right wing has already stated repeatedly and on the record that they are willing to construct new laws simply to their advantage - their position may be summarized as "fuck ya'll." Power. Power. Power. And their "laws" to paper over deprivations. What about non-violent demonstration? Don't be surprised if a new Trump admin simply authorizes martial law and you get shot for peacefully demonstrating.

Respectfully, your allegations that I'm being rude are false, unsupported by my comments, and a needless distraction from the content of my posts and others in the thread.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

No, he won't. But the media need the clicks leftstreet Aug 2023 #1
Absolutely and I will see you and raise you. Prairie_Seagull Aug 2023 #19
Well sure. He was a cash cow. leftstreet Aug 2023 #25
so the media is grifting Conjuay Aug 2023 #26
Yes - that does indeed make you just like him FBaggins Aug 2023 #2
Exactly... WarGamer Aug 2023 #20
Agreed. Ms. Toad Aug 2023 #29
Worse FBaggins Aug 2023 #31
You are WRONG LetMyPeopleVote Aug 2023 #3
He is not saying that he will not win the election DontBelieveEastisEas Aug 2023 #7
Maxrandb is not a troll. Elessar Zappa Aug 2023 #17
That has been my impression as well FBaggins Aug 2023 #22
It came out yesterday that Cornell West owes over a half million in back taxes... brush Aug 2023 #9
Jill Stein met with Putin and still hurt Clinton in 2016 LetMyPeopleVote Aug 2023 #11
West still bares watching as who knows who he's conspiring behind the scenes. brush Aug 2023 #12
What neutralizes him even more is his abrasive personality ExWhoDoesntCare Aug 2023 #77
This seems like an extremist point of view, or TROLLing? DontBelieveEastisEas Aug 2023 #4
Keepin it 100! InAbLuEsTaTe Aug 2023 #5
If he were to become president, the US would likely be in such a perpetual state of chaos RKP5637 Aug 2023 #6
Exactly! And No, I am not a troll maxrandb Aug 2023 #27
The founders never entertained IMO such a beast as Trump coming along as a president, and much RKP5637 Aug 2023 #28
That is exactly what the MAGA crowd believed about Biden. Ms. Toad Aug 2023 #30
kooky DontBelieveEastisEas Aug 2023 #36
Dude, you're all over this thread insulting the OP. BlackSkimmer Aug 2023 #38
It's the rules, calling the post kooky, not the poster. DontBelieveEastisEas Aug 2023 #65
Lol, so you changed the post where you called another DUer a troll? BlackSkimmer Aug 2023 #71
an interesting academic question. harumph Aug 2023 #45
You can't answer that without context maxrandb Aug 2023 #54
Those are not hypothetical - Ms. Toad Aug 2023 #62
If you think what MAGA Dipshits think of Biden, is anywhere remotely the same maxrandb Aug 2023 #53
Goodness gracious, what a thread! BlackSkimmer Aug 2023 #57
I eddited my 'TROLL' headline DontBelieveEastisEas Aug 2023 #68
Using how you feel about someone to justify an insurrection is the same illegal act Ms. Toad Aug 2023 #63
But it's NOT just "feelings" maxrandb Aug 2023 #81
Not the point. Ms. Toad Aug 2023 #82
Please read my post again maxrandb Aug 2023 #86
Read your OP again Ms. Toad Aug 2023 #87
And virtually called for Civil War DontBelieveEastisEas Aug 2023 #89
Agreed. Ms. Toad Aug 2023 #90
Yes, I knew you were being concise DontBelieveEastisEas Aug 2023 #91
No it doesn't maxrandb Aug 2023 #93
Declaring martial law for the purpose of using military force to remain in office Ms. Toad Aug 2023 #94
This message was self-deleted by its author B.See Aug 2023 #33
DeSantis is desperately counting on Trump not being able to run. keithbvadu2 Aug 2023 #8
There are things I would like to say, grumpyduck Aug 2023 #10
Good rant. I believe we outnumber the trumper cult...meaning Democrats.... brush Aug 2023 #13
Unrest DontBelieveEastisEas Aug 2023 #14
I'll go with you on the large cities, in red state too. Some pols also. Newsom in California... brush Aug 2023 #16
I and millions of others thought the same in 2016. Do agree it's unlikely. Silent Type Aug 2023 #15
'eking' not 'eeking' 0rganism Aug 2023 #18
I think it's hard not to think these are like past times when things were hard but mostly rational. Prairie_Seagull Aug 2023 #21
Setting all the other silliness aside, he's not going to president because he's not going to win. BannonsLiver Aug 2023 #23
Fatso needs to be brought in front of the court of public opinion. BlueIdaho Aug 2023 #24
So you believe in insurrection? former9thward Aug 2023 #32
What is to "believe in insurrection?" harumph Aug 2023 #50
Read OP again. DontBelieveEastisEas Aug 2023 #66
While I absolutely agree with your characterization of MAGA'S Antichrist... B.See Aug 2023 #34
Do NOT become complacent GenThePerservering Aug 2023 #35
I believe in the rule of law and that will never change. William769 Aug 2023 #37
Yeah, 1933- 39, German laws were made that Jews report and be counted. harumph Aug 2023 #40
Oh for fuck sake William769 Aug 2023 #41
You're incredibly naive if you don't think once harumph Aug 2023 #42
The naysayers in this thread criticizing the OP harumph Aug 2023 #43
Well, your estimation would be wrong. BlackSkimmer Aug 2023 #44
When some posters imply that harumph Aug 2023 #47
No, you really are being insulting muriel_volestrangler Aug 2023 #49
I don't agree. harumph Aug 2023 #51
You're not just infantilizing the commentators of the thread, you're distorting their words muriel_volestrangler Aug 2023 #55
In post #29 Ms. Toad states: harumph Aug 2023 #56
Your post #43 was incredibly rude muriel_volestrangler Aug 2023 #59
+1000 BlackSkimmer Aug 2023 #61
I stand for mankind DontBelieveEastisEas Aug 2023 #75
This message was self-deleted by its author DontBelieveEastisEas Aug 2023 #76
"Frankly Bullshit" eh... harumph Aug 2023 #73
Wow, if you think for one second that being part of a "traditionally disadvantaged" group as William BlackSkimmer Aug 2023 #80
Red herring. harumph Aug 2023 #85
So you're saying that DUers shouldn't even stand up against slurs aimed at fellow DUers? muriel_volestrangler Aug 2023 #98
It seems pretty obvious what a couple of posters are up to here. BlackSkimmer Aug 2023 #99
Thank you. BlackSkimmer Aug 2023 #60
I think this is the problem maxrandb Aug 2023 #95
The OP will stand on saying the election of trump demands civil war. DontBelieveEastisEas Aug 2023 #67
You're saying that if you insult trump, you've already lost the arg DontBelieveEastisEas Aug 2023 #64
I am a Gay man that lives in the State of Florida. Yea I'm so privileged. William769 Aug 2023 #46
So, you cannot be (part) of a privileged group harumph Aug 2023 #48
I'm guessing you're not gay, are you? BlackSkimmer Aug 2023 #58
The ones that agree with the OP DontBelieveEastisEas Aug 2023 #69
They're war types ExWhoDoesntCare Aug 2023 #78
Six week MorbidButterflyTat Aug 2023 #72
You are looking at absolutes. William769 Aug 2023 #97
This post speaks to the asymmetry of the democratic and republican mindsets. harumph Aug 2023 #39
If the repugs take power no matter who it is, democracy will die and the christian nutjobs will rule Hotler Aug 2023 #52
I'll pass. stuck in the middle Aug 2023 #70
"He is an absolute MorbidButterflyTat Aug 2023 #74
I've gone back to this b/c my comments were highjacked (IMO) downthread harumph Aug 2023 #79
I can't tell who's replying to who, above. stuck in the middle Aug 2023 #88
Now that your rant in finished... brooklynite Aug 2023 #83
And there it is. BlackSkimmer Aug 2023 #100
The media needs to stop RANDYWILDMAN Aug 2023 #84
In the ForgedCrank Aug 2023 #92
Trump belongs in an insane asylum! If he gets re-elected, there will be no rule of law anymore. He liberal_mama Aug 2023 #96
Uh, no. Patton French Aug 2023 #101
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Everyone needs to stop pr...»Reply #56