Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Irish_Dem

(81,988 posts)
19. Large groups of scientists have PR teams who write the press releases.
Thu Oct 5, 2023, 10:21 AM
Oct 2023

Most people don't understand that most PhD scientists are incapable
of writing so that normal people can understand them.

In large science agencies, institutions, universities, etc., the scientists
hand over their material to a PR team who translates the dry, pedantic, academic
word salad into something comprehensible and interesting to lay people.

When I was working on my PhD at a large research university, we were trained
to write in a very academic, highly stylized, very technical way.

Professors every now and then, would aggravate the crap out of us us by ordering us
to write an Aunt Fanny report or article. This was something your Aunt Fanny could understand,
and of course it was the hardest thing in the world to write.

When you read about something a university scientist has discovered, that scientist was
required to hand their material over to the university PR department. In fact, at my university all PhD
dissertations had to be automatically handed over to the University PR department. They went through
all dissertations, God help them, to determine if anything should go out to the popular press.

We always got a kick out of how the material was twisted and changed for public viewing.
A friend of mine had an interesting dissertation and it hit the popular press and she got a real kick
at what the PR department had done with it. We all kidded her about it.

Later when I wrote psych reports to courts, probation departments, attorneys, physicians, I always
had to translate the my findings into something they could understand.

So when we see all these press reports from climate change scientists about being stunned and shocked we
know it is all disingenuous. 100% certain scientists are not surprised in the least by what
is happening, they have been warning us for decades. And scientists don't talk this way about their emotionally
when making a report. This is all the PR team.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Terrifying. femmedem Oct 2023 #1
Perhaps exactly as planned by groups such as the Competitive Enterprise Institute and their ilk? yonder Oct 2023 #17
Post removed Post removed Oct 2023 #26
Much longer than you will here. NewHendoLib Oct 2023 #27
Hello edbermac Oct 2023 #28
"Scientists stunned" Effete Snob Oct 2023 #2
Word! Atreus Oct 2023 #5
Word? Bird is the word. :) spike jones Oct 2023 #8
my grandson said I should apologize for posting this. spike jones Oct 2023 #15
...I've heard! Atreus Oct 2023 #24
Thanks for that. I will be sure my grandson watches it. Grandpa could be cool again. spike jones Oct 2023 #25
I came to post the same thing. Scientists are not stunned at the temperatures. Irish_Dem Oct 2023 #6
You get it-too bad most can't see what is in front of their face Stargazer99 Oct 2023 #10
Large groups of scientists have PR teams who write the press releases. Irish_Dem Oct 2023 #19
Exactly! mountain grammy Oct 2023 #14
While I generally agree with you about science reporting BS... Silent3 Oct 2023 #22
Was expected LiberaBlueDem Oct 2023 #3
I can speak for my island malaise Oct 2023 #4
Those "Stop Global Whining" bumper stickers from the 90's were quaint. czarjak Oct 2023 #7
Carbon burning for energy is outdated and antiquated Farmer-Rick Oct 2023 #9
At last some one who can see through conservative crap Stargazer99 Oct 2023 #11
A calamity is already upon us Johnny2X2X Oct 2023 #12
When the population of the planet increases it creates more pollution LiberalFighter Oct 2023 #13
Not at all surprised.. mountain grammy Oct 2023 #16
My take on this ... it's the fault of the Guardian FakeNoose Oct 2023 #18
Tiny Tim knew it 50 years ago. spike jones Oct 2023 #20
Don't believe a word of it.. Permanut Oct 2023 #21
About a year ago, also from the Guardian. Prairie_Seagull Oct 2023 #23
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»'Gobsmackingly bananas': ...»Reply #19