Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

jmowreader

(53,271 posts)
45. What my response would be
Wed Dec 20, 2023, 06:15 PM
Dec 2023

Fm: (name), Director, Seattle Children's Hospital
To: The Honorable Ken Paxton, Attorney General of the State of Texas
Subj: Your recent demand for patient records

1. I shall start this letter with a definition: jurisdiction, n. the authority given by law to a court to try cases and rule on legal matters within a particular geographic area and/or over certain types of legal cases. It is vital to determine before a lawsuit is filed which court has jurisdiction. State courts have jurisdiction over matters within that state...

2. Seattle Children's Hospital is a nonprofit corporation operating primarily within the State of Washington, with a number of locations. Our Hospital Campus is located at 4800 Sand Point Way NE, Seattle. This campus also houses our Emergency Department and an Urgent Care Clinic. We have Urgent Care Clinics in Bellevue, Everett and Federal Way, all cities in the Seattle metropolitan area. We have two Odessa Brown Children's Clinics in Seattle, one of which we will proudly open in 2024. We possess general medical clinics in the Seattle area and in two cities in Central Washington, those being Kennewick and Wenatchee. We own three out-of-state clinics, all specializing in Pediatric Cardiology. One of them is in Anchorage, Alaska; the other two are in the Montana cities of Bozeman and Great Falls. Please note that Seattle Children's Hospital does not maintain any sort of business presence in the State of Texas. Texas is blessed with many very fine children's hospitals.

3. Because Seattle Children's Hospital does not and will not operate within the State of Texas, Seattle Children's Hospital does not fall into the jurisdiction of your office. Therefore, we will not provide you with any of the information you have demanded.

4. Seattle Children's Hospital's general counsel advises that if you intend to pursue this matter further you should retain a competent attorney as she believes you don't have one.

Regards and best wishes.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

I assume the Seattle hospital will mention HIPAA Ocelot II Dec 2023 #1
HIPAA does not cover government investigations FreeState Dec 2023 #36
Don't see that any of those qualify. LiberalFighter Dec 2023 #38
It applies under at least two of those FreeState Dec 2023 #42
Appeal NowISeetheLight Dec 2023 #54
Are We Sure That Applies? ProfessorGAC Dec 2023 #40
Fuck off, fascists is what I'd say ArkansasDemocrat1 Dec 2023 #37
Repukes...keeping government small and out of your lives. n/t The Unmitigated Gall Dec 2023 #2
and they are the first ones to scream gvt interferance . AllaN01Bear Dec 2023 #25
Counter demand SarahD Dec 2023 #3
Seattle Children's maxsolomon Dec 2023 #4
They are under no obligation to comply. As a matter of fact, they would be breaking the law. LeftInTX Dec 2023 #12
Oh good! ShazzieB Dec 2023 #28
This is just a fishing expedition to satisfy the bible beaters. sop Dec 2023 #47
Do they have a specific individual that they're looking for here ? CincyDem Dec 2023 #5
Fuck off, assholes. grumpyduck Dec 2023 #6
Can the American Pediatric Association or the American Endocrine Association sue Maraya1969 Dec 2023 #7
Tell Texas to sit on it. republianmushroom Dec 2023 #8
And rotate. grumpyduck Dec 2023 #9
HIPPA? MOMFUDSKI Dec 2023 #10
it's HIPAA Skittles Dec 2023 #57
Now it's just getting comical kwolf68 Dec 2023 #11
It's not even HIPAA. It's the Medical Practice Act of one state versus another state. LeftInTX Dec 2023 #14
Well now, maybe ALL the republicons in Texas should send ALL their medical records to Washington state bluestarone Dec 2023 #13
Hey Texas montanacowboy Dec 2023 #15
Damn skippy! Aristus Dec 2023 #52
wasshington should pass a law that makes it a crime for another state ag to ask for records moonshinegnomie Dec 2023 #16
Hey Texass, Sal_NV Dec 2023 #17
HIPAA doesn't seem to apply here, but it's still a shitty request WhiskeyGrinder Dec 2023 #18
This must be absolutely terrifying for parents of transgender kids. Incanus Dec 2023 #19
That's probably the point. To terrify. chowder66 Dec 2023 #27
Agreed. And it feeds their base who can only thrive on hatred. Incanus Dec 2023 #32
They are literally acting Mr.Bill Dec 2023 #20
Agree 100. But they aren't really acting are they. twodogsbarking Dec 2023 #21
Hopefully every hospital in the country will use a standard response: mn9driver Dec 2023 #22
HIPAA anyone? barbtries Dec 2023 #23
texas has no juristition there . AllaN01Bear Dec 2023 #24
No jurisdiction over the US-Mexico border either DBoon Dec 2023 #30
The records request will be refused. LeftInTX Dec 2023 #53
I'm sure the hospital will tell Paxton where to stick his morbid religious scruples Warpy Dec 2023 #26
Rest assured, they will start going after women who have out of state abortions in the same way. kysrsoze Dec 2023 #29
Wouldn't that be child abuse? Butterflylady Dec 2023 #31
The none-too-subtle sadistic undertones of these TX laws are being ignored. bucolic_frolic Dec 2023 #33
Sounds like one huge HIPPA violation in the making. Ford_Prefect Dec 2023 #34
HIPAA does not apply to government investigations FreeState Dec 2023 #39
Don't make the lede so mundane ArkansasDemocrat1 Dec 2023 #35
Fuck Q Anon, Infowars, Fox News, OAN, Newsmax, and AM radio. Initech Dec 2023 #41
OK, Kenny, let me get that for you JoseBalow Dec 2023 #43
The government of the state of Texas seems... dchill Dec 2023 #44
What my response would be jmowreader Dec 2023 #45
to many words I edited it down moonshinegnomie Dec 2023 #48
That's a little more succinct, and gets you to the same place. jmowreader Dec 2023 #50
Fuck that shithole masquerading as a state dalton99a Dec 2023 #46
"I want to be able to day people basic things." -Paxton sakabatou Dec 2023 #49
Dear Texas, Aristus Dec 2023 #51
They're asking for personal medical files for minors. Deuxcents Dec 2023 #55
Or send them redacted records and charge TX $10,000/page and shipping and handling fees. Freethinker65 Dec 2023 #56
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Texas is demanding gender...»Reply #45