General Discussion

revmclaren

(2,613 posts)

126. Tuesday morning Kick.

Reply to madaboutharry (Original post)

Tue Jan 2, 2024, 08:57 AM

Jan 2024

Let's keep this important thread going. 🕍

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

127 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

Released Hostage Mia Schem has something to say. [View all] madaboutharry Dec 2023 OP

I won't criticize her and hope she gets help to heal... hlthe2b Dec 2023 #1

She was transferred from family to family to family repeatedly. Same thing, always. Why do you doubt her experience? Hekate Dec 2023 #7

I do not doubt her experience as I very clearly said. I doubt the ability to extrapolate to an entire hlthe2b Dec 2023 #13

Can you cut and paste where she discusses being transferred from family to family, please? Ms. Toad Dec 2023 #16

Here you go. ShazzieB Dec 2023 #23

Via ambulance to boot NickB79 Dec 2023 #26

It does say she was moved from home to home, Ms. Toad Dec 2023 #29

It seems to me, you are seeking reasons to doubt her story. I don't doubt it. Why would she lie? Demsrule86 Dec 2023 #77

I have not disputed a single fact attributed to her in the article. Ms. Toad Dec 2023 #98

She also states that everyone are terrorists forthemiddle Dec 2023 #90

Unless she has met every Palestinian, that is feeling - not fact. Ms. Toad Dec 2023 #97

Here with additional paragraphs . Read it again in the middle question everything Dec 2023 #25

I'm not contesting anything she actually said. Ms. Toad Dec 2023 #32

I think most see this as her story to tell. madaboutharry Dec 2023 #22

I would be kicked off DU if I said what I wanted to say right here. TomDaisy Dec 2023 #38

Well Thanks for Kicking the Thread. Cha Dec 2023 #54

Post removed Post removed Dec 2023 #100

Post removed Post removed Dec 2023 #45

Given I have actually worked in the Middle East, I don't need that from you. hlthe2b Dec 2023 #73

Why don't we see or hear people protesting Hamas there ? JI7 Dec 2023 #61

First, it's hard to stage a protest when bombs are falling. intheflow Dec 2023 #75

bombs weren't falling on oct 7 JI7 Dec 2023 #78

No, but that's not what I was replying to. intheflow Dec 2023 #108

They weren't protesting on Oct 7 or anytime before JI7 Dec 2023 #109

I don't expect that JustAnotherGen Dec 2023 #89

There is little doubt there is support for Hamas in Gaza... Demsrule86 Dec 2023 #76

Thank you for holding back your criticism of the victim. egduj Dec 2023 #113

It is so generous of you to refrain from criticizing her! TheKentuckian Dec 2023 #116

What is your motivation in misrepresenting my posts? Seriously? What? hlthe2b Dec 2023 #117

This is very true. But it's telling that not one person in this family or any of her captors showed her any humanity. Beakybird Dec 2023 #2

That tells me everything that I need to know about the "resistance". SoFlaBro Dec 2023 #12

I won't believe that an 8 year old or younger isn't innocent RandomNumbers Dec 2023 #3

What about 9 year olds and older? Is it OK to treat them the same as combatants and blow them up? David__77 Dec 2023 #6

Why don't you write letters to all the hostages. madaboutharry Dec 2023 #18

The question was posed as intended. We can say, if we choose, "no, we don't agree that babies in Gaza are terrorists". David__77 Dec 2023 #20

No one here is saying that babies are terrorists. madaboutharry Dec 2023 #27

are you telling her what to say? is she required to say what you demand? TomDaisy Dec 2023 #41

Seriously? madaboutharry Dec 2023 #43

You'll find that when you stamp your feet and yell and demand other people TomDaisy Dec 2023 #44

That is not what I wrote. madaboutharry Dec 2023 #47

Post removed Post removed Dec 2023 #99

No One Is Required To Answer, Sir The Magistrate Dec 2023 #101

are we going to go through this again TomDaisy Dec 2023 #40

Go through what again? Cha Dec 2023 #56

Think. Abolishinist Dec 2023 #63

Intriguing Hekate Dec 2023 #102

... lapucelle Dec 2023 #103

What are we going through again? MarineCombatEngineer Dec 2023 #57

This Is Bullshit, Sir, And I Expect You Know It The Magistrate Dec 2023 #42

Damn, that's some good shit right there Beetwasher. Dec 2023 #60

These are ForgedCrank Dec 2023 #64

I just picked 8 years old as an arbitrary point, that (hopefully) EVERYONE would agree on RandomNumbers Dec 2023 #87

I wonder how much duress the family was feeling. Like drug cartels taking over neighborhoods in Mexico for example. cbabe Dec 2023 #4

They starved her. madaboutharry Dec 2023 #10

Comment 15 cbabe Dec 2023 #24

My post is in response to your post madaboutharry Dec 2023 #30

Nope. I simply asked a question. Bye now. cbabe Dec 2023 #31

So you agree w/her... NotVeryImportant Dec 2023 #62

This is Mia Schem's story, not mine. madaboutharry Dec 2023 #65

clearly not every Gazan is Hamas, or Hamas supporters ... stopdiggin Dec 2023 #5

Vanishing very few have any desire to look through the eyes of the Gazan. PTL_Mancuso Dec 2023 #8

Systematically screwed by the Egyptians & other Muslim nations, you mean? Pawns since 1948... Hekate Dec 2023 #11

Anyone doing the dehumanizing is at fault here! PTL_Mancuso Dec 2023 #37

Hamas, Dear, Has Done A Wonderful Job Of 'Dehumanizing' Palestinians The Magistrate Dec 2023 #71

Thank you, Sir Hekate Dec 2023 #105

The Sadistic Butchers of HAMAS are the ONES That Cha Dec 2023 #114

I would agree stopdiggin Dec 2023 #21

The leaders of Hamas are billionaires NickB79 Dec 2023 #28

"you will see that they have been systematically FU&*ed over time and time again." EX500rider Dec 2023 #112

Recommend that the doubters of this young woman read the whole damn article & interview at link Hekate Dec 2023 #9

You are misinterpreting what others are saying. They are not doubting her statements. hlthe2b Dec 2023 #15

Clarified indeed. I feel like I can look through the "just asking questions" & the "whatabouts" & "bothsides " Hekate Dec 2023 #36

You accuse fellow Duers who express concern for both the hostages and Gazan children of being hlthe2b Dec 2023 #74

The question is, why would clarifying this fact be warranted in response to an emotional testimony of a victim? Beastly Boy Dec 2023 #39

I don't agree that babies in Gaza are terrorists. David__77 Dec 2023 #17

Strawman. Nowhere does the hostage say "babies in Gaza are terrorists." emulatorloo Dec 2023 #33

Direct quote: RandomNumbers Dec 2023 #93

Believe Women Deep State Witch Dec 2023 #86

what an important story and obviously a horrible ordeal LymphocyteLover Dec 2023 #14

I can't begin to imagine the psychological trauma COL Mustard Dec 2023 #19

What you permit you promote JustAnotherGen Dec 2023 #34

yup, the propaganda being spread by Hamas and their filthy supporters when some hostages were released JI7 Dec 2023 #59

They are terrorists JustAnotherGen Dec 2023 #88

K&R betsuni Dec 2023 #35

Yeah let's cut the bullshit here ....What Mia Schem said. GuppyGal Dec 2023 #46

She's right. Cut the fucking shit. These demonstrations are now dancing at the 9/11 Memorial. Shit behavior. Done w/them SoFlaBro Dec 2023 #82

You think every civilian in Gaza is a terrorist? Oneironaut Dec 2023 #92

"Everything we do is justified" -Hamas sarisataka Dec 2023 #48

Fuck NO, Medieval Mutilatinig Savage Beasts.. Cha Dec 2023 #67

By any means neccessary sarisataka Dec 2023 #68

Yeah, Well IDF says Cha Dec 2023 #69

Such a horrendous ordeal and probably many revmclaren Dec 2023 #49

This thread. Wow. nt LexVegas Dec 2023 #50

I know...wow indeed. revmclaren Dec 2023 #53

Yes, I saw more sympathy for the one that accused Biden . I forgot her name but I think she JI7 Dec 2023 #58

Tara Reade, yes, she had a lot of support. Chris Hayes, The Young Turks, etc. betsuni Dec 2023 #66

Post removed Post removed Dec 2023 #51

Wow. Do better. N/T Jedi Guy Dec 2023 #70

They are not treated well LeftInTX Dec 2023 #52

Imagine the outrage Mountainguy Dec 2023 #91

The UN and other International orgs also JI7 Dec 2023 #55

Honestly limbicnuminousity Dec 2023 #72

Glad she survived SocialDemocrat61 Dec 2023 #79

It has been no secret... purr-rat beauty Dec 2023 #80

What this woman endured is horrific. She deserves nothing but compassion. Of course she was Nanjeanne Dec 2023 #81

Seeing people twist themselves into a pretzel to apply both siderism to what this woman went through..... LexVegas Dec 2023 #83

People are not doing that at all. People reacted to her terrible story with compassion. That there are Nanjeanne Dec 2023 #84

"I won't criticize her and hope she gets help to heal, lapucelle Dec 2023 #104

Oh there's more.. Cha Dec 2023 #106

No. There is not. hlthe2b Dec 2023 #118

Very disingenuous to not include the full statement which does not at all criticize her hlthe2b Dec 2023 #115

Yes, Deflection , both sides, and Denial. Cha Dec 2023 #94

A lot of misrepresentation (both unintentional and intentional) to incite and divide us, that is clear. hlthe2b Dec 2023 #119

Mia Shem on #Israeli TV tonight, reveals more details about her 54-day #Hamas captivity in #Gaza. LetMyPeopleVote Dec 2023 #85

Mahalo LMPV Cha Dec 2023 #95

Saturday morning KICK to keep this important thread trending. revmclaren Dec 2023 #96

New Years Eve Kick to keep this important thread alive revmclaren Dec 2023 #107

Mahalo, Rev.. Cha Dec 2023 #120

I can't imagine the horror she experienced crim son Dec 2023 #110

More victim blaming. madaboutharry Dec 2023 #111

Still not enough people seeing this. egduj Jan 2024 #121

Mahalo egduj🕊️🕯️🇮🇱💙🌊 Cha Jan 2024 #122

+1 betsuni Jan 2024 #124

She has something to say, but too many are covering their ears to avoid hearing. DavidDvorkin Jan 2024 #123

The full 30 minute interview with former Hamas hostage Mia Schem is out with English subtitles. LetMyPeopleVote Jan 2024 #125

Tuesday morning Kick. revmclaren Jan 2024 #126

Mid week Kick to get this post trending again. revmclaren Jan 2024 #127