Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

AloeVera

(4,305 posts)
29. Legitimate according to what/who?
Wed Jan 10, 2024, 09:25 PM
Jan 2024

I have not seen any exemption under international law to protection of journalists/civilians unless they've taken up arms/are in direct combat. Even then, they are not to be killed in their homes along with their families.

If they have not taken up arms, simply working for a state-run propaganda network/media outlet is not an exemption.

Was this young woman engaged in combat or does Israel have proof she took up arms - all while sleeping in her bed surrounded by her young daughter and family?

Seems to me Israel is making up its own rules and considers itself above the law of nations.

As for your statement on military escorts of "legitimate journalists" - I suppose that's one way to ensure no Palestinian can ever be considered a "legitimate" journalist.


Recommendations

5 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Now why would Israel be targeting journalists' homes? They must be Hamas fighters! Lonestarblue Jan 2024 #1
Nice try. former9thward Jan 2024 #33
Well atreides1 Jan 2024 #2
"since Israel began its war on the Palestinian territory on Nixie Jan 2024 #3
This also jumped out at me, MarineCombatEngineer Jan 2024 #4
Exactly. All those "journalists" laughing at the atrocities Nixie Jan 2024 #7
Israel also declared war on Oct 7 Donkees Jan 2024 #5
"also declared war" Nixie Jan 2024 #6
This war has been the deadliest recorded for journalists AloeVera Jan 2024 #8
I see by some of the comments that the focus again is on the messenger, not the message. AloeVera Jan 2024 #9
Wait, I thought it was said that Israel isn't allowing journalists into Gaza, MarineCombatEngineer Jan 2024 #10
What is your definition of a "legitimate journalist" Big Blue Marble Jan 2024 #11
A hint of racism? MarineCombatEngineer Jan 2024 #12
I Expect By 'Legitimate Journalists' The Gentleman Meant 'People Not Part Of The Hamas Propaganda Shop' The Magistrate Jan 2024 #13
Journalists are being killed at a rate of 14 times higher than civilians. AloeVera Jan 2024 #14
Never fails malaise Jan 2024 #15
Here's a Reuters "journalist" telling Gazans to get in there and commit more atrocities Arazi Jan 2024 #16
More collective punishment uponit7771 Jan 2024 #17
If you're actually a Hamas militant pretending to be a journalist Arazi Jan 2024 #18
I expect terrorist acts from terrorist and 100% collective punishment, no gaslight accepted uponit7771 Jan 2024 #36
So journalists are being killed with cause? N/T AloeVera Jan 2024 #19
"Journalist" Arazi Jan 2024 #20
Marina Medvin is a POS racist, hardcore RWer, I trust her as a source as far as I could toss her Celerity Jan 2024 #40
The Hamas propaganda corps are legitimate targets TheKentuckian Jan 2024 #21
Legitimate according to what/who? AloeVera Jan 2024 #29
Every member and operative for Hamas is to be eliminated TheKentuckian Jan 2024 #35
The IDF and Natanyahu are particularly invested in controlling what news comes out of GAZA... WarGamer Jan 2024 #22
Yes, they have a "reputation" to protect in the U.S. in particular, the West in general. AloeVera Jan 2024 #31
Link. AloeVera Jan 2024 #32
No that is Hamas. former9thward Jan 2024 #34
Two more "journalists" killed by the IDF Arazi Jan 2024 #23
Of course the IDF will claim they're all terrorists. WarGamer Jan 2024 #24
Because they're in Hamas, a terrorist organization Arazi Jan 2024 #25
So the dead journalist in this OP... and her family were HAMAS warriors? WarGamer Jan 2024 #28
I never said that Arazi Jan 2024 #37
Well the whole point of the OP.... is the OP. WarGamer Jan 2024 #38
Oh boy, a thread police post Arazi Jan 2024 #39
A lot of "journalists" in Gaza moonlighting as terrorists. Ace Rothstein Jan 2024 #27
Yeah I can see how that would result in a death sentence. AloeVera Jan 2024 #30
Articles and headlines often use loaded emotional wording that favors the left, especially regarding support for GuppyGal Jan 2024 #26
I wonder if a US-sourced weapon did the killing. David__77 Jan 2024 #41
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Gaza journalist Heba al-A...»Reply #29