General Discussion

ancianita

(43,307 posts)

46. Okay, thank you. Do you think he will appeal to the 11th Circuit based on this Order? Because to me, it

Tue Mar 19, 2024, 08:53 AM

Mar 2024

looks as if she's implicitly affirmed that she can make the defense's position on the law an actual jury instruction. She looks as if she's willing to give the jury instruction on how to reason a Dismissal of the trial altogether.

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

57 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

Judge Cannon is going to be removed from Smelvis' case [View all] malaise Mar 2024 OP

My mother of blessed memory PCIntern Mar 2024 #1

Your mom and her generation saved the world Duncanpup Mar 2024 #2

Precisely malaise Mar 2024 #3

Kudos to your mother who was clearly a patriot. TFG who is running to lead this country would sell to the highest bidder Rhiannon12866 Mar 2024 #4

My dad had a TS clearance for more than 20 years Best_man23 Mar 2024 #27

I was a lowly census worker... 2naSalit Mar 2024 #41

Imagine my house, my wife was 28 years with CIA. I have clearances from my service. She will not ... marble falls Mar 2024 #52

My best buddy was in the Navy. He was posted to a nuclear sub.. When ever anything comes up about what he did mitch96 Mar 2024 #56

Does Cannon even know what is in the PRA? LiberalFighter Mar 2024 #5

Apparently not malaise Mar 2024 #7

she will be a supreme court justice if she can stretch this out past november rampartc Mar 2024 #8

"We've reached a point where I'm in over my head. What do you guys suggest?" bucolic_frolic Mar 2024 #6

One of best friends was air force... JT45242 Mar 2024 #9

My Dad worked at the Atomic Plant True Blue American Mar 2024 #20

One more thing they have.... radical noodle Mar 2024 #37

I know... this is insane. FalloutShelter Mar 2024 #54

She is clever like the donald, a little bit smarter than him, but very unwise (as unwise as he is) Bernardo de La Paz Mar 2024 #10

There's nothing to "clarify" BumRushDaShow Mar 2024 #15

"Clarify" if only to clear out some defense nonsense, but since she is biased she bungled it. . . . nt Bernardo de La Paz Mar 2024 #19

Just the fact that she introduced "hypotheticals" BumRushDaShow Mar 2024 #29

Jesus Jumpin' Christ -- the two pink ice cream cones and their 3Hotdogs Mar 2024 #28

They originally wanted $200 million BumRushDaShow Mar 2024 #31

I look at this move as moniss Mar 2024 #11

Delay Delay Delay and now this. . Emile Mar 2024 #12

traitortrump's loose cannon wants to be provided with an excuse to dismiss the case. Hermit-The-Prog Mar 2024 #13

Do you really think the Special Counsel can remove her? dem4decades Mar 2024 #14

Ben Meiselas: Jack Smith is being asked to engage with situations that violate the law BeyondGeography Mar 2024 #16

Thanks for this malaise Mar 2024 #26

So the very act of Smith's even answering this is what, a trap? Moss says he should answer it. ancianita Mar 2024 #42

If his answer is she's at odds with the law they're on the same page BeyondGeography Mar 2024 #44

Okay, thank you. Do you think he will appeal to the 11th Circuit based on this Order? Because to me, it ancianita Mar 2024 #46

I hope he does and not just for the purposes of this case BeyondGeography Mar 2024 #48

Me, too. This fits the standard of "egregious." In her case, mere rebuke by the 11th just won't work. ancianita Mar 2024 #51

Too bad we can't do to Cannon what they did to Fani Willis Baitball Blogger Mar 2024 #17

It's not over with Fani gab13by13 Mar 2024 #25

It seems to be his only strategy. Baitball Blogger Mar 2024 #40

I cannot believe lawyers are still willing to represent him at this point. BlueKota Mar 2024 #53

Where did it say she is being removed from the case? MichMan Mar 2024 #18

It is the OP's conjecture. Doesn't have to be in the link. General Discussion is not LBN Bernardo de La Paz Mar 2024 #21

Pure fantasy then MichMan Mar 2024 #22

Not fantasy, it is a real and distinct possibility open to Smith Bernardo de La Paz Mar 2024 #23

I bet the MAGA people will be really upset if it happens. Kingofalldems Mar 2024 #30

Thank you malaise Mar 2024 #24

On this entire topic... Think. Again. Mar 2024 #32

It said she was being removed MichMan Mar 2024 #33

Fantazing, predicting, stating a hope, whatever... Think. Again. Mar 2024 #35

Of course, or maybe space aliens abducted him MichMan Mar 2024 #43

How often have Fed judges been removed from a case before it begins? 3Hotdogs Mar 2024 #34

Well, luckily, there are set rules... Think. Again. Mar 2024 #38

---just that a google search turned up no instances. 3Hotdogs Mar 2024 #39

Clearly she's looking for delay delay delay. And throwing anything at the wall to do it. FailureToCommunicate Mar 2024 #36

This sort of trap is likely in a system wherein a single person is designed to be a full 1/3rd of the government. jaxexpat Mar 2024 #45

Kick and rec for those who are triggered by this thread. Kingofalldems Mar 2024 #47

Correction: Cannon *should be* removed Silent3 Mar 2024 #49

No she won't onenote Mar 2024 #50

She looks the same way Katie Britt sounds Blue Owl Mar 2024 #55

My favorite paragraph from this article... Native Mar 2024 #57