Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

soldierant

(9,365 posts)
15. I do understand that if a nation were to pull back from, fail to support, a long time ally which was suddenlay attacked
Wed Apr 3, 2024, 11:17 PM
Apr 2024

that it would be like committing national suicide. No ally would ever trust that nation again. I get that. We had to support Israel immediately.

But we are past that now - targeting non-combatants who are only there to provide humaitarian aid has got to be a war crime.

And I also cannot disagree with quaherboy:
"Israel is not evil. I dont even think we should stop arming Israel, in the long run. It is a country with a right to exist and a definite need to be able to protect itself from hostile neighbors"

I don't know the answer. Netanyahu is as stubborn as TSF - and apparently as sick as well - and, while I cannot believe the Jewish people would support what he is doing, yet he is surrounded by enablers - also like TSF. No one - no words -are going to change his mind any more than any one or any words would get TSF to drop out of the Presidential race tomorrow.

We have no right to order around the leader of a sovereign state, and if we did, we'd have no way to enforce it. Yes, he is doing Israel no good and instead inflicting harm. Yes, Israel desperately needs new leadership. But we can't bring that about, and really, we shouldn't if we could.

And as long as I'm ranting - I may as well point out one more complication: Jews are not the only Semites in the world. Aras are also a Semitic people. The phrase "brother against brother" comes to mind.

Recommendations

10 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

'I wish I never founded WCKitchen' [View all] WhiskeyGrinder Apr 2024 OP
No words... 50 Shades Of Blue Apr 2024 #1
Heartbreaking AmBlue Apr 2024 #2
. Think. Again. Apr 2024 #3
I can see the gentle soul within. peacebuzzard Apr 2024 #4
I hope Biden stop the arms transfer to Israel... people are really upset LymphocyteLover Apr 2024 #5
I agree. Deuxcents Apr 2024 #7
I too agree... sprinkleeninow Apr 2024 #11
Agreed geardaddy Apr 2024 #27
It's maddening and needs to stop. Now. Deuxcents Apr 2024 #6
I hear what you're saying. And also, other innocents have been targeted for months. WhiskeyGrinder Apr 2024 #8
Take Action screamcheese Apr 2024 #9
We have to stop arming this. Scrivener7 Apr 2024 #10
The real "Good Guys" of this disaster are the humanitarians like WCKitchen and others Ping Tung Apr 2024 #12
Unfortunately that is exactly why they were targeted quakerboy Apr 2024 #13
Most of the people impacted don't deserve what is happening to them IronLionZion Apr 2024 #14
I do understand that if a nation were to pull back from, fail to support, a long time ally which was suddenlay attacked soldierant Apr 2024 #15
I wish I could recommend your post 100 times Yo_Mama_Been_Loggin Apr 2024 #16
I agree that a majority of Israelis are not evil, but the people running their country are. Lonestarblue Apr 2024 #18
Well, Robert Hubble has, soldierant Apr 2024 #29
Great post. pazzyanne Apr 2024 #19
thank you. soldierant Apr 2024 #30
My Very Dear Chef Andres, We weep with you! emmacom Apr 2024 #17
next-day kick WhiskeyGrinder Apr 2024 #20
I have been traveling and did not know about this. Kali Apr 2024 #21
midmorning kick WhiskeyGrinder Apr 2024 #22
K & Fuckin'R nt Carlitos Brigante Apr 2024 #23
Biden needs to cut off Israel NOW. Sky Jewels Apr 2024 #24
Please! If people have time, they should call or message the WHite House on this LymphocyteLover Apr 2024 #25
How do we get the Americans back? JustAnotherGen Apr 2024 #28
I think I'll start pretending things I don't like don't exist. BannonsLiver Apr 2024 #26
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»'I wish I never founded W...»Reply #15