Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

CousinIT

(12,512 posts)
30. RELATED: Smears, Sadism and Social Security-Why Elon Musk wants to make seniors suffer (Krugman)
Wed Mar 19, 2025, 09:28 AM
Mar 2025
https://paulkrugman.substack.com/p/smears-sadism-and-social-security

. . .

Musk’s big blooper was his claim that millions of dead people are receiving Social Security checks. This claim probably reflected the failure of young Musk staffers — what Dudek called the “DOGE kids” — to understand how the SSA’s databases work, combined with a complete lack of common sense. I mean, if there really were huge numbers of dead people receiving Social Security payments, don’t you think someone else would have noticed?

In a normal political environment, getting something that big that wrong would have destroyed Musk’s credibility and led to his permanent exile from any role in setting policy. But this is America in 2025, so Trump amplified the already-refuted claim when addressing Congress, and Musk seems more powerful than ever.

Furthermore, Musk refuses to give up his Social Security smears, making the completely implausible claim that fraudulent use of Social Security numbers accounts for 10 percent of federal spending. And I’d argue that that the plan to effectively cut off many disabled Americans is best seen as part of a desperate effort to find or pretend to find Social Security fraud, retroactively justifying Musk’s big mistake.

Still, does the plan have to be this cruel to the most vulnerable Americans? As I see it, the cruelty is a feature, not a bug.

After all, gratuitous, seemingly gleeful cruelty has been a hallmark of DOGE’s operations. Even if you think DOGE’s mass layoffs — some quickly reversed when it turned out that critical workers were fired — make sense, think of the way they are being carried out. In general, workers are being fired with no warning, no chance to make plans for the future, and often face insulting (and false) claims that they were poor performers.

It's hard to escape the sense that DOGE staffers are actually enjoying this. And why not? We’re mostly talking about poorly socialized young men suddenly given the power to ruin other people’s lives, taking their cues from a leader who has declared that “the fundamental weakness of Western society is empathy.” So why should we be surprised that the DOGE kids’ rampage through the government looks more and more like a remake of Lord of the Flies?

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

This is basically pushing grandma off the cliff. SunSeeker Mar 2025 #1
only if they need to change their status drray23 Mar 2025 #2
This is just Step One. FoxNewsSucks Mar 2025 #3
Absofuckingloutely! SheltieLover Mar 2025 #5
Or making all DENVERPOPS Mar 2025 #14
Question: My SS deposit goes to credit union "A" with which I verified my identity in person. If I want allegorical oracle Mar 2025 #27
Blood in the streets? Trexmaster Mar 2025 #23
So what if you just bamagal62 Mar 2025 #4
I tried to change my address with the Social Security Administration and I couldn't do it online. SunSeeker Mar 2025 #6
SunSeeker - was this recently or a while ago? Supposedly this change doesn't take effect until March 31. Nt CousinIT Mar 2025 #8
I tried to do it online on 11/27/24. I called that same day and they gave me an appointment for 1/16/25. SunSeeker Mar 2025 #13
I always do it over the phone. bamagal62 Mar 2025 #24
It appears to say just for new signups or direct deposit changes.... CousinIT Mar 2025 #7
My daughter in law is planning on retiring Figarosmom Mar 2025 #9
It says it can be done online if one has a login.gov or id.me account. Those who do not CousinIT Mar 2025 #11
Thanks Figarosmom Mar 2025 #20
There are only two reasons for this. yellow dahlia Mar 2025 #10
I think both but more 2 than 1. Nt CousinIT Mar 2025 #12
Yep. Both of the above. calimary Mar 2025 #22
I'd hate to see them reduce benefits for everybody KS Toronado Mar 2025 #15
IMO, believe we ought to make their Repug lives miserable -- call them over every petty allegorical oracle Mar 2025 #28
Amen, they deserve to be miserable KS Toronado Mar 2025 #31
This is also going to require people to have personal transportation. LisaM Mar 2025 #16
It's going to kill people around here. Our local SS office closed many years ago. mucholderthandirt Mar 2025 #25
They don't have the staff Puppyjive Mar 2025 #17
They closed our local offices twenty years ago bhikkhu Mar 2025 #18
Yes, we were told there was a secure computer system, it would save everybody. mucholderthandirt Mar 2025 #26
Step 2 is already tee'd up Ruby the Liberal Mar 2025 #19
We cannot allow this to happen. BarbD Mar 2025 #21
GOOD LUCK getting a single member of Congress to even mention it. nt CousinIT Mar 2025 #29
RELATED: Smears, Sadism and Social Security-Why Elon Musk wants to make seniors suffer (Krugman) CousinIT Mar 2025 #30
KNR niyad Mar 2025 #32
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Heads up - Social Securit...»Reply #30