Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

General Discussion

Showing Original Post only (View all)

Happy Hoosier

(9,559 posts)
Thu Jul 3, 2025, 10:09 AM Jul 2025

We REALLY need to lift the SS tax cap. [View all]

Kind of a humble-brag, but with a purpose. I just paid my last SS tax for the year. I will effectively get a 6.2% raise for the rest of the year. Meanwhile, we are careening towards a cliff for the SS trust fund. This MAKES NO SENSE. I get the argument that SS is not intended as a welfare system. But it already has benefit "bend points" intended to replace lower percentages of income as income raises. The top-level "bend point" is targeted at 15% income replacement (it's progressive, though, so higher levels of replacement at lower incomes are blended with lower levels of replacment at higher incomes for a higher total replacment percentage). If folks want to avoid just adding more tax to high-earners while maintaining the benefits cap, just add another bend point and no benefits cap. Make it a 7.5% bend point. I'd gladly pay the additional amount to shore up the trust fund and the few extra benefit bucks would be welcome, I guess.

But either way, we need to eliminate the current cap. It's dumb. There is no reason for me to get another 6.2% income that I'll just put in my brokerage account, while people pulling in $1200/mo in SS are looking at a $400/mo cut!

37 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
We REALLY need to lift the SS tax cap. [View all] Happy Hoosier Jul 2025 OP
Lifting the cap is no longer enough.nt Autumn Jul 2025 #1
It'll be close. carpetbagger Jul 2025 #7
It should be REMOVED! No cap! NM Grins Jul 2025 #15
ding. this . this was a ron raygun era piece of junk. AllaN01Bear Jul 2025 #18
Gonna have to kill the filibuster to do it Fiendish Thingy Jul 2025 #2
Remove the cap but cap benefits Freddie Jul 2025 #3
I'd be fine with that... Happy Hoosier Jul 2025 #11
the problem w that mopinko Jul 2025 #22
If I can afford to have 6.25% deducted from every paycheck, so can the very rich Freddie Jul 2025 #25
Did you read my post? I agree with that. Happy Hoosier Jul 2025 #26
You are unfortunately correct Freddie Jul 2025 #29
I agree. Does anyone know whether raising the cap was in John Larsen's Social Security 2100 Act? CousinIT Jul 2025 #4
I agree. At least raise it. LoisB Jul 2025 #5
Raise the cap to a reasonable level and add 2.0% (1.0% each to the employer and employee) to the amount OLDMDDEM Jul 2025 #6
Obama tried to do just that, he was bashed by Democrats and his commission was branded the Catfood Silent Type Jul 2025 #8
Bad for small business WSHazel Jul 2025 #9
And NOT fixing this problem is bad for everyone else. Happy Hoosier Jul 2025 #27
There are plenty of subsidies that can be turned off to save money WSHazel Jul 2025 #32
Raising the cap and the minimum wage would go a long way...nt Wounded Bear Jul 2025 #10
The Cap is so unfair to most Americans ERW Jul 2025 #12
It won't happen. Our evil government is perfectly fine with letting the trust fund GoodRaisin Jul 2025 #13
They Won't Do It Because It Is TRUE! Mr.Bee Jul 2025 #14
The cap is at 176 thousand now. Instead of going up a small amount each year or so, we should double it to 350K. patphil Jul 2025 #16
The ultra wealthy got that way on the backs of the working poor. They can return the favor. Auggie Jul 2025 #17
While I totally agree, I think I'll be happy MLWR Jul 2025 #19
No, We just need to raise the FICA tax by 1% Jacson6 Jul 2025 #20
I'd argue making FICA progressive IbogaProject Jul 2025 #34
Not as Easy as You Think Thistle1233 Jul 2025 #21
You didn't ready my post, apprently.... Happy Hoosier Jul 2025 #28
With respect.... I did read your post. Thistle1233 Jul 2025 #37
The tax cap was applied mostly to keep people with power from screaming too loudly Warpy Jul 2025 #23
Need to have better taxes on unearned income IbogaProject Jul 2025 #35
I would classify that DENVERPOPS Jul 2025 #24
Congress will be forced to act sooner or later.... Happy Hoosier Jul 2025 #30
Lift the cap on the SS tax, raise the top income tax rate to 90%, like it was in the 50s; Fil1957 Jul 2025 #31
Why not a small tax on short term trading and a minimum tax on multi millionaires? IbogaProject Jul 2025 #33
YES! All we need are supermajorities in both house of Congress. MineralMan Jul 2025 #36
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»We REALLY need to lift th...