Reposted From Facebook

[Atreus]

27. NOT historical analysis, but defeat in disguise

This whole post is wall to wall defeatism disguised as historical analysis. It cherry-picks worst-case examples from nearly a century ago and pretends they map one to one onto America in 2025. They don’t.

First off, the “fascists never removed democratically” line is just false. Pinochet in Chile was ousted by, virtually, a referendum. Marcos in the Philippines lost power through elections and mass protest. Even here, democracy has weathered Nixon, McCarthyism, segregationist regimes, and Bush era overreach; none of which ended in dictatorship. The record isn’t “hopeless inevitability.”

Second, the U.S. isn’t Weimar Germany or 1920s Italy. Those were broken, poor, war-torn nations. America today is the richest country in history with independent courts, powerful state governments, a free press, and a massive civil society. Authoritarianism here faces real opposition, not paper thin institutions ready to collapse.

Third, the secession/UN peacekeeper fantasies in this post are pure LARPing. California isn’t about to call in Canadian troops, and blue states aren’t about to launch their own currency. That’s not a plan, that’s collapse fan fiction.

Finally, this essay’s only real message is despair: it’s over, nothing matters, give up. And that is exactly the mentality authoritarianism feeds on. The truth is the opposite: democracy has survived wave after wave of challenges, and it survives because people organize, vote, resist, and refuse to bow to manufactured hopelessness.

At the end of the day this post isn’t a warning — it’s poison. It convinces people they’re powerless when in reality, authoritarian projects only succeed if people stop fighting back. Nothing is inevitable. Step up, organize, vote, speak out, and keep democracy alive. It’s hard work, yes, but that’s exactly why it works.