Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

harumph

(3,350 posts)
28. Prior to Asimov circa 1980, there was Richard Hofstadter 1963
Thu Sep 18, 2025, 11:37 AM
Sep 2025

Anti-intellectualism in American Life 1963

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-intellectualism_in_American_Life

“Tocqueville saw that the life of constant action and decision which was entailed by the democratic and businesslike character of American life put a premium upon rough and ready habits of mind, quick decision, and the prompt seizure of opportunities - and that all this activity was not propitious for deliberation, elaboration, or precision in thought.”
― Richard Hofstadter, Anti-Intellectualism in American Life


“The American mind was shaped in the mold of early modern Protestantism. Religion was the first arena for American intellectual life, and thus the first arena for an anti-intellectual impulse. Anything that seriously diminished the role of rationality and learning in early American religion would later diminish its role in secular culture. The feeling that ideas should above all be made to work, the disdain for doctrine and for refinements in ideas, the subordination of men of ideas to men of emotional power or manipulative skill are hardly innovations of the twentieth century; they are inheritances from American Protestantism.”

“The older America, until the 1890s and in some respects until 1914, was wrapped in the security of continental isolation, village society, the Protestant denominations, and a flourishing industrial capitalism. But reluctantly, year by year, over several decades, it has been drawn into the twentieth century and forced to cope with its unpleasant realities: first the incursions of cosmopolitanism and skepticism, then the disappearance of American isolation and easy military security, the collapse of traditional capitalism and its supplementation by a centralized welfare state, finally the unrelenting costs and stringencies of the Second World War, the Korean War, and the cold war. As a consequence, the heartland of America, filled with people who are often fundamentalist in religion, nativist in prejudice, isolationist in foreign policy, and conservative in economics, has constantly rumbled with an underground revolt against all these tormenting manifestations of our modern predicament.”




Recommendations

1 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

I'll have to get a copy. dhol82 Sep 2025 #1
There are three initial novels. He added a few over the years PCIntern Sep 2025 #2
These were the best Wifes husband Sep 2025 #27
I've seen elements of this theme in other movies Ilsa Sep 2025 #3
The minute you start thinking this NJCher Sep 2025 #13
Yeah, I feel like I am. I can't leave the country, Ilsa Sep 2025 #30
As a matter of fact .... Mossfern Sep 2025 #4
Prelude was written well before 1998 seeing that Asimov died around 1993. galapagos Sep 2025 #8
The Prelude trilogy was written by other writers, not asimov Blue_Adept Sep 2025 #10
And Ronald Searle also illustrated Trump in the 1950s muriel_volestrangler Sep 2025 #5
Asimov was prescient, and a great writer as well! lark Sep 2025 #6
Kick dalton99a Sep 2025 #7
I marvel at what SF writers were able to explore through novels/movies/TV through the 1900s. I frequently wiggs Sep 2025 #9
He was *much* less subtle about it at times, e.g. his essay "A Cult of Ignorance". sir pball Sep 2025 #11
TYVM for the link that has the full article & essay Hekate Sep 2025 #20
Avec plaisir, I actually hadn't ever read the whole thing myself... sir pball Sep 2025 #29
Prior to Asimov circa 1980, there was Richard Hofstadter 1963 harumph Sep 2025 #28
I made that connection back in 2017, and totally agree with you. lastlib Sep 2025 #12
Apparently the books were inspired by the PatSeg Sep 2025 #24
Trump is The Mule in the most important way Fichefinder Sep 2025 #14
Humor aside... PCIntern Sep 2025 #15
True that, but Wednesdays Sep 2025 #21
You're right about that! PCIntern Sep 2025 #25
But none have whatever it is that Trump has Fichefinder Sep 2025 #31
"Ponietz" was inspired by the Ponitz character Ponietz Sep 2025 #16
😂😂😂😂😂😂 PCIntern Sep 2025 #17
"The Last Question" SCantiGOP Sep 2025 #18
I once got rejected by Isaac Asimov Farmer-Rick Sep 2025 #19
A series currently on Apple TV... crud Sep 2025 #22
That is my favorite show right now PatSeg Sep 2025 #23
The only part of the Asimov-written prequels MurrayDelph Sep 2025 #26
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»I swear to God, it's as t...»Reply #28