Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

General Discussion

Showing Original Post only (View all)

pat_k

(12,663 posts)
Thu Sep 25, 2025, 04:52 PM Sep 2025

Republicans want to cut your healthcare so badly, they'll shut down the government to do it. [View all]

Suggestions on the messages to hammer from Tamara Massengale Miro @UnmuteAlabama

https://sez.us/l/4nt9r15k

How I’m Talking About the Shutdown

The news makes it sound like a procedural fight in Washington. Meetings canceled. Deadlines looming. Continuing resolutions. Yawn.

Here’s what I’m saying: Republicans want to cut health care so badly, they’re willing to shut down the government to get it done.

This isn’t about Beltway squabbles. It’s about whether families can afford to see a doctor.

Medicaid is facing the biggest cuts in U.S. history.

ACA tax credits are expiring, which means premiums could jump by an average of 75%.

Medicare is on the chopping block for more than $500 billion in cuts.

Hospitals, rural clinics, even children’s cancer research could lose funding.


When you talk about the shutdown, don’t start with politics. Start with people.

This shutdown isn’t just “government dysfunction.” It’s a health care crisis manufactured on purpose.

👉 The “how” matters.

Say “Republicans want to cut your health care so badly…” instead of “Democrats and Republicans can’t agree.”

Say “millions of families will lose coverage” instead of “funding lapses.”

Say “research into children’s cancer will stop” instead of “budget line items.”


If we lead with the human cost, the politics takes care of itself.


And an additional suggestion from Anat Shenker Osario (Freedom Over Fascism toolkit):

Refuse to frame it as a government shutdown fight. Frame it as refusing to be an accomplice to turning the government into a weapon against the people.


I think that message can be pulled in by saying things like:

We refuse to be accomplices in the biggest cuts to Medicaid in U.S. history.

We refuse to be accomplices to increasing healthcare premiums for 75 million Americans by an average of 75%.

We will not be accomplices to the Republican Congress's cowardly refusal to demand that Trump stop breaking his oath of office and carry out the laws passed by Congress.


54 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Yep.............. Lovie777 Sep 2025 #1
Democrats will cheer. Republicans will say, "Who care?" We are split 50/50, so not sure we'll prevail. Silent Type Sep 2025 #2
Trump's "coalition" has collapsed pat_k Sep 2025 #5
No, we're not 50/50 paleotn Sep 2025 #6
Guess you don't trust polls? Please provide a citation of your trope that it is50/50. Silent Type Sep 2025 #19
His approval rating is a "tad" below 50%, no? paleotn Sep 2025 #23
I'd call 40% Approve 60% Disapprove more than a "tad" pat_k Sep 2025 #27
I was being facetious with the "tad" comment. paleotn Sep 26 #51
Opps. Me being a tad dense. pat_k Sep 26 #52
When over 90 million voters sat out of the last election, over a 3rd, then roughly 60% voted and 51% of them R Cheezoholic Sep 2025 #24
Look at the results for 2024. What was trump's percentage of votes, not to mention losing both chambers. Silent Type Sep 2025 #31
Your statement this country is 50/50 is false. If anything we're 50/50 of those who vote and those who dont Cheezoholic Sep 2025 #35
of course we're not. pat_k Sep 2025 #21
If the Dems don't give in and won't refuse anything less BigmanPigman Sep 2025 #3
Just need to message it properly. paleotn Sep 2025 #7
We, the base, are messengers too. And we can get it right. And push our electeds to do a better job. pat_k Sep 2025 #25
I love this message. Scrivener7 Sep 2025 #30
Thanks! Perhaps you'll like my follow-up too. pat_k Sep 2025 #34
P.S. I suggest you subscribe to Ariella Elm's substack. pat_k Sep 2025 #33
Yes to this mountain grammy Sep 2025 #46
Glad this inspired a big Yes! pat_k Sep 2025 #47
Also Help Point Out How Many People Will Lose Their Jobs modrepub Sep 2025 #4
Yes. I need to take some time to see if CBO, or other entities, have good estimates of ripple effects... pat_k Sep 2025 #36
If only a shutdown would shut down ICE... Wounded Bear Sep 2025 #8
That is for a future battle. pat_k Sep 2025 #37
K&R B.See Sep 2025 #9
Thanks! pat_k Sep 26 #53
Good message, too bad you can't fit "people will die" somewhere in there. Fil1957 Sep 2025 #10
Oh, I think you can. pat_k Sep 2025 #38
Great post! Thank you! ancianita Sep 2025 #11
Thanks! If you have other socials, perhaps post there too! pat_k Sep 26 #54
And it all to take from those who need jobs and health care IbogaProject Sep 2025 #12
I'm a little unclear about how demands to maintain full appropriations for Medicaid... pat_k Sep 2025 #39
Wut? IbogaProject Sep 26 #48
Of course. But appropriation bills and CR's don't.. pat_k Sep 26 #49
Ah, I was talking about public messaging IbogaProject Sep 26 #50
This is great stuff. Ready to call and write my sleazy FL legislators with these, and share with everyone I meet. Timeflyer Sep 2025 #13
So glad to hear it inspired you to action. It did the same for me. (nt) pat_k Sep 2025 #40
Slow genocide. moondust Sep 2025 #14
That is our message. mountain grammy Sep 2025 #15
Hear! Hear! And if you have a Democratic Rep, or if either (or both) Senators are Dems, send them the message. pat_k Sep 2025 #45
In MAGA World, cutting healthcare is "good" while trying to save it is "liberal extremism." n/t Beartracks Sep 2025 #16
I'm a liberal extremist BOSSHOG Sep 2025 #20
There are plenty in MAGA world receiving those "enhanced ACA subsidies" pat_k Sep 2025 #41
"When you talk about the shutdown, don't start with politics. Start with people." Beartracks Sep 2025 #17
Frame it as unwilling to be an acquiescent accomplice. BattleRow Sep 2025 #18
I may be in a minority here ... Metaphorical Sep 2025 #22
I totally agree. But I think an important part of our strategy should be to spread the message in the OP Scrivener7 Sep 2025 #28
This woman is talented. I hope all our reps listen to this and do what she says. Scrivener7 Sep 2025 #26
She is. I've found all of her contributions over on Sez.Us extremely valuable. pat_k Sep 2025 #43
All republicans have to do is say it's for immigrants...... Lovie777 Sep 2025 #29
And we counter that with more powerful messages. It's time for US, Not Them, to create "Reality." pat_k Sep 2025 #44
Republicans Shut the Government Down because Epstein! PuraVidaDreamin Sep 2025 #32
Republicans want non-billionaires to DIE so that they won't VOTE! Jack Valentino Sep 2025 #42
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Republicans want to cut y...