Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

JoetheShow

(155 posts)
12. I was in the military back in the 70s.
Thu Oct 16, 2025, 05:23 PM
Oct 2025

The military is not required to follow "illegal" orders. The problem is that if you refuse the order, you will have to stand trial and basically prove it is illegal. I remember the case of Ehren Watada, the army officer who refused to rotate with his unit to Iraq during GWB's unprovoked attack. He said the war was illegal and he was required to not participate. I personally thought this was an open and shut case and he should be hailed a hero. The military took a different view. He had to stand trial and even though the trial ended in a mistrial, he was eventually discharged under conditions other-than-honorable. To this day, I think he covered himself with more honor than anyone else associated with that aggressive war.

Recommendations

2 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Disappointed, should have stayed to fight from the inside... MiHale Oct 2025 #1
Being in the military is different from civilian employment Raven123 Oct 2025 #6
I've never been in the military. markodochartaigh Oct 2025 #9
Dude's been in almost 30 years; it's nice to retire. Mysterian Oct 2025 #10
How does that help? BlueTsunami2018 Oct 2025 #2
Yeah, that was my thought as well. progressoid Oct 2025 #3
Any sign of defiance against the Orange Ass (thanks B. Midler) is welcome. JoetheShow Oct 2025 #14
The UCMJ is not the US Constitution, as my husband pointed out to me many times... Hekate Oct 2025 #17
That's not what I mean. BlueTsunami2018 Oct 2025 #18
Actually, right now -probably not. haele Oct 2025 #19
That's exactly what Trump and his fascist mob want: to get rid of all officers who respect the constitution. sop Oct 2025 #4
Thank you sir for your gumption. Be well, Be safe. nt Hotler Oct 2025 #5
The downside is Wednesdays Oct 2025 #7
Hegseth has ordered all members of the military to watch his bullshit speech pfitz59 Oct 2025 #8
Good for him. Passages Oct 2025 #11
I was in the military back in the 70s. JoetheShow Oct 2025 #12
He can be more vocal outside the military. NoSheep Oct 2025 #13
We don't want them all leaving but at the same time you can't expect them all to stay jgmiller Oct 2025 #15
And the Admiral over SOUTHCOM retires at end of 2025. nt Ilsa Oct 2025 #16
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Marine colonel quits afte...»Reply #12