Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

betsuni

(28,654 posts)
29. When grievances matter more than vulnerabilities.
Sun Dec 28, 2025, 10:36 PM
2 hrs ago

Steve Almond, in his book "Bad Stories," gives three examples.

Josh, Harvard educated, works for non-profit research institute partly government funded. Voted Libertarian in 2016. Almond asked if he knew the policies he voted for. Nope, it was a protest vote. Josh had lost his job and the Obama stimulus package paid for his family's health insurance. Zero Republican votes. Did Josh remember that Democrats allowed him to keep his coverage? Nope. Grievances (probably stupid bullshit about Democrats being "corporate" or "neoliberal" and corrupt because they have to pay for campaigns like everyone and somehow that makes them corrupt) more important than reality.

Almond's wealthy neighbor voted for Trump, complaining about Democrats never did anything for her, that after her parents died there was hardly any money left and her daughter's private university tuition was too high. "What was this woman saying in the end? She was saying that Obama had failed to honor a bargain whose terms she, as a citizen, felt free to shift according to her whim. It was an argument of such subjective force and ingrained entitlement, as to be impervious. ... She saw no relationship between her life and the election beyond the lazy hope that the new guy would give her more stuff than the last."

A small business owner on Obamacare, husband needing a liver transplant, voted for Trump because he was a businessman who could shake up Washington and bring jobs back; she chose not to believe that Trump would get rid of the ACA. "She represents our national habit of taking our grievances seriously but not our vulnerabilities."

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Many Democrats expect their elected Dem reps to lead the revolution. FalloutShelter 16 hrs ago #1
The GOP embraces their protesters and far right spokesmen Farmer-Rick 14 hrs ago #11
Not true at all creeksneakers2 25 min ago #31
Elected Democratic leaders need to endorse popular Democratic candidates and ideas while fighting the fights they can. Gore1FL 13 hrs ago #14
We don't actually need a revolution, we need a counter-revolution. The Reagan Revolution has to go JHB 12 hrs ago #17
The fight now is trying to protect what we have creeksneakers2 22 min ago #32
One suggestion: Democratic leaders should hold "shadow" hearings and tape them Justice matters. 11 hrs ago #21
There is the day to day process where right now we are weak as the minority. Then there is vision. Which we seem.... dutch777 16 hrs ago #2
trouble is- mopinko 15 hrs ago #5
And these things need to be accomplished in a hard hitting get-it-done manner. Trust_Reality 12 hrs ago #18
We need to be more outspoken WmChris 15 hrs ago #3
It doesn't fully explain it. everyonematters 15 hrs ago #4
"trans boys" angrychair 6 hrs ago #24
I should have said trans girls. everyonematters 5 hrs ago #25
Corporate media has their thumb on the scale for the pukes as well. It's not an even playing field. Blues Heron 15 hrs ago #6
Yep. For profit media is for profit first. Trust_Reality 12 hrs ago #19
But Democratic candidates are winning Buckeyeblue 15 hrs ago #7
i don't see Dem adrenaline. AOC and Gavin are exceptions Tetrachloride 14 hrs ago #8
Post removed Post removed 14 hrs ago #9
Republicans are to the left of "corporate" Democrats? Martin Eden 14 hrs ago #13
It's simple. Low approval for Democrats does NOT equate to approval for Republicans Martin Eden 14 hrs ago #10
Yes, Democrats need to fight harder Mysterian 14 hrs ago #12
Democratic low polling numbers are from Democrats or unaffiliated Democratic leaning voters, 'cause the Democratic Fil1957 13 hrs ago #15
Both parties make the same mistake of thinking--or choosing to think--that voters... Ol Janx Spirit 13 hrs ago #16
With a few exceptions (AOC, Gavin, Bernie) pinkstarburst 11 hrs ago #20
I think there's a disconnect between campaigning and achieving dickthegrouch 11 hrs ago #22
It all stems from a sometimes-Democrat that has misled a large swath of the left-leaning electorate. W_HAMILTON 10 hrs ago #23
Absolutely. That kind of damage to Democrats wasn't possible before. betsuni 3 hrs ago #28
Republicans can't do policy. OAITW r.2.0 5 hrs ago #26
Many of the polls ask the wrong questions Bluetus 3 hrs ago #27
When grievances matter more than vulnerabilities. betsuni 2 hrs ago #29
I have a good explanation for it. bob4460 45 min ago #30
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Democratic Party's Low Po...»Reply #29