Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
General Discussion
Showing Original Post only (View all)Officer in Renee Good shooting fired the fatal shots while filming with a phone in his left hand [View all]
UPDATE: as I was initially writing this post, the video from Ross's phone was released. I've added it to the bottom of this post.I hadn't noticed it until just now, despite watching the videos multiple times.
In the original video from the back-left of the vehicle, you can clearly see that Jonathan Ross is filming the incident, with his phone in his left hand. Here are some screengrabs from the New York Times analysis video:


Why is he doing this? Surely walking in front of a car which is potentially about to move is not good practice, so why is he doing that with a phone in his hand? How closely can he possibly be paying attention to what's happening in front of him if he's holding a phone screen up in his left hand? Is he looking at the car or the screen?
Knowing that he has a phone in his left hand, if you watch the video you can see that the entire incident occurs while he is holding that phone. He draws, aims, and fires his weapon with one hand, all while holding a cell phone in his left hand. After the shooting, he holsters his gun and you can just about still see the phone in his left hand.

This guy is supposed to be a well-trained ten-year veteran firearms expert. Is it standard police practice to walk in front of a car filming a video with a phone in your left hand, then draw, aim, and fire your weapon three times into the car with the other hand, risking hitting the other officer standing right next to you, as well as anyone standing behind the vehicle should the bullets miss or pass through it?
EDITED TO ADD: They've now released the video from Jonathan Ross's phone:
If they've done that, it can only have been done with his consent, and likely his lawyers, and likely the Trump administration. Presumably they think this helps their case that he was hit with the car. Ross's video doesn't really show that, but it certainly proves that he was clearly distracted by his phone while shooting someone.
91 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Officer in Renee Good shooting fired the fatal shots while filming with a phone in his left hand [View all]
EarlG
Friday
OP
Good questions, all of them. Maybe there might be answers--who knows? ...n/t
CaliforniaPeggy
Friday
#2
The fact that he was holding his phone surely shows criminal negligence if nothing else
EarlG
Friday
#6
It also makes it a harder to make the case that he was in fear for his life when he decided to pull the trigger.
Ms. Toad
Friday
#84
Exactly. His distraction prevented him from knowing the car momentarily backed up.
John1956PA
Friday
#29
you can see his hand in frame briefly when he is being confronted by Rebecca Good.
uncle ray
Friday
#54
Trophy hunting is psycho/serial killer behavior, and evidence of premeditation.
RockRaven
Friday
#14
"Out here shootin' libtards, now smash that LIKE button! Don't forget to subscribe!"
flvegan
Friday
#16
Renee Nicole Good: "That's fine dude, I'm not mad at you." ICE Officer: "Fuckin' bitch"
underpants
Friday
#20
He can be heard calling her a "f***ing b****" immediately after shooting her.
PA Democrat
Friday
#21
Exactly. She's turning the steering wheel to avoid the dumbass who is filming her.
Rhiagel
Friday
#70
They are proud of killing people. And maybe they get a bonus for every dead body.
Irish_Dem
Friday
#31
Trophy hunters who can't afford safaris or those stateside 'wild animal' hunt parks for rich guys?
Attilatheblond
Friday
#39
I noticed it too, but thought 'nah, they can't be that stupid, maybe just a bad view angle'
Attilatheblond
Friday
#42
The fact that this video was clearly released in coordination with the White House is certainly grounds for suspicion
EarlG
Friday
#47
He could have fired because for a split second he THOUGHT he was going to get hit, but
EarlG
Friday
#49
My question is, why would anyone in this situation walk as close as possible in front of a car?
flashman13
Friday
#75