Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Jedi Guy

(3,440 posts)
33. They could, yes.
Sun Feb 1, 2026, 03:58 AM
5 hrs ago

But they're going to ask you to lower the window so they can talk to you. You don't necessarily have to lower it all the way, though. You could lower it halfway so it's enough to talk and pass your license and such through the gap but not so low that they could easily reach in.

As a practical matter they'd only likely get you out of the car to search you for weapons, which on your bog standard traffic stop should be fairly unlikely, especially if you keep your cool. Getting someone out of a car on the side of the road is risky for both the officer and the driver so in a normal stop it's not very likely.

On that note, if they should happen to ask you to exit the vehicle that's considered a lawful order under Pennsylvania v. Mimms. Refusing to do so is just going to escalate things, potentially to the point of them forcibly removing you from the car.

As someone else noted, you can put your hazard lights on when they initiate the stop and then pull over in a place that's well lit and has other people around, like a gas station.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

What worries me is that these roid-raging thugs will interpret someone getting out as a threat-- viva la 21 hrs ago #1
You only get out if they tell you to nt EX500rider 20 hrs ago #6
Seldom do I watch YouTube's because they take too long to get to the point..but this was outstanding, easy to watch and Ninga 21 hrs ago #2
Here is a little bit different take on this... NowsTheTime 21 hrs ago #3
Transcript. If you can't copy and paste or print out a video. usonian 20 hrs ago #13
really good information Roc2020 21 hrs ago #4
not necessarily good information cab67 21 hrs ago #5
Basically stay in the car with window down & hands in sight unless told to exit EX500rider 20 hrs ago #7
When ordered to get out of your car, lock the door behind you. It becomes another 4th Amendment blockade and the cops OMGWTF 19 hrs ago #14
If they don't have permission or probable cause EX500rider 17 hrs ago #19
If they can make up any reason to arrest you Cerulean Southpaw 1 hr ago #36
It looks like an advertisement. I say situational awareness is the first rule of self defense. littlemissmartypants 20 hrs ago #8
In what neighborhood? Cirsium 20 hrs ago #9
+1 leftstreet 17 hrs ago #20
Would be nice to have a written list of do's and don't's . . . AverageOldGuy 20 hrs ago #10
Here you go. Jedi Guy 17 hrs ago #21
I used to get a lot of reels about how people act when a cop pulls them over, or otherwise approaches them. mucholderthandirt 13 hrs ago #24
To the best of my knowledge, ICE aren't cops in the way we normally think of them. Jedi Guy 5 hrs ago #34
If you rolled your window, can they just reach in and unlock the car? question everything 8 hrs ago #31
They could, yes. Jedi Guy 5 hrs ago #33
Good luck rolling the window up & locking the door ...instead simply state that "I do not concent to any searches" NowsTheTime 20 hrs ago #11
Yes, You start rolling up your windows before getting out..... Zackzzzz 19 hrs ago #18
Transcript, in case you can'r memorize videos. usonian 20 hrs ago #12
So we should assume they won't prevent us from closing the door? Raven123 19 hrs ago #15
Can't they just unlock the door Mossfern 19 hrs ago #16
The exception to everything he said.... Staph 19 hrs ago #17
Also bad advice in my opinion EX500rider 15 hrs ago #23
I live in a rural area where the closest populated area might be 10 miles away. MichMan 11 hrs ago #26
I haven't forgotten the murder of Cara Knott by on-duty CHP Craig Peyer in 1986 chia 11 hrs ago #27
I don't find it very good advice in my opinion EX500rider 15 hrs ago #22
I liked Chris Rock's video better Polybius 11 hrs ago #25
That's a good one! 👍nt Raine 6 hrs ago #32
It is probably good legal advice for a routine traffic stop, but it will not work with ICE Bluetus 10 hrs ago #28
"Understand that in every state AFAIK, assault does not require any physical contact." MichMan 10 hrs ago #29
That is the law. But the difference is the police don't get to decide that. Bluetus 9 hrs ago #30
Won't happen in reality. RandiFan1290 1 hr ago #35
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»If Cops Demand Your Windo...»Reply #33