Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

radical noodle

(10,607 posts)
13. It is not either/or but...
Fri Mar 13, 2026, 10:58 AM
Mar 13

We rise to their bait every time. Some group is hurt every time they do this. The trans community has suffered because of this and we could have responded in a different way to take the pressure off, but instead we unwittingly gave fuel to the fire.

We care about LGBTQ rights. We care about prices. But somehow we always pick the wrong argument. The more we defend trans people the way we do the more gas gets thrown on the fire for the culture wars.

I have a dear friend with a trans daughter. She was living a fairly normal life until the trans culture wars began. Now she is living in fear, practically in hiding. Her boyfriend has left her because he became afraid. Her doctor has been arrested and she can't find another one. Our defense of her did not help. It made the argument louder, more prominent. We should have turned that argument around.

I admit to being a fairly ignorant about trans people and how they generally feel about all this. I only have one person to look to in order to form an opinion. It worries me right now that I may have said something with this post that could be hurtful to someone here. I hope not, but if I did I am certainly open to being corrected.

We are all human beings (well, okay... there is some question about this current administration) and while we need to defend all people we must do a better job of it. While we're at it, why don't we educate people so they know that there are not just male or female babies being born? Most people have no idea there are intersexual people. That "only male or female" argument could have been slowed a long time ago.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

The American people seem to value hatred more than common sense. Irish_Dem Mar 13 #1
Unfortunately true why we are stuck Tree Lady Mar 13 #16
And they destroy themselves in the process. Irish_Dem Mar 13 #17
Those shots are going to hurt. nt BootinUp Mar 13 #2
Talarico has the right message, top vs bottom, not left vs right Deminpenn Mar 13 #3
Yes, but that is a verboten topic. OldBaldy1701E Mar 13 #7
The moneychangers are about to be thrown out of the temple Deminpenn Mar 13 #14
My respects, but the moneychangers have been here for over 100 years. OldBaldy1701E Mar 14 #20
Since the beginning of the Republic actually Deminpenn Mar 15 #22
So, rinse and repeat it is. OldBaldy1701E Mar 15 #23
For perspective, read the book Deminpenn Mar 15 #24
I appreciate the suggestion and I will look into that tome. OldBaldy1701E Mar 16 #25
Watched. Watched a lot of Jim on YouTube. He is impressive. mobeau69 Mar 13 #9
In the immortal words of the Master Debater, I refuse the question. WhiskeyGrinder Mar 13 #4
Multitasking OC375 Mar 13 #5
This! FalloutShelter Mar 13 #6
Great slogan MustLoveBeagles Mar 13 #18
"Pronouns" are a great distraction from their failures and our successes. progressoid Mar 13 #8
They are optional. gulliver Mar 13 #15
Amen, brother. Joinfortmill Mar 13 #10
I like Talarico jfz9580m Mar 13 #11
Plural pronouns are valuable when dealing with large quantities GreenWave Mar 13 #12
It is not either/or but... radical noodle Mar 13 #13
Special interest group bullies won't like it but we need more candidates spreading this message. BannonsLiver Mar 13 #19
That's the way to handle it! mcar Mar 14 #21
Americans are not afraid of WOKE FalloutShelter Mar 16 #26
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Talarico: ... what do the...»Reply #13