General Discussion

ShazzieB

(23,060 posts)

109. I would hate to see anyone here take what the author said personally.

Mon Jun 22, 2026, 02:29 AM

Yesterday

I think she was trying to describe a certain demographic that includes a large percentage of Trump supporters but never neant to imply that EVERYONE In that demographic is a Trumper. I also agree that racism is the key factor in who Trump appeals to, regardless of the education or work experience of any individual voter.

Mr. B and I are white, and we both came from what I would call working class backgrounds. We both have college degrees, and I worked white collar jobs, but he ended up spending about 2/3 of his working life on a factory assembly line, simply because that was a type of work he felt well suited to. Neither of us ever remotely considered voting for Trump, any more than anyone else here (give or take a few lurkers or trolls) did.

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

153 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

The Guardian nails it: White working class votes for white supremacists. Period. [View all] AverageOldGuy Sunday OP

Kick dalton99a Sunday #1

Thank you for posting this. It's the plain truth. n/t Mister Ed Sunday #2

The American Civil War NEVER ENDED. NoMoreRepugs Sunday #3

Had I been in power in 1865 lonely bird 22 hrs ago #115

I agree and I've been in Alabama for 60-plus years misanthrope 15 hrs ago #136

No it did not and it has been obvious misanthrope 15 hrs ago #135

May I suggest Jeremi Suri's lonely bird 9 hrs ago #145

Thanks misanthrope 4 hrs ago #151

Yup. Ocelot II Sunday #4

White Working Class includes a lot of others now--given the devastating economy-- so... hlthe2b Sunday #5

It's a long article, worth the read. yardwork Sunday #44

I agree that it is about racism, but economics are also a factor. wnylib Sunday #67

A lot of well said information electric_blue68 11 hrs ago #140

Well, like other people my age, I lived through wnylib 9 hrs ago #143

Lots of interesting family background, and work situation issues! electric_blue68 5 hrs ago #148

I am 76. You are the age of my younger sister. wnylib 4 hrs ago #150

If you were paying attention that 3 yrs difference stands out.. electric_blue68 2 hrs ago #152

Democrats did lose 30% of the young, male, black vote. questionseverything Sunday #70

In part because Democrats are now defending gay and trans people. Wednesdays Sunday #84

Empathy is looked down on wolfie001 20 hrs ago #119

I venture to guess many/most DUers are "working class" and a lot are White. Are they all to be lumped in hlthe2b Sunday #88

In a sense, "access to power over other racial groups" is still viewed by lower class whites as an economic advantage. sop Sunday #6

+1 dalton99a Sunday #11

Great OP malaise Sunday #7

"I may get screwed over, but the Other, the 'They', they get screwed over even more." ck4829 Sunday #8

I'm white working class. I am not MAGA! I am not racist! Please stop stereotyping. Doodley Sunday #9

You're right. It would be more accurate to add the modifier "some" before "white working class." sop Sunday #13

I live in a "working class" neighborhood in metro Detroit. Kid Berwyn Sunday #22

+1 Auggie Sunday #32

This message was self-deleted by its author yardwork Sunday #45

Geez. Nobody is stereotyping. yardwork Sunday #46

Not sure that "strong majority" of white working class still holds true. Not all white working class KPN Sunday #65

I don't know a single Trump voter who says they regret their vote. yardwork Sunday #77

I've never heard one say, "I think Trump is terrible, I regret voting for him, I think I'll vote 'D' next time." sop 21 hrs ago #116

We cannot discuss race without someone being offended Keepthesoulalive Sunday #49

As a white person I just don't understand the defensiveness. yardwork Sunday #60

Race is an uncomfortable subject Keepthesoulalive Sunday #64

A lot of Americans cling to our mythology. yardwork Sunday #73

It's classic bean souping... meadowlander Yesterday #106

24% of black men voted for Trump. Why? It isn't as simple as black versus white. Yes, you need modifiers unless you Doodley 22 hrs ago #113

The problem with any discussion about race Keepthesoulalive 18 hrs ago #123

I'm not being defensive. I can talk about race all day, but stop stereotyping--that's what racism is. Doodley 17 hrs ago #125

You're being defensive now Keepthesoulalive 16 hrs ago #127

Sorry if you don't like my opinion that you shouldn't stereotype and that stereotyping is what racism is. Doodley 16 hrs ago #128

Once more for the folks in the audience Keepthesoulalive 16 hrs ago #129

You are wrong in your assumptions about me. 11 people recommended my reply in which I objected to the stereotyping. Doodley 16 hrs ago #131

Okay Keepthesoulalive 15 hrs ago #132

Let's have a truce and accept maybe we misunderstood each other. I apologize if my tone was aggressive. Doodley 15 hrs ago #134

We're all good Keepthesoulalive 14 hrs ago #137

15% Dlpger61 16 hrs ago #130

It is actually 21 percent according to Pew. Doodley 15 hrs ago #133

Absolute agreement. Literalism can be a popular pablum allowing Torchlight 18 hrs ago #124

I'm white working-class male and I Dr. T Sunday #51

Good for you Cirsium Sunday #76

What are you talking about? Doodley 22 hrs ago #114

This Cirsium 13 hrs ago #139

What are you talking about here: Doodley 8 hrs ago #147

No Cirsium 4 hrs ago #149

It's twelve people now. Let me understand. Are you saying you are "disappointed" with them? And their Doodley 2 hrs ago #153

Spot on ABC123Easy Sunday #10

Bill Clinton had a chance to change this when he was in the White House FakeNoose Sunday #12

I can remember a picture of Clinton & Gore with a credit-card type card that would be your access card to Universal NBachers Sunday #27

Yeah, Clinton's eight years of peace and prosperity comradebillyboy Sunday #38

If not President Clinton MorbidButterflyTat Sunday #78

That's not what I implied, but thanks for sharing your thoughts FakeNoose Sunday #87

The majority of white people have voted republican since LBJ Keepthesoulalive Sunday #39

They started leaving way before Bill Clinion DFW Sunday #40

LBJ knew he was going to lose the southern racists by signing the Civil Rights Act FakeNoose Sunday #89

Read the essay linked in the OP. yardwork Sunday #47

No. White working class left in post-civil rights era after the two parties diverged on race, cultural changes. betsuni Sunday #55

Fox News and hate radio push a steady diet of anti-Black, anti-immigrant messaging. yardwork Sunday #58

At the gym yesterday .. justsomeguy01 Sunday #62

From the Right: "liberals hate white people," other direction: "Dem establishment ignores white working class betsuni Sunday #66

...to his credit.. thomski64 21 hrs ago #117

Not true Cirsium Sunday #75

I would hate to see anyone here take what the author said personally. ShazzieB Yesterday #109

How do you "install" universal healthcare? LisaM Sunday #103

Myth there are simple solutions for everything but corrupt establishment stops it. betsuni Yesterday #107

Clinton wasn't the only thing happening when white working class started leaving MadameButterfly 22 hrs ago #112

While often true, it's not a universal, absolute truth Fiendish Thingy Sunday #14

But will they continue to vote for the party of progress Keepthesoulalive Sunday #68

The paradigm has shifted Fiendish Thingy Sunday #86

I wish I could share your enthusiasm Keepthesoulalive Sunday #91

The evidence indicates the billionaires are losing Fiendish Thingy Sunday #98

They will control the House for a generation. mr715 Sunday #94

I think it is important to note that West Virginia mr715 Sunday #92

But why Keepthesoulalive Sunday #93

White, working class voters. mr715 Sunday #95

West Virginia is one of the most beautiful states Keepthesoulalive Sunday #97

Republicans told people Democratic environmental regulations would take all their jobs. betsuni Yesterday #108

"centrist, neoliberalism and triangulation, deregulation of energy" -- for example? Blame Democrats! betsuni Yesterday #110

That's true. Janbdwl72 Yesterday #105

And Carter in 1980 mr715 16 hrs ago #126

Worth reading, and here's the money shot... TygrBright Sunday #15

+1 leftstreet 18 hrs ago #122

When I hear him say make Americkkka great again it's really make racism great again! kimbutgar Sunday #16

great read. mopinko Sunday #17

I worked in Greenville MS back in 1989 when Boeing had a plant there KS Toronado Sunday #18

There is in group discussion Keepthesoulalive Sunday #59

Really wish more on DU would understand this reality. rogue emissary Sunday #19

It's a shallow combination of ownership within class identity and fear of unknown competition haele Sunday #50

Yes, artificial and unnecessary division based on falsehood that Democrats "ignore the working class." betsuni Sunday #71

And these beliefs and preferences are very difficult to counter, even with the "right messaging" Redleg Sunday #20

The story of the white sharecropper poisoning his black sharecropper neighbor's mule come to mind. Squaredeal Sunday #21

Jeezus. Humans need a reboot. Joinfortmill Sunday #25

This message was self-deleted by its author MerryBlooms Sunday #102

Republicans understand this. SamuelAdams Sunday #23

dumb, dumber, dumbest Joinfortmill Sunday #24

I think they need somebody to look down on. zanana1 Sunday #26

I wonder if there's not some of that going on with "us" TheProle Sunday #57

Well, we look down on MAGA. zanana1 21 hrs ago #118

MAGA is simply shorthand for anyone who slavishly supports and follows Trump. sop 20 hrs ago #120

Sounds like the older part of my family....MAGATs all BeneteauBum Sunday #28

This is a "duh" headline..white working class vote their hate for "the other"... agingdem Sunday #29

Not really "duh" since we aren't used to seeing this from the media, at least in the U.S. Redleg Sunday #30

The Guardian is British paper...our papers/MSM are so terrified of MAGA agingdem Sunday #35

... Solly Mack Sunday #31

Worked in an auto plant just West of Detroit. multigraincracker Sunday #33

We need to go back to colorblind (if we still can) gulliver Sunday #34

But the US was almost never "colorblind". electric_blue68 10 hrs ago #141

The "colorblind ethic" was solid and working... gulliver 9 hrs ago #144

No, it wasn't solid and it wasn't working Quiet Em 8 hrs ago #146

Yes, this is central to understanding the American project and why it has failed. nt Blasphemer Sunday #36

"Mississippi Burning" duckworth969 Sunday #37

A great movie- I doubt it would be made today, given the kow-towing to Trump Redleg Sunday #43

It's because of racism we can't have the nice things that folks have in other rich countries. Fil1957 Sunday #41

And yet...guys like Graham Platner, Zohran Mamdani, Abdul El Sayed biocube Sunday #42

Post removed Post removed Sunday #48

And what about brown men with "foreign-sounding names" like Mamdani and El Sayed? biocube Sunday #54

American Arabs are white adjacent in the minds of many. yardwork Sunday #56

That's just great. MorbidButterflyTat Sunday #82

What rhetoric is Platner using that signals he is a racist? I find your attack on him to be problematic at best. He is Celerity Sunday #90

What is the point? Cirsium Sunday #79

And yet...Andrew Cuomo won white voters in NYC SocialDemocrat61 19 hrs ago #121

Ive pushed back on this for decades Cosmocat Sunday #52

I've said drumphf "gave permission" for rhe racists to come out from under their rocksr electric_blue68 10 hrs ago #142

yes, like Black people have known since forever yobrault1 Sunday #53

While I agree to a point, but it's waaay more complicated than that. paleotn Sunday #61

We enable that to happen, by ... Bluetus Sunday #63

Noooooo! We Just Need To UNDERSTAND THEM! TALK With Them! Really.....! ColoringFool Sunday #69

I live in Pennsylvania and I know plenty of people like that. Alice B. Sunday #72

I grew up in rural Ohio and I hear it often from people I grew up with. yardwork Sunday #74

People start framing things like, the "Obama Library" MorbidButterflyTat Sunday #83

Which is why we will never see a black Republican presidential nominee in our lifetimes. Wednesdays Sunday #80

Saida Grundy nails it Cirsium Sunday #81

The ruling class uses racism orthoclad Sunday #85

All American racists love Trump and would never vote for anyone else. Martin68 Sunday #96

Wish i could JustAnotherGen Sunday #99

Some eyes are being opened here Keepthesoulalive Sunday #104

Yes, has The Guardian stamp of progressive approval, no shooting the messenger. All data says same thing. betsuni Yesterday #111

We have made progress in the face of racist forces manipulated by corrupt wealth. We will again. pat_k Sunday #100

Keeping it sinple and visual. usonian Sunday #101

The same white working class that put Biden over the top in 2020? TheProle 14 hrs ago #138