General Discussion

hfojvt

(37,573 posts)

116. dialogue would involve

Sun Jan 20, 2013, 03:05 AM

Jan 2013

you explaining your POV. Not saying "you are free to think what you want, because anything can be true with art". And now attacking me as somebody not interested in communicating and with some sort of emotional barrier.

My hostility towards anarchy really has nothing to do with the question at hand. The OP says that the movie, the leading character V, promotes anarchy. My position was that it does not, that V was fighting tyranny and not promoting anarchy.

It was you who engaged in the battle by refudiating me with the fact that Alan Moore is an anarchist.

And I countered that by explaining why I don't think that fact matters.

And I state my hostility towards anarchy because if I had perceived that the movie was promoting anarchy, I would have been pretty quick to say "this movie sucks".

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

127 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

Why do so many people idolize V for vendetta's anarchy? It is not democratic to blow up buildings [View all] graham4anything Jan 2013 OP

Moore himself is troubled by that Recursion Jan 2013 #1

What franchise is that? Marr Jan 2013 #65

Pirates of the Caribbean Recursion Jan 2013 #66

Ah, I never saw the ones with the East India Company. Marr Jan 2013 #71

Yeah it's only alluded to in the first one Recursion Jan 2013 #72

The third film has the greatest negotiation scene. Leopolds Ghost Jan 2013 #106

Let me help you with that MattBaggins Jan 2013 #69

You mean "Vendetta". Nye Bevan Jan 2013 #2

Even if choice A and choice B.. sendero Jan 2013 #31

Politicians work for what gets them elected Chathamization Jan 2013 #59

I vacillate... sendero Jan 2013 #70

Apathy's a problem Chathamization Jan 2013 #76

Except when "the people" include corporations. krispos42 Jan 2013 #34

Because of the perception theKed Jan 2013 #49

Wasn't the building filled with bad guys? nt MannyGoldstein Jan 2013 #3

Well, bad only if you're Catholic Marengo Jan 2013 #40

I think the OP was referring to the movie MannyGoldstein Jan 2013 #42

Random thought I had yesterday: XemaSab Jan 2013 #4

One quibble riqster Jan 2013 #32

Which makes the film even more like Fight Club XemaSab Jan 2013 #82

I agree... Dr Hobbitstein Jan 2013 #5

Uh, anarchists punks are not right wingers.., a la izquierda Jan 2013 #75

Anarchists punks Dr Hobbitstein Jan 2013 #92

Reread the Declaration of Independence. Our country was founded on treason and anarchy. rhett o rick Jan 2013 #6

So President Obama did not win two democratic elections? Nye Bevan Jan 2013 #9

Bringing up the "debates" to provide evidence of legitimacy is indicative of missing the point TheKentuckian Jan 2013 #78

Obama was chosen well before the elections Leopolds Ghost Jan 2013 #81

Sorry to be the one to break it to you. By-the-way look up the definition of rhett o rick Jan 2013 #94

It was hardly anarchy frazzled Jan 2013 #14

Exactly--the colonists really did try to reason with the crown. King George put his boot up their MADem Jan 2013 #24

Well, he seemed pretty fond of the conquired Quebecois Sen. Walter Sobchak Jan 2013 #83

That's something of a simplification. Both sides misunderstood what the other was aiming at.... Moonwalk Jan 2013 #103

Common misconception tama Jan 2013 #27

I think perhaps the misconception is yours frazzled Jan 2013 #41

There were plenty of radicals at the time of the American Revolution. They didn't win the debate Leopolds Ghost Jan 2013 #85

Huh? frazzled Jan 2013 #93

I don't think you quite grok the intent of the mask. Leopolds Ghost Jan 2013 #101

The colonists were British subjects and even some of the representatives at the Continental Congress rhett o rick Jan 2013 #57

Organized armed revolt is not the same as anarchism frazzled Jan 2013 #64

I stand corrected. I check the internets and see what you are saying. rhett o rick Jan 2013 #99

Thanks for the thanks! frazzled Jan 2013 #100

Shhh, dont spread it around. Not sure it's legal. nm rhett o rick Jan 2013 #102

Do you understand the meaning of anarchy? enlightenment Jan 2013 #52

Yes I think I do rhett o rick Jan 2013 #61

That's true, but your avatar blew up Indochina DerekG Jan 2013 #7

I proudly wear my avitar to remember the actual good that was done in America. graham4anything Jan 2013 #26

Well, I guess it was a good thing to be an American under LbJ... a la izquierda Jan 2013 #73

Wasn't good to be anyone in the way of V who was in Big Ben at the time graham4anything Jan 2013 #110

Interesting thoughts... I will say this Leopolds Ghost Jan 2013 #105

At least get the movie's title right. backscatter712 Jan 2013 #8

Fawkes wanted to make it illegal to be a Protestant Recursion Jan 2013 #11

The creation and use of symbols doesn't always make sense. backscatter712 Jan 2013 #12

I don't think V was very much of a villain hfojvt Jan 2013 #15

He was very much an anti-hero, and at times, he was incredibly cruel. backscatter712 Jan 2013 #16

so it's his fault that the cops will shoot somebody who is not threatening them? hfojvt Jan 2013 #18

V knew perfectly well the cops were looking for a guy in a black cloak and a Guy Fawkes mask. backscatter712 Jan 2013 #68

what did he do to Evey? hfojvt Jan 2013 #74

Ah, then the scalding with hot steam must have been good clean fun... backscatter712 Jan 2013 #112

This message was self-deleted by its author backscatter712 Jan 2013 #62

I think the guy ordering the troops to stand down was likely following protocol Hippo_Tron Jan 2013 #97

why does he seem like a villain? he was an ordinary soldier, & as such, unlikely to have been HiPointDem Jan 2013 #115

Because there are a hell of a lot of angry people on both sides of the political spectrum. randome Jan 2013 #10

I don't see many people "idolizing" it Scootaloo Jan 2013 #13

I don't appreciate being likened to those monsters... Comrade_McKenzie Jan 2013 #17

If you're going to get your panties in a knot over a COMIC BOOK Matariki Jan 2013 #19

you mean . . . Batman and Superman are fictional?!? That hurts. ChairmanAgnostic Jan 2013 #54

Where is the anarchy? hfojvt Jan 2013 #20

except for one chemistry grad student and a few unimportant janitors you are saying??? graham4anything Jan 2013 #25

I work as a janitor myself hfojvt Jan 2013 #39

Alan Moore is anarchist tama Jan 2013 #28

maybe Chevy Chase is too hfojvt Jan 2013 #43

You are free tama Jan 2013 #44

actually, not really hfojvt Jan 2013 #46

What makes art art tama Jan 2013 #48

to me that sounds like hfojvt Jan 2013 #58

To me that sounds tama Jan 2013 #67

dialogue would involve hfojvt Jan 2013 #116

No intention to attack, quite the opposite tama Jan 2013 #119

In the film - which is what most people know intaglio Jan 2013 #21

Wow, can you get anymore apples to oranges with a post? Rex Jan 2013 #22

Because V was fighting what was basically, a neo-Nazi government. AverageJoe90 Jan 2013 #23

The American Revolution was not very Democratic either stultusporcos Jan 2013 #29

Oh, but that was a GOOD revolution! So many are BAD (Cuba, e.g.)! *sarcasm* WinkyDink Jan 2013 #47

and what of China? ChairmanAgnostic Jan 2013 #55

Anarchy is democracy tama Jan 2013 #30

anarchy is NOT the democratic party, which this particular site is graham4anything Jan 2013 #33

Do you have problem tama Jan 2013 #35

You simply don't understand what anarchy is all about Harmony Blue Jan 2013 #36

There has been a meme floated about lately...... socialist_n_TN Jan 2013 #50

BTW, there's a pretty good discussion in the Socialist Progressives group....... socialist_n_TN Jan 2013 #51

anarchy on either side is not the democratic way. It is anarchy graham4anything Jan 2013 #84

Precisely the opposite problem. What the ancient Greeks called democracy is now labeled anarchy Leopolds Ghost Jan 2013 #90

We don't live in ancient greece though. And the founders did not set up one person/one vote graham4anything Jan 2013 #108

Blowing up buildings is not anarchism, that was a right wing theocrat Leopolds Ghost Jan 2013 #125

Libertarians are NOT anarchists Downtown Hound Jan 2013 #98

LBJ was infinitely more liberal than Obama. n/t Leopolds Ghost Jan 2013 #86

This site is not the democratic party. redgreenandblue Jan 2013 #91

this particular site is not the democratic party n/t fishwax Jan 2013 #111

I Dunno---Maybe Because It Was Just A Fucking Movie? Paladin Jan 2013 #37

Based on a well respected graphic novel Leopolds Ghost Jan 2013 #88

The book is brilliant Nevernose Jan 2013 #38

I think someone is metaphorically challenged. marmar Jan 2013 #45

Ya think? Egalitarian Thug Jan 2013 #114

I've never seen the movie or read the book, but I'm tired of seeing those masks everywhere n/t arcane1 Jan 2013 #53

Well, institutional democracy is one form... Deep13 Jan 2013 #56

..... obamanut2012 Jan 2013 #60

Immediate gratification, instead of disciplined and work-wo/manly commitment to change of the patrice Jan 2013 #63

Within the context of the movie, what the hell else was to be done? TheKentuckian Jan 2013 #107

What are you talking about? tama Jan 2013 #120

Thanks for the timely post. Comrade Grumpy Jan 2013 #77

v is an anti-hero part of a long tradition in superhero comic books Phillip McCleod Jan 2013 #79

suttler is bush; creedy is cheney and dwp6577 Jan 2013 #80

It's like when the Rebel Alliance blew up the Death Star in Star Wars. limpyhobbler Jan 2013 #87

Using violence against tyranny is justified. Using violence against a democracy isn't. redgreenandblue Jan 2013 #89

that sounds like the NRA simplicity. graham4anything Jan 2013 #109

Words have meanings. redgreenandblue Jan 2013 #118

sheesh, complain, complain, yet you are free/open to write on a board google searched worldwide graham4anything Jan 2013 #121

Point to where I said that the USA is a tyranny? redgreenandblue Jan 2013 #123

Don't vote for Jeb Bush and it never will. Don't vote 3rd party and it never will. graham4anything Jan 2013 #124

US tama Jan 2013 #122

That is easy to answer. Lady Freedom Returns Jan 2013 #95

It wasn't very democratic for the American colonists Downtown Hound Jan 2013 #96

Thank you for pointing this out(+1) Lady Freedom Returns Jan 2013 #117

Here's some interesting Guy Fawkes Day poems from the era before Guy Fawkes became "safe" Leopolds Ghost Jan 2013 #104

Our founding fathers were at one time traitors davidn3600 Jan 2013 #113

I would... deathrind Jan 2013 #126

Sometimes the only viable solution is to blow shit up. bowens43 Jan 2013 #127