General Discussion
In reply to the discussion: If The Dems Made A Concerted Effort To Appeal To Rural Voters What Would You Recommend They Do?.... [View all]"classic divide with genuine progressive movements"
What does that mean? The USA has property rights, the government can not just take land from people to give it other people. It is against the constitution. If you think that "genuine progressive" means to take from one set of people to give to a different set of people than your movement is going nowhere.
I would like to know of what historical example you would cite of one people taking land from another to distribute? The European invasion of the Americas?!?! What ongoing processes? The Gaza strip?!?!
Wealth distribution through progressive taxation is one thing, and most people believe in that principle to a certain extent. The major differences between the sides is to what degree that transfer of wealth should be, our side believing that more progressive taxation being the answer. As soon as you start talking about taking land from other people and giving it to someone else you will lose 80% of both sides. Even more so because you want to take land from people who vote one way and give it others to vote the way you want them to.
Nonsense.