Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

yellowcanine

(36,777 posts)
33. I would also point out that some Catholic practices are a bit strange also.....
Fri Jan 27, 2012, 05:39 PM
Jan 2012

Some priests will administer the Annointing, part of the Last Rites, AFTER a person has died, simply for the comfort of the survivors, although this was also apparently justified before Vatican II on the basis that the soul might still be in the body, as I understand it. I am sure there are Catholic DUers who can clarify.

The other practice I wonder about is saying prayers at the funeral for the person's soul to keep it out of purgatory (again, my understanding) would seem to be something which really cannot be justified if one adheres to the notion of personal responsibility for one's faith.

And then there is that transubstantiation thing - which essentially turns the celebrants into cannibals, it seems to me.

Philosophically I have some trouble with the Immaculate Conception of Mary thing as well. So not only was Mary a virgin but HER mother was also? How about Mary's Grandma? How far do the virgin births go back?

And that Mary was a virgin all of her life - so Jesus had no siblings, but yet he supposedly did?

Is it unfair to compare these practices/beliefs to the Mormon practice of converting ancestors?

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

that is one of the very weirdest aspects of LDS barbtries Jan 2012 #1
It's not converting them - FreeState Jan 2012 #13
lol barbtries Jan 2012 #15
Dead or not the premise of the OP is 100% false FreeState Jan 2012 #17
As a former mormon, that is TECHNICALLY true, BUT.... arbusto_baboso Jan 2012 #27
Former Mormon myself too FreeState Jan 2012 #36
Trying to determine what mormons really believe... arbusto_baboso Jan 2012 #37
Reminds me a lot of the indulgences the Borgias used to sell... Taverner Jan 2012 #29
so it is also possible to unconvert dead mormons and take away their after death rights lol nt msongs Jan 2012 #2
That is a great idea MattBaggins Jan 2012 #23
Can someone explain to me how he'll sell this as freedom of religion? auburngrad82 Jan 2012 #3
This makes about as much sense as Gman Jan 2012 #4
I think this demonstrates a great level of disrespect for another person's dignity and humanity. madaboutharry Jan 2012 #5
yeah. barbtries Jan 2012 #16
Oh the evangelicals are going love this!! nt rbrnmw Jan 2012 #6
As an atheist, he'd laugh his ass off about this. MineralMan Jan 2012 #7
I think its a great campaign issue. Atheists don't care but all the other believers care A LOT! riderinthestorm Jan 2012 #9
As an atheist MattBaggins Jan 2012 #25
I'm a bit more of an agnostic Aerows Jan 2012 #8
Nut jobs! GeorgeGist Jan 2012 #10
This is no more ridiculous than some Christian beliefs Hugabear Jan 2012 #11
Mormons also consider themselves to be Christians DesertRat Jan 2012 #26
They are Christians, for whatever that's worth Taverner Jan 2012 #32
All religions are goofy Taverner Jan 2012 #31
If you can't get 'em while alive, do it after they're dead, when they have nothing to say about it. Avalux Jan 2012 #12
This is why the Mormon church collects mountains of genealogy records. Gidney N Cloyd Jan 2012 #14
This is how the Mormon church collects millions of dollars . . . Major Hogwash Jan 2012 #21
Why can't these mormons be man enough to try to baptize someone while they... Tikki Jan 2012 #18
I could be wrong but I don't think they do the "conversion" on the actual corpse. yellowcanine Jan 2012 #22
I still want to know why they don't do this while I'm still alive! Tikki Jan 2012 #28
Thats the point FreeState Jan 2012 #41
I was given the choice. Everyone who has been approached by their missionaries can say.. Tikki Jan 2012 #44
I would also point out that some Catholic practices are a bit strange also..... yellowcanine Jan 2012 #33
Someone in the family or attending the funeral must be.... Tikki Jan 2012 #35
I am more looking at from the standpoint of practices/beliefs that a nonreligious person or person yellowcanine Jan 2012 #43
"Klaatu... Barata... Necktie... Nickjob... Neckfffffff...." Warren DeMontague Jan 2012 #19
I am not Morman but I really don't have any problem with someone "converting me" to Mormanism yellowcanine Jan 2012 #20
how fanatical and ridiculous fascisthunter Jan 2012 #24
No. Mitt THNINKS he converted his deceased father-in-law. GoCubsGo Jan 2012 #30
Yeah it is weird but that is not why I don't want Mitt to be President. yellowcanine Jan 2012 #34
Are you makeing this up? n/t wandy Jan 2012 #38
This is true. Mormons convert dead people to Mormonism. Cali_Democrat Jan 2012 #42
This message was self-deleted by its author Obamanaut Jan 2012 #39
Those who are irreligious or practice other religions can find all manner of issues with which to jody Jan 2012 #40
I had to check up on this baptizing dead hogwash rbrnmw Jan 2012 #45
Snort! ROFLMAO lonestarnot Jan 2012 #46
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Yes, the Romneys Converte...»Reply #33