Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
General Discussion
Showing Original Post only (View all)Where do Michelle Rhee's children go to school? Glad you asked.... [View all]
HARPETH HALL, Nashville TN.
http://dianeravitch.net/2013/01/14/14051/
What? Not a charter school staffed by Teach for America temps? TFA temps = the best teachers in the country, according to Rhee.
Harpeth Hall
Harpeth Hall School is an all-girls private college preparatory school for grades 5-12 in Nashville, Tennessee. Tuition = $21K. Students: 650
Our Mission: To teach girls to think critically, to lead confidently, and to live honorably.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harpeth_Hall_School
Harpeth Hall School is an all-girls private college preparatory school for grades 5-12 in Nashville, Tennessee. Tuition = $21K. Students: 650
Our Mission: To teach girls to think critically, to lead confidently, and to live honorably.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harpeth_Hall_School
Look what Harpeth Hall's got:
Lots of technology, a 40-acre campus, an 8:1 student/teacher ratio, full arts, drama, music and sports programs, lots of student clubs, a highly experienced teaching staff, most with Masters Degrees --
http://www.harpethhall.org/podium/default.aspx?t=151749
http://www.harpethhall.org/podium/default.aspx?t=151749
One thing Harpeth doesn't have, though, is many black girls. Judging from the photos, even though Nashville public schools are half black:
http://www.harpethhall.org/
And, astonishingly, not a single mention of the all the reformy stuff Michelle thinks is so very very important for other people's children -- you know, important stuff like continual standardized testing, teacher evaluations, 'no excuses' discipline, accountability, humiliating teachers in the newspapers by falsely calling them perverts, duct tape --
All the stuff Michelle pushed in DC while she decimated the experienced teaching staff, broke up schools and cut programs. What gives?
It's almost like -- correct me if I'm wrong, but it's almost like her actions say OUR KIDS need one thing, but HERS need another.
Almost like she thinks OUR KIDS are different from hers. Stupider, or more criminal, or less creative, or less deserving or something.
It's almost like she doesn't want our kids to have all the nice arts and drama and music and sports programs and small classrooms and experienced teachers hers have.
I mean, really, correct me if I'm wrong, but that's what it kinda looks like...
And I wonder why Rhee is so vague about where, exactly, her girls go to school in this interview with Nashville's "City Paper"?:
You mention your kids, are they attending public school?
What I will say is that I am a public school parent, and, you know, because of that I think that all of these things, again, have a different impact.
Im just wondering do your kids go to a traditional public school or a charter school?
I would rather I keep my comments to Im a public school parent.
http://nashvillecitypaper.com/content/city-news/michelle-rhee-talks-charters-vouchers-and-getting-reprieve-school-boards
What I will say is that I am a public school parent, and, you know, because of that I think that all of these things, again, have a different impact.
Im just wondering do your kids go to a traditional public school or a charter school?
I would rather I keep my comments to Im a public school parent.
http://nashvillecitypaper.com/content/city-news/michelle-rhee-talks-charters-vouchers-and-getting-reprieve-school-boards
What Michelle is trying to say is that when she lived in DC, her girls went to a top-rated public elementary school in DC with other sons & daughters of DC's elites. So, she's a 'public school parent'.
Just not in Nashville. Which happens to be where her girls attend school now. But once a public school parent, always a public school parent, I guess.
Rhee's girls are in Nashville to be near their father, Kevin Huffman, from whom Rhee is divorced. Huffman is (surprise, surprise) the Commissioner of the Tennessee State Department of Education, an education deformer and former TFA-er!
From TFA, he jumped into law school, then became a lawyer for -- wait for it -- TEACH FOR AMERICA!!! And now he's Tennessee's state Education Commissioner!! How do these people do it??? They must be really really fucking fucking smart. No wonder they need different kinds of schools for their kids, because their kids are probably really really fucking fucking smart too.
Tell me, how do I get a gig like that? I mean, where I graduate from college with an English degree, teach for -- what was it Kevin, 3 months or 6 months or something like that? -- get a law degree & jump into senior management at the place where you were formerly a mere peon teacher temp -- and from there go on to run an entire state education department?
Is it the Swathmore English degree that assures this kind of career trajectory, do you have to grease some palms, or does somebody else do the greasing? You & your ex Michelle, same quick rise from temping to running the show.
How does that work? Do you have a connected relative? Or is it just that you were better at brown-nosing and back-stabbing than the rest of your TFA class and so caught the attention of the sociopath billionaires funding education deform?
Tell me the secret, Kev. How did a Whitey McWhitebread Swathmore English grad whose only experience in education is working as a TFA temp & litigating for Teach for America come to be running the mostly black & minority Tennessee public schools without some palms getting greased somewhere?
Kev is currently pushing through a raft of reformy, "cutting edge" (he calls it) stuff in Tennessee, like --
Teacher evaluations!
Teacher report cards!!!
New teacher accreditation organizations!!
A state-level version of Teach for America!!!
A teacher 'supply & demand' study!!!
Online schooling!!!
The largest student-and teacher-level database ever assembled!!!!
http://www.tn.gov/firsttothetop/programs.html
Teacher report cards!!!
New teacher accreditation organizations!!
A state-level version of Teach for America!!!
A teacher 'supply & demand' study!!!
Online schooling!!!
The largest student-and teacher-level database ever assembled!!!!
http://www.tn.gov/firsttothetop/programs.html
Woohoo, can you feel the excitement?
More cutting edge -- they're taking over all the 'bad' schools statewide!!
Parents in the Binghampton district in Tennessee are furious that the state took over their school, changed the name and colors, brought in an inexperienced staff, and no one thought to consult them.
Tennessee created the Achievement School District and put charter founder Chris Barbic in charge. Barbic, a graduate of the unaccredited Broad Superintendents Academy, has promised to take the schools scoring in the bottom 5% and put them in the states top 25% in five years. He has the authority to take control of low-performing schools to turn them around.
http://dianeravitch.net/2013/01/14/memphis-families-outraged-by-school-takeover/
Tennessee created the Achievement School District and put charter founder Chris Barbic in charge. Barbic, a graduate of the unaccredited Broad Superintendents Academy, has promised to take the schools scoring in the bottom 5% and put them in the states top 25% in five years. He has the authority to take control of low-performing schools to turn them around.
http://dianeravitch.net/2013/01/14/memphis-families-outraged-by-school-takeover/
Other cool 'cutting edge' stuff Kev's got going:
- Withholding state education funding from Nashville because they voted against (4 times) the McCharter school (Arizona corporation)/segregation academy Kev wanted to bring into the city:
http://dianeravitch.net/2012/10/27/kevin-huffman-knows-exactly-what-hes-doing/
Over the weekend, we discovered that not only was the state board of education encouraging Great Hearts to appeal, they were driving the bus, board member Anna Shepherd fired off before voting to deny the West Nashville charter school that a throng of affluent parents have pushed as a remedy for their wariness of public schools.
http://nashvillecitypaper.com/content/city-news/great-hearts-how-charter-operator-lost-political-fallout-and-what-happens-now
http://nashvillecitypaper.com/content/city-news/great-hearts-how-charter-operator-lost-political-fallout-and-what-happens-now
Well, I guess that's enough about this divorced power couple.
So to close, please join me in the Harpeth Hall Alma Mater:
O Harpeth Hall, O place beloved,
Our voices ring with happiness,
Our hearts are filled with pride,
As here each girl finds for herself
The joys that will abide.
So light of heart and free, we pledge
Allegiance through the years.
And of thy destiny so fair
Proud privilege to sing!
Our voices ring with happiness,
Our hearts are filled with pride,
As here each girl finds for herself
The joys that will abide.
So light of heart and free, we pledge
Allegiance through the years.
And of thy destiny so fair
Proud privilege to sing!
278 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Where do Michelle Rhee's children go to school? Glad you asked.... [View all]
HiPointDem
Mar 2013
OP
I find it disgusting, bringing children into a political fight. We have no idea why that family
msanthrope
Mar 2013
#12
Have you noticed that NOT ONE POSTER wants to talk about her kid in public school? Not one. nt
msanthrope
Mar 2013
#60
Okay--she's got one kid in public schools, and one in private. So, her policies would
msanthrope
Mar 2013
#90
Yes, it does. I can't think of a more fitting example of "Do as I say, not as I do"
hatrack
Mar 2013
#263
She's got one in public, one in private, according to the link. How does that make her a hypocrite?
msanthrope
Mar 2013
#54
If you dont see it, then I doubt you are willing to listen to an explanation. If you support her
rhett o rick
Mar 2013
#76
I have no support for Michelle Rhee, but I think bringing her kids into this discussion
msanthrope
Mar 2013
#79
Bringing America's children into a money making racket which is what she does, is
sabrina 1
Mar 2013
#165
Ahem--one child is in public school, one in private. And she doesn't hold public office.
msanthrope
Mar 2013
#171
She may not hold public office, but she has the ear of a great number who do.
kcass1954
Mar 2013
#235
She's got one in public, one in private, according to the link. So is it that she hates one, likes
msanthrope
Mar 2013
#55
She's got one in public, one in private, according to the link. So what does that say? nt
msanthrope
Mar 2013
#57
My guess would be the younger daughter isn't old enough for the 5 - 12 private school, yet.
mojowork_n
Mar 2013
#68
Why do you presume the public school is second rate? And why do you presume Nashville
msanthrope
Mar 2013
#71
I'm not making that presumption. I'd actually bet the kid's enrolled in a totally OK school.
mojowork_n
Mar 2013
#73
Well, you are the one who used the term "second-rate" education. Why even bring the kids into this-
msanthrope
Mar 2013
#88
Comparing apples to apples, I said it wouldn't seem fair to send them to different high schools.
mojowork_n
Mar 2013
#96
Well, that's ultimately a decision that family gets to make. Your 2nd paragraph underscores a great
msanthrope
Mar 2013
#107
Obviously she doesn't--she has a child in public school in Nashville. Facts are good. nt
msanthrope
Mar 2013
#172
I come by this information from the OP--read the links!! Rhee said one kid was in public school, an
msanthrope
Mar 2013
#177
Orrex, I never asserted or assumed that her child is 'special needs.' My kid is. nt
msanthrope
Mar 2013
#185
The OP does not link to Rhee saying one of her children is in PS. This is what
sabrina 1
Mar 2013
#193
Hey, aren't you brining the "other" public school kid in to your political argument?
Hassin Bin Sober
Mar 2013
#81
Dude--it's in the links provided by the OP. I say keep the kids out of it altogether. But be
msanthrope
Mar 2013
#83
I love Angry Attack Muffin!! We should have more bakery product avatars in general!. nt
msanthrope
Mar 2013
#109
Forget the kids. They're not "brought in to it." But what about that husband?
mojowork_n
Mar 2013
#86
But you haven't demanded that Rhee keep the rest of our children 'out of it' have you?
sabrina 1
Mar 2013
#223
Well, she's got one in public schools, and one in private. So, if you critique her on that, you've
msanthrope
Mar 2013
#82
Okay--so what's the relvancy of her having a kid in public, a kid in private schools? Instead of
msanthrope
Mar 2013
#93
I think the father has some say-so in this. Isn't the private school attendee there to be with him?
freshwest
Mar 2013
#260
The author of the OP is one of DU's finest. That was a blatant insult, Sid.
madfloridian
Mar 2013
#241
Yeah well, the NRA thought making a commercial about the Obama girls schpooling was appropriate, so
msanthrope
Mar 2013
#168
Oh, lordy--it would help if you read the thread. And I do not answer your questions. nt
msanthrope
Mar 2013
#186
I don't construct strawmen, so careful where you wave that insinuation around.
AtheistCrusader
Mar 2013
#236
Funny thing...in Hawaii public school teachers tend to send their kids to private school,
dkf
Mar 2013
#2
yeah, cause they're all getting so rich on those big union salaries!!! wheee!!!!!!!!
HiPointDem
Mar 2013
#3
Here's how think tanks like Heartland get those seemingly high results: They include administration
HiPointDem
Mar 2013
#220
so your 'source' is a 1995 article from the conservative "Heartland Institute" propaganda tank,
HiPointDem
Mar 2013
#7
I have never met a public school teacher who sent their kids to private schools.
duffyduff
Mar 2013
#145
When the Superintendent and the director of the BOE both send their kids to Iolani...
dkf
Mar 2013
#31
The way they collect those bogus statistics is by including administrators in the tally.
HiPointDem
Mar 2013
#248
DC (28%);Baltimore(35%);Phillie(44%);Chicago(41%)teachers w/kids in private schools
Divernan
Mar 2013
#113
Washington Times is NOT a reliable source and inner city school districts aren't representative
duffyduff
Mar 2013
#152
The Washington Times is an unreliable source for just about anything. They were
sabrina 1
Mar 2013
#200
The Wash.Times study was in 2004, and the teachers' union has not refuted it.
Divernan
Mar 2013
#215
Baloney. It's a pack of lies, just like dkf's garbage about Social Security. n/t
duffyduff
Mar 2013
#140
he didn't have a teaching degree. he had an english lit degree. but from swathmore.
HiPointDem
Mar 2013
#9
You know those General Education requirements that everyone hates and calls useless.
JVS
Mar 2013
#249
Disgusting, bringing a person's minor children into a political fight. Absolutely revolting. nt
msanthrope
Mar 2013
#11
My daughter goes to a religious school that accommodates her disability...the
msanthrope
Mar 2013
#25
I think it's disgusting when a family's only "option" is to have to pay money to go to a religious
Brickbat
Mar 2013
#28
I note that not a single poster has addressed the fact that one kid is in public school, one in
msanthrope
Mar 2013
#63
I think it's disgusting when someone like Rhee interferes with the decisions
sabrina 1
Mar 2013
#197
I do not answer your questions anymore, Sabrina, but it is enjoyable to watch you try to pose them.
msanthrope
Mar 2013
#205
Did you miss the point where one child is in public schools, and one in private? I note that no one
msanthrope
Mar 2013
#59
You think there aren't private schools in Nashville that teach 4th grade and below? My critique is
msanthrope
Mar 2013
#77
I don't see this as, "bringing the children into it." The line of criticism here is entirely about
Dark n Stormy Knight
Mar 2013
#230
She's divorced. Are you sure she even makes that decision? Further, you have
msanthrope
Mar 2013
#36
How is she hypocritical? Once child is in public schools, one in private. You have no idea what
msanthrope
Mar 2013
#53
Well, don't facts bring an interesting change to your argument? Now you aren't concerned about
msanthrope
Mar 2013
#67
She's got a kid in public school. So that kid isn't 'protected.' And you have no idea why one
msanthrope
Mar 2013
#104
What did he nail? He forgot that one kid is in private school, one in public. It kinda blows his
msanthrope
Mar 2013
#61
Orrex, my special needs child is in private school because her public school district cannot
msanthrope
Mar 2013
#112
I find your suggestion disgusting---and let me tell you why. Her child's private needs, regardless
msanthrope
Mar 2013
#121
I don't have to offer any refutation to the idea that a child must have their privacy violated
msanthrope
Mar 2013
#148
If you can't 'win' a debate without involving people's minor children, you've lost. If this is what
msanthrope
Mar 2013
#163
I don't get this, in NY all special education is paid for/provided by public funding
Progressive dog
Mar 2013
#119
I'm in PA. But NY state parents will tell you the same thing--you can't make teachers accomodate
msanthrope
Mar 2013
#124
She's got one in public, one in private, according to the link. So how is she hypocritical? nt
msanthrope
Mar 2013
#58
On a similar note, my parents wanted me to attend a private school that required a 30+ minute
no_hypocrisy
Mar 2013
#40
The OP makes it sound like both attend Harpeth, And posters here should ask themselves why. nt
msanthrope
Mar 2013
#70
The promotional literature on Harpeth contradicts much of what she wants in public schools
lolly
Mar 2013
#196
Excellent point... Why isn't this Education reformer fighting for smaller class sized?
midnight
Mar 2013
#94
You don't have to support Michelle Rhee to say that I would also send my kids to this or one like
Pisces
Mar 2013
#101
I don't agree with this argument. Her reforms may be a beginning. But I don't think she or
Pisces
Mar 2013
#133
No one is attacking her for her that. What she is being criticized for is that
sabrina 1
Mar 2013
#217
Rahm Emmuel pulling the same shit in Chicago w/his kids in elite private school.
Divernan
Mar 2013
#115
arne duncan went to the u of chicago lab school. he sends his kids to virginia public schools, but
HiPointDem
Mar 2013
#226
That is the point, but the usual suspects want to claim all of these public school teachers,
duffyduff
Mar 2013
#153
Performance-based incentives for teachers, and increased options for parents
michigandem58
Mar 2013
#237
Even after the concerted effort of team blue to derail this, you're top of the greatest page!
Egalitarian Thug
Mar 2013
#239
"The comfort of the rich depends on an abundance of the poor." Voltaire
Tierra_y_Libertad
Mar 2013
#269
Thousands of miles from here, which is odd considering she lives here and is married to the mayor.
LeftyMom
Mar 2013
#273
I was wondering about that too, but since some of the articles made it sound like she herself
HiPointDem
Mar 2013
#274