General Discussion

dflprincess

(29,271 posts)

29. No, from what I read in the Star Tribune, I had it right.

Thu Feb 2, 2012, 09:45 PM

Feb 2012

If a person was working for the church - say as an aide to the Archbishop - any insurance provided would not have to cover birth control.

On the other hand if someone worked at a hospital run by the church but that hosptial accepted Federal funds in any way, then birth control would have to covered. The same would be true of and charity or school that was taking any federal money.

This isn't really a ground breaking decision. Any denomination is free to choose who it allows to be a member of their congregation or clergy even if they have policies that violate the Civil Rights Act. But, any organization run by a church that gets federal money cannot violate the Civil Rights Act and expect to continue to get that money.

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

41 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

why pick a fight with Catholics right now? [View all] GusFring Feb 2012 OP

Someone who expected them to follow the law? Fumesucker Feb 2012 #1

You know, if it was an "unacceptable" religion getting money from the govt ... zbdent Feb 2012 #7

This message was self-deleted by its author Tesha Feb 2012 #2

Well that makes way to much sense. southernyankeebelle Feb 2012 #8

+1 mmonk Feb 2012 #35

You mean like a HOSPITAL?! FarLeftFist Feb 2012 #3

If they want to be in the business of health care, they need to provide the best care available. HuckleB Feb 2012 #4

I would Angry Dragon Feb 2012 #5

I have a feeling countingbluecars Feb 2012 #6

As a catholic I would want it covered and as a catholic I wouldn't go to their hospital to have my southernyankeebelle Feb 2012 #9

Which other regulations and laws should religious institutions be allowed to opt out of? Warren Stupidity Feb 2012 #10

I would since we had a catholic hospital imposed on us with no tsuki Feb 2012 #11

"Pick a fight" MNBrewer Feb 2012 #12

Would you want to be a Rape Victim with only a Catholic Hospital in town? HockeyMom Feb 2012 #13

Because they coddle sickos who rape kids? Odin2005 Feb 2012 #14

The church had a simple choice surfdog Feb 2012 #37

Because 98% of Catholic women have used some form of "banned" birth control. PA Democrat Feb 2012 #15

No one expects a Catholic institution to hand out birth control pills Warpy Feb 2012 #16

I don't think it's picking a fight SickOfTheOnePct Feb 2012 #17

I think you are right on the mark. CBHagman Feb 2012 #19

Because WOMENS RIGHTS should be protected at 'all times', this is an INSURANCE issue ... Tx4obama Feb 2012 #18

Catholic institutions are being forced to purchase birth control SickOfTheOnePct Feb 2012 #20

When you are an 'employer' you should have to play by the same rules as everyone else. Tx4obama Feb 2012 #21

We'll just agree to disagree SickOfTheOnePct Feb 2012 #22

If that were the case then ... Tx4obama Feb 2012 #23

I believe this rule only applies to entities that accept federal funds dflprincess Feb 2012 #25

No SickOfTheOnePct Feb 2012 #26

No, from what I read in the Star Tribune, I had it right. dflprincess Feb 2012 #29

No mention of a federal funds issue SickOfTheOnePct Feb 2012 #31

Then the Catholic Church shouldn't accept government money (Medicare, etc.) SharonAnn Feb 2012 #27

I'm still a little sore about the Spanish Inquisition DefenseLawyer Feb 2012 #24

I was raised Catholic- my mom and grandparents were good Italian Catholics... w8liftinglady Feb 2012 #28

Some Catholics are pro-choice, but some are not. The position of the Church... Honeycombe8 Feb 2012 #32

I think the church will stop offering insurance SickOfTheOnePct Feb 2012 #33

I gotta agree with you on that one, Gus. Bad move, IMO. nt Honeycombe8 Feb 2012 #30

They're still talking about this on Morning Joe. It's a fight POTUS cant win imo GusFring Feb 2012 #34

Rachel Maddow talked about it on the far more widely-viewed "Today Show" this morning. GoCubsGo Feb 2012 #40

Should Catholic institutions be able to fire gay people too? sufrommich Feb 2012 #36

They also don't have the right to force their beliefs on non-believers. GoCubsGo Feb 2012 #39

This law does not force using birth control on anyone. PeaceNikki Feb 2012 #38

Because those assholes need to learn to shut their fucking mouths AngryAmish Feb 2012 #41