General Discussion

oldhippie

(3,249 posts)

44. I would rather the States ....

Mon May 13, 2013, 02:15 PM

May 2013

... not enact tax laws that they cannot enforce. I do not advocate enforcing the existing use tax laws. They should be repealed.

And I don't think the state tax module to an online sales platform would be that simple. Each of the (how many?) state and local taxing jurisdictions are going to be contacting you (the internet retailer) and telling you what they interpret their rates and rules to be. Will they always be truthful? Correct? Some will want remittance monthly, some quarterly, some upon attaining a certain dollar amount. Do you really think having hundreds of state and local beauracrats telling you what to do with your accounting system is not a challenging problem? Being subject to audit by hundreds or thousands of different auditors?

I think if enacted, there will be endless litigation. I don't see it as an efficient way to collect revenue.

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

70 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

Internet Sales Tax [View all] liberalmike27 May 2013 OP

Full Text of Article liberalmike27 May 2013 #1

"if we buy something we should come home and pay taxes on that" jberryhill May 2013 #2

Living in AL liberalmike27 May 2013 #8

Adding liberalmike27 May 2013 #9

You seem to be misdirected jberryhill May 2013 #12

"only a moron is going to cut a check to the State, for stuff they've bought elsewhere" jberryhill May 2013 #10

You most certainly do NOT pay that tax to the other state joeglow3 May 2013 #22

So I buy a product from Italy and install it here and then ship it to customer in another state... L0oniX May 2013 #37

Italy is not in the United States jberryhill May 2013 #40

Ummm, are you really in business? joeglow3 May 2013 #43

Cal Thomas is an ultra-conservative Ron Paul/Bush/Steve Forbes republican graham4anything May 2013 #3

Thing Is liberalmike27 May 2013 #6

But it's not an extra tax kcr May 2013 #11

But, it wasn't being collected because ... oldhippie May 2013 #18

Sounds like regulation of interstate commerce to me jberryhill May 2013 #19

Uh, no. That would be .... oldhippie May 2013 #23

I referred to two things jberryhill May 2013 #26

Agree on Thing 1 ... oldhippie May 2013 #33

Can you honestly tell me ...... oldhippie May 2013 #27

Flat taxes are regressive. DebJ May 2013 #4

Flat taxes are regressive, yes liberalmike27 May 2013 #5

There is a hidden assumption in your figures jberryhill May 2013 #21

I have no problem with the internet sales tax as long as the tax goes to the Larkspur May 2013 #7

"...but I don't pay it because it's a hassle and easily forgotten. " oldhippie May 2013 #20

I use Turbo Tax to do my 1040 form Larkspur May 2013 #30

OK, I understand now ...... oldhippie May 2013 #36

Yep jberryhill May 2013 #42

I would rather the States .... oldhippie May 2013 #44

No, they are not going to be contacting anyone and lying to them jberryhill May 2013 #47

Hello? oldhippie May 2013 #48

My eyes aren't that bad jberryhill May 2013 #52

If the state wants the tax, then they have to find a way to enforce it Larkspur May 2013 #49

My state has a line in it's tax code concerning out of state purchases. bluestate10 May 2013 #65

Tax is for things that cost the nation and state and county and city money. L0oniX May 2013 #13

How do those purchases appear at your door? jberryhill May 2013 #14

Gas, tire, property and other taxes already pay for that. L0oniX May 2013 #15

Then why did you include it in your list? jberryhill May 2013 #17

So hows that tax thing working out for Delaware? L0oniX May 2013 #24

"a counter attack on you"? jberryhill May 2013 #29

But those goods don't magically appear on store shelves. joeglow3 May 2013 #25

Yes, and? jberryhill May 2013 #32

I agree with you, but in a stronger sense joeglow3 May 2013 #35

Ah jberryhill May 2013 #38

Once can argue the merits and demerits of sales taxt, but this is collecting taxes already owed. JHB May 2013 #16

Most store front operations sell online too as I am sure you know... L0oniX May 2013 #31

It seems like you are making an odd connection here joeglow3 May 2013 #39

Oh jeeze ...another reframe to promote an argument on DU. Whatever pffft n/t L0oniX May 2013 #41

So, won't answer the question, huh? oldhippie May 2013 #45

Whether I buy online or in a brick and mortar has nothing to do with taxes. RC May 2013 #46

"Sales tax is small potatoes compared to the income taxes that are not being paid" jberryhill May 2013 #53

The federal Government does not have a sales tax. RC May 2013 #56

The federal government is not proposing one either jberryhill May 2013 #57

Not just personal income tax, but ALL Federal income tax, corporate and personal. RC May 2013 #58

Am I in the right place? FreeJoe May 2013 #28

"to not bias them in favor of the well off" jberryhill May 2013 #34

it's only good if it's a federal tax alc May 2013 #50

"So I'd use some service to manage it" jberryhill May 2013 #54

One principle should be abundantly clear: only regressive taxes need indepat May 2013 #51

What are the demographics of internet purchasers? jberryhill May 2013 #55

I know not, but suspect the big-league professional basketball, football, and hockey players, who indepat May 2013 #59

Nothing like good, hard data jberryhill May 2013 #60

A relatively well off, well educated group of people. They should pay the damned taxes. nt bluestate10 May 2013 #66

I am always suspicious when something is endorsed by Big Business. Savannahmann May 2013 #61

Good business people understand money flow and document every movement. bluestate10 May 2013 #67

Here be the rub. Savannahmann May 2013 #68

Yeah, because... jberryhill May 2013 #69

Have you ever noticed that the rich folks never get audited? Savannahmann May 2013 #70

Great post SavannahMann liberalmike27 May 2013 #62

I support an Internet sales tax and want it implemented asap. bluestate10 May 2013 #63

Republicans LOVE sales taxes alarimer May 2013 #64