Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
General Discussion
In reply to the discussion: Why is woo sold as "mainstream?" [View all]marions ghost
(19,841 posts)27. This is my perspective:
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/larry-malerba/homeopathic-arnica_b_1081164.html
Clearing Up Some Misconceptions:
A bit of an odd situation has arisen because although homeopathic medicines are FDA approved and regulated, they have not been widely embraced by mainstream medicine and, as a result, there is a lack of information and many misconceptions regarding the nature and use of homeopathic products. With recent media attention (1) (2) focused on the use of Arnica for healing injuries, it is important to clarify those misconceptions and set the record straight as to how it can be properly used to maximize its benefits. In addition, there has always been a good bit of confusion in the media about herbal and homeopathic preparations in general -- and this identity problem applies to Arnica as well as many other homeopathic products.
Most of the general public is pretty well acquainted with herbal products. Also called botanicals or phytomedicines, herbal medicines are prepared from plant materials and administered in their natural form for a wide variety of ailments. Arnica has been historically used as an herbal preparation, however, the most common over-the-counter and only FDA approved and regulated form available is homeopathic Arnica montana. Sold in most natural food stores, it is important to understand that homeopathic Arnica is not an herbal product nor is it a nutritional supplement.
Homeopathic medicines are made from plant, mineral and animal substances, but it is the manner in which they are prepared that makes them unique. Homeopathic medicines are diluted to such a degree that skeptics claim the small doses are merely placebos. They argue that, in theory, it is impossible for them to have any therapeutic effect because it cannot be explained how they work. Experienced homeopathic practitioners and patients make the counter-claim that they actually work in practice. While the controversy rages on, the popularity of homeopathic medicine continues to grow.
Clearing Up Some Misconceptions:
A bit of an odd situation has arisen because although homeopathic medicines are FDA approved and regulated, they have not been widely embraced by mainstream medicine and, as a result, there is a lack of information and many misconceptions regarding the nature and use of homeopathic products. With recent media attention (1) (2) focused on the use of Arnica for healing injuries, it is important to clarify those misconceptions and set the record straight as to how it can be properly used to maximize its benefits. In addition, there has always been a good bit of confusion in the media about herbal and homeopathic preparations in general -- and this identity problem applies to Arnica as well as many other homeopathic products.
Most of the general public is pretty well acquainted with herbal products. Also called botanicals or phytomedicines, herbal medicines are prepared from plant materials and administered in their natural form for a wide variety of ailments. Arnica has been historically used as an herbal preparation, however, the most common over-the-counter and only FDA approved and regulated form available is homeopathic Arnica montana. Sold in most natural food stores, it is important to understand that homeopathic Arnica is not an herbal product nor is it a nutritional supplement.
Homeopathic medicines are made from plant, mineral and animal substances, but it is the manner in which they are prepared that makes them unique. Homeopathic medicines are diluted to such a degree that skeptics claim the small doses are merely placebos. They argue that, in theory, it is impossible for them to have any therapeutic effect because it cannot be explained how they work. Experienced homeopathic practitioners and patients make the counter-claim that they actually work in practice. While the controversy rages on, the popularity of homeopathic medicine continues to grow.
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
Recommendations
0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):
161 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
Not all homeopathy is quackery, but the homeopathy market does let in some quackery as well.
JaneyVee
Jul 2013
#1
All true homeopathy is quackery. It's heavily diluted water that supposedly has a "memory."
Dash87
Jul 2013
#4
Good point. I was lumping things like acupuncture and massage into homeopathy.
JaneyVee
Jul 2013
#15
It's easy to confuse the term *holistic* medicine (which is often legit, or at least arguably so)
The Velveteen Ocelot
Jul 2013
#29
Homeopathy's claims and its premises have all been falsified by 19th and 20th century science.
longship
Jul 2013
#25
I see problems with both ends of this - being a pharmaceutical chemist for many years....
NRaleighLiberal
Jul 2013
#45
I know a researcher who is trying to get the terminology changed to "placebo response"
Recursion
Jul 2013
#76
Just out of curiosity, what's your position on Asian medicine in general? Those
HardTimes99
Jul 2013
#132
I don't want to hijack Archae's thread but was hoping someone with expertise
HardTimes99
Jul 2013
#143
Do you mean to say that they've given up on that horseshit about 10K dilutions in water?
eridani
Jul 2013
#106
Please provide links to published (peer reviewed lit) reports of controlled studies
kestrel91316
Jul 2013
#34
using herbs/natural medicines is a good thing - but the dilutions/techniques
NRaleighLiberal
Jul 2013
#46
If you could sell a tiny ass bottle of water for $5, wouldn't you? n/t
taught_me_patience
Jul 2013
#19
if it was packaged nicely, I might buy a bottle of Mermaid Tears> BTW, OPI has a nail polish
KittyWampus
Jul 2013
#23
Personally, I was raised to consider lying and fraud to be bad things. (nt)
Posteritatis
Jul 2013
#42
Yes, many of us were, yet there seems to be a long held opinion that those things don't
Cleita
Jul 2013
#58
You seem to post extremely often on the subject of "woo". Regarding homeopathy>
KittyWampus
Jul 2013
#26
It is harmless so long as it does not cause owners to delay legitimate medical care.
kestrel91316
Jul 2013
#35
Agreed. I think some of the problem is that it is marketed as "natural".
Liberal Veteran
Jul 2013
#39
The only "homeopathic" remedy that I ever relied on was the chamomile pills...
Luminous Animal
Jul 2013
#88
They were sold as "homeopathic" and that is why I put the word into quotes.
Luminous Animal
Jul 2013
#98
We did. My husband used to manage a health food store and refused to carry
Luminous Animal
Jul 2013
#103
Yeah, I understand that (I'm a nurse), and we consulted with our pediatrician
Butterbean
Jul 2013
#115
Damn...I just now got used to homosexuals...Now I got some OTHER homo-thingy to try ...
BlueJazz
Jul 2013
#101
She thinks she's helping the people (from what she says). I suspect otherwise but try to be fair...
BlueJazz
Jul 2013
#113