Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

CTyankee

(68,234 posts)
57. You are RIGHT!
Sat Jul 13, 2013, 07:22 AM
Jul 2013

They are all artworks that were hidden in a castle in Montegufoni in Tuscany to keep them safe from wartime bombings of WW2. Most, but not all, had resided in the Uffizi in Florence. The major force behind this effort was Giovanni Poggi, superintendent of Galleries of Florence, Arezzo and Pistoia. Some 38 such repositories were used, primarily in Tuscany ( the artworks from the Veneto were sent to the Vatican for safekeeping). The so-called “Monuments Men,” primarily made up of art professors and historians in the U.S. (several from Yale) and U.K., served in the Allied forces to preserve and protect Italy’s art patrimony once the invasion of Italy was begun, from 1943 to the end of the war (known as the Italian Campaign). Here is a review of a newly published account of of this effort: http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424127887323744604578474901096756108.html

The art works that were too big to move or frescoes were protected in situ. Scaffolding was placed around the David at the Accademia and cushioned with thick padding. Then the entire statue was entombed in brick.

I have just finished reading "Saving Italy" by Robert Edsel, who also wrote "The Monument Men" and "Saving DaVinci." This is the 4th book on the MM that I have read, so it is something of a hobby of mine!

"The Monument Men" is now being made into a movie directed by and starring George Clooney, also featuring Matt Damon and Kate Blanchett. It will be released in December. I'm really looking forward to it.

The works in Montegufoni were largely unharmed (there was some minor damage to Pontormo's Visitation, shown here). And they were never stolen. So I guess I "gave away" the answer in my early response to the query that they were stolen by the Nazis! Unfortunately, other repositories were not so lucky. Once the Germans found out about them, the ransacking began (they called it "protecting" at first because Italy was an ally, but soon just hauled away what they wanted). The two Cranachs, Adam and Eve, owned by the Uffizi, were taken earlier from another castle as a special gift to the Fuehrer, since the Germans valued the art of Germany and the North over Italian art.

I didn't included La Primavera in the Challenge because I could see that on that painting's Wikipedia page, its removal to Montegufoni is noted. I knew that once I gave that hint, folks would have their answer!

Interestingly, the works were primarily moved by the Italians themselves to keep them from bombing damage by the Allies after the invasion of Italy. The Monument Men provided bombadiers with maps marked with locations of art work or architecture that should be avoided if at all possible. In Florence, that effort was spectacularly successful. However, the saddest part of the book is the account of the Germans blowing up every bridge in Florence except the Ponte Vecchio as they were retreating from the Allies. By order of Hitler himself, the Ponte Vecchio was spared. But the far greater architectural treasure, Santa Trinita (designed by Michelangelo), was reduced to rubble.

There is a considerable amount of this book devoted to the bombing that nearly destroyed Leonardo's Last Supper in Milan but it suffered greatly from bombs dropped next to the church where it resides. The MM tried heroically to restore what they could. However, this fresco was doomed from the moment Leonardo started it, since he experimented with paints and with painting it on dry wall, not wet, as true frescoes are done. It began to flake quite early on and is in very bad shape today.





Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

K/R and my initial "shot in the dark" guess about the connection was... NYC_SKP Jul 2013 #1
Not stolen. CTyankee Jul 2013 #3
No shoes!!! valerief Jul 2013 #2
Thanks. Nice to see you here! CTyankee Jul 2013 #4
#1 looks like Zimmerman, #2 is Snowden, #3 shows a drone strike, #4 ... wait, what ... 11 Bravo Jul 2013 #5
Yeah, I thought everybody needed a little break. I was getting a bit Zimmerman deranged myself... CTyankee Jul 2013 #14
And that's why you are a DU treasure! 11 Bravo Jul 2013 #28
Yeah, I know #5 is problematic. But actually, it's part of a good, not a bad, story... CTyankee Jul 2013 #42
Wayell, let's see, Benton D Struckcheon Jul 2013 #6
no, that is not a "connection." But it sure is nice to see you here, Benton! CTyankee Jul 2013 #8
I thought the Annunciation for some reason (but #5?) but that seems to be a no-go. Shrike47 Jul 2013 #7
I love them (maybe not the battle scene so much)... CTyankee Jul 2013 #10
Foreigners! Nevernose Jul 2013 #9
well, pink was a big deal color back in the century the ones with all the pink were painted. CTyankee Jul 2013 #12
Jesus wrote the Constitution, though jberryhill Jul 2013 #26
Naw, you know me better than THAT, jberryhill! CTyankee Jul 2013 #35
some are pre-Renaissance and others are later Renaissance so I'll guess Pretzel_Warrior Jul 2013 #11
They are not all in the Uffizi or any other one collection... CTyankee Jul 2013 #13
I don't think #1 is in the Uffizzi Nevernose Jul 2013 #16
You are right. Where does it reside? And who painted it? CTyankee Jul 2013 #19
Is it a Vermeer? Nevernose Jul 2013 #22
well, I hope she comes back soon...you need a little help here... CTyankee Jul 2013 #37
Okaayyy... ananda Jul 2013 #15
You got that part right! CTyankee Jul 2013 #20
I see a lot of angels ... oldhippie Jul 2013 #17
Quick guess Tansy_Gold Jul 2013 #18
I think St. Elizabeth is only in #1, based on the painting's title... CTyankee Jul 2013 #21
Well, i told you it was a quick guess! Tansy_Gold Jul 2013 #24
Thanks. There will be a major hint later if the mystery here is not solved...so drop by later... CTyankee Jul 2013 #27
I thought Tansy_Gold Jul 2013 #36
You are on a pretty good track...but keep going... CTyankee Jul 2013 #39
That's what I thought too. Kingofalldems Jul 2013 #25
I know. This one is vexing. But I thought art folks would enjoy doing a bit of sleuthing around CTyankee Jul 2013 #29
They all have people in the background? Nevernose Jul 2013 #23
I never thought of that...interesting, but not the connection I am seeking here... CTyankee Jul 2013 #30
all have illusion of depth from vanishing points to foreshortening, etc. Pretzel_Warrior Jul 2013 #31
one in particular represents a deviation from the Renaissance ideal of linear perspective... CTyankee Jul 2013 #33
2 are medieval and the rest are Renaissance or early modern. Deep13 Jul 2013 #32
Most do, but it is not the connection that these have in art history... CTyankee Jul 2013 #34
1.The Visitation by Jacopo da ontormo, 2.The Ognissanti Madonna by Giotto, avaistheone1 Jul 2013 #38
Yes. They are all in Florence but that is not the connection. Lotsa art in Florence... CTyankee Jul 2013 #40
Gee well how did I do identifying the art? avaistheone1 Jul 2013 #41
You got 'em. How didja do it? Or didja just know them? CTyankee Jul 2013 #43
Remembered most of them from my art history class a lifetime ago. avaistheone1 Jul 2013 #44
wow. that was one helluva good art history class! I wish I had had that...altho I've loved my CTyankee Jul 2013 #45
Something to do with the Medicis? Benton D Struckcheon Jul 2013 #46
good guess, but it is not anything to do with the Medici. CTyankee Jul 2013 #47
Here is your major HINT CTyankee Jul 2013 #48
That is Sandro Botticelli's La Primavera pinboy3niner Jul 2013 #49
I think this is the connection. ananda Jul 2013 #55
Yes, and the Italians kept this repository a secret from the Germans. They never got their hands CTyankee Jul 2013 #58
You are RIGHT! CTyankee Jul 2013 #57
The story of the rescue of the art treasures is impressive pinboy3niner Jul 2013 #59
Thanks! I hadn't seen the article. However, I did read Brey's book, "The Venus Fixers." CTyankee Jul 2013 #60
Thank you! Tansy_Gold Jul 2013 #61
Id love to see that movie again! CTyankee Jul 2013 #63
40+ years apart Tansy_Gold Jul 2013 #77
Just found it on Youtube! The whole movie! CTyankee Jul 2013 #78
I thought googling wasn't allowed? BainsBane Jul 2013 #65
I try to explain that there is a way to cheat directly by finding the image location and pasting it CTyankee Jul 2013 #68
This message was self-deleted by its author BainsBane Jul 2013 #66
It's funny .. ananda Jul 2013 #50
BEAUTIFUL???!!!! elleng Jul 2013 #51
REACHING! TOUCHING! elleng Jul 2013 #54
That's one of the most beautiful paintings ever BainsBane Jul 2013 #64
Also fuck Savonarola BainsBane Jul 2013 #67
I'm of two minds about Savonarola. While I am repulsed by his zealotry, he was also trying to CTyankee Jul 2013 #70
It's the Bonfire of the Vanities I hold against him BainsBane Jul 2013 #73
No, I am retired from Planned Parenthood of CT where I was director of Major Gifts. CTyankee Jul 2013 #74
What a wonderful way to spend your retirement BainsBane Jul 2013 #75
A few years back I toyed with the idea of getting an art history masters but the memory of CTyankee Jul 2013 #76
I wish I could go with you! chervilant Jul 2013 #79
That's great! I sometimes need a travel companion, but since I often use Road Scholar, they do offer CTyankee Jul 2013 #80
Variations of the Isis/Mary/etc. stories? nt ZombieHorde Jul 2013 #52
In Botticelli's "Spring", Manifestor_of_Light Jul 2013 #53
No, #1 is The Visitation. However, it does resemble the renderings of the 3 graces in other CTyankee Jul 2013 #56
Grat challenge ...... oldhippie Jul 2013 #62
What was the connection? Kingofalldems Jul 2013 #69
See my post #57 for an explanation. CTyankee Jul 2013 #71
Yes it is quite a story. Kingofalldems Jul 2013 #72
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Hi, DUers. Time for your ...»Reply #57