Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
General Discussion
In reply to the discussion: The History of the LABOR Movement is being erased from our nation's History Books. [View all]jtuck004
(15,882 posts)51. "They WILL have to fight these same battles all over again." Don't think so.
I agree with you, but...
We are in a fundamentally different era.
No longer do we have tens of thousands of people to organize and shut down production, because there isn't shit for production left here. (And it would take perhaps $20 to $40 trillion or more to bring it back in any meaningful fashion, and the other countries now have their own facilities, so we would have far less of a market to sell it to). Now we get a few hundred or thousand to shut down, what, McDonalds? To get a wage that still won't send the kids to school or pay for retirement?
We are about to be awash in old people like me, and we will be seeing bigger fights over social security and food stamps and health care. Smart kids are getting training that will let a few work internationally in ways we never dreamed of, even while we pull the rug out from under research that would solve some of the problems we are about to face.. There will be over a trillion in student loan debt that has no hope of every being paid back, we are replacing full-time jobs with part-time jobs in wholesale numbers, and home ownership is now down to the levels not seen since 1996, but with 50 million more people. Oh yeah, and a few people want an immigration bill which the CBO says will make us better off, but everyone skips the two paragraphs where it says it will increase unemployment for the next 10-15+ years before it gets better. (Because a lot of old folks will die off in those next 10-20 years).
Finance has replaced manufacturing, and it's tough to organize people who make a living by taking advantage of others.
I think when today's unions, government, and business conspired to kill off the labor movement in the 20's, their success paved the way for exactly what we have today. Until we can get people to consider doing what is needed to take control, they best many will ever be able to hope for puts them in a position of being what Malcom X termed the "house negro", and many, many more won't even have those "advantages". Here.
One can disagree with that, but, ironically, they can't even turn on their TV or pick up a copy of Time magazine without getting only what the corporatists WANT them to see. Harriet Tubman said "I saved a thousand slaves. I could have saved a thousand more if only they knew they were slaves". We are living those words.
Unless we consider where all that is taking us, we will be just running around in circles wondering where the cheese is, when the facts are that it is gone.
I agree that for a strong, secure, and independent people we need to not lose the spirit of what they fought for and taught us. Their actions were appropriate for the time, and unless we are together we will fail. But what does that mean in this very different world from theirs going forward?
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
Recommendations
0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):
112 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
The History of the LABOR Movement is being erased from our nation's History Books. [View all]
bvar22
Aug 2013
OP
human beings have a natural sense of when they are being treated badly. They can try and erase the
liberal_at_heart
Aug 2013
#1
A great program at Berkeley. Wish more people were going into the labor field. nt
SunSeeker
Aug 2013
#69
along with the era when government used to bust monopolies instead of enable them...
Blue_Tires
Aug 2013
#82
Our firm represents dozens of Unions nationally, yet I find many of the rank and file vote
Dustlawyer
Aug 2013
#84
Maybe This Time We Won't Settle for "Better Treatment" and Continue to Cede Ownership ...
HumansAndResources
Aug 2013
#64
A LOT of people won't have access to them, people who need to be aware of them.
jtuck004
Aug 2013
#53
When the free speech fights were going on, and in other places, the Wobblies used
jtuck004
Aug 2013
#96
Umm, what do you expect when Textbooks are now mostly being made by Big Corporations?
AZ Progressive
Aug 2013
#11
You might find this family interesting. They took over Texas and Texas all but
Egalitarian Thug
Aug 2013
#15
Sorry I didn't mean to step on your post. Texas is ground zero for the problem!!!!!
BlueManFan
Aug 2013
#40
You had already pointed out that Texas has national implications for textbooks
BlueManFan
Aug 2013
#55
Wow, how very super kind of you. Well, it's still no problem and any opportubity to both
Egalitarian Thug
Aug 2013
#62
There was never much there to begin with. When the labor movement was linked with communism, and
LuckyLib
Aug 2013
#16
What do you expect? .. with all the textbooks being published in Texas, of all places? eom
99th_Monkey
Aug 2013
#26
I remember learning about the new deal and labor movement in civics class sometime in the late 90's
PrestonLocke
Aug 2013
#27
In a culture where schooling has largely replaced education...mostly to keep us docile
jtuck004
Aug 2013
#47
I Like to think of this as the Texas effect. Since Texas is such a huge textbook market
BlueManFan
Aug 2013
#37
I swear all they teach is from the Pilgrims to the Civil War. Every damn year.
femmocrat
Aug 2013
#45
Many benefits which are being enjoyed by workers is the result of unions fighting to make work place
Thinkingabout
Aug 2013
#56
Texas controls what is in our public-school textbooks. All about its purchasing power.
WinkyDink
Aug 2013
#81
I made sure to cover it when I subbed in history for a couple of days.
knitter4democracy
Aug 2013
#85