General Discussion
In reply to the discussion: Time to cut the crap. Obama Derangement Syndrome doesn't really exist. [View all]nadinbrzezinski
(154,021 posts)It's the winner take all system enshrined in the Constitution. When we have more or less stable times it works well. It has failed when we get lack of cooperation between the two parties. It depends on compromise. Once it failed spectacularly, to the point that it led to a shooting civil war. It also led to the death of a hyper Conservative party and the rise of republicans, who were rather progressive. Yes the party of Lincoln was progressive.
Why Mill looked at that and decided it needed to be improved. Mind you, his system of proportional representation has been improved upon, but the US adopting that system would be a huge improvement. It would short circuit some of the dysfunction we currently suffer. If this system fails in an 1860 spectacular fashion again, I don't think the country will survive. I hope the successor state I live will remain a democracy, and will adopt a more modern way of electing legislators, and will remain secular.