General Discussion

LuvNewcastle

(17,911 posts)

9. Were you replying to me?

Mon Oct 14, 2013, 05:18 AM

Oct 2013

It's "secession" not "succession." A lot of people make that mistake; I'm just telling you for future reference.

Yes, I'm sure that if it were up for a popular vote, no state would vote to secede. There are a lot of military veterans down here, especially where I live, and very few of them would vote to leave the U.S. Southern states also receive a disproportionate amount of federal aid. A lot of people down here are rather ignorant, but they know where their money is coming from. We also have a lot of old people, many of whom are living off of Social Security. They certainly aren't going to vote to stop receiving those checks.

Southerners know their states can't and won't help them and the economy would fall to pieces if they left the U.S. Besides, even all of the southern states together would be no match for the U.S. military. Secession would be a very stupid thing to do on any level. Sure, there are some who would vote for secession enthusiastically, but most people down here know those people are idiots.

Trust me, I've lived down here all my life and I have deep roots here. Things would really have to get bad before secession would be considered. It would have to be a situation where they had nothing to lose, such as if the federal government collapsed and there was widespread anarchy.

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

86 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

About the South Seceding.... [View all] Are_grits_groceries Oct 2013 OP

Some, even here, seem convinced secession is the answer to our problems Hekate Oct 2013 #1

We have more than our share of crazies down here, LuvNewcastle Oct 2013 #2

If what you say is true, that a majority of Southerners do not want Secession, then hold a vote MarchemintotheSea Oct 2013 #3

I don't think it's a majority. Mariana Oct 2013 #4

Then put it to a vote and lets see who is correct! MarchemintotheSea Oct 2013 #5

Put it to a vote. So what? Are_grits_groceries Oct 2013 #8

Who's going to pay for it? You? Mariana Oct 2013 #56

Did I say that? Are_grits_groceries Oct 2013 #6

Yes I do in fact I think many would quietly accept it MarchemintotheSea Oct 2013 #7

Have you not seen the Moral Monday protests in NC against the GOP. Are_grits_groceries Oct 2013 #10

Yeah I have seen minor ineffective push back. MarchemintotheSea Oct 2013 #14

"minor ineffective push back?!!" please retract this zazen Oct 2013 #32

^---- wish this had a "rec" button nt Mother Of Four Oct 2013 #33

"better off relocating to better places" kentauros Oct 2013 #58

The only people I am aware of that want the South to secede cordelia Oct 2013 #27

There is another group that wants us to secede: kentauros Oct 2013 #59

Absolutely correct. cordelia Oct 2013 #61

Do you blame them? The south keeps sending idiotic teabaggers to DC. Sirveri Oct 2013 #81

Were you replying to me? LuvNewcastle Oct 2013 #9

No I was not MarchemintotheSea Oct 2013 #11

Well aren't you a sweetheart. Enjoy your stay. LuvNewcastle Oct 2013 #12

You know jack about what the South wants AND will quietly accept. Are_grits_groceries Oct 2013 #13

Seeing that I have lived in mutiple Southern locations I think I know a whole lot about the South MarchemintotheSea Oct 2013 #15

I'm a GRITS (Girl Raised In The South) and I'm married to a Yankee - Fawke Em Oct 2013 #67

You are a prime example renie408 Oct 2013 #20

You are incorrect..I don't feel superior at all. I see it as different people who want to live a MarchemintotheSea Oct 2013 #23

Exactly! Jamastiene Oct 2013 #75

In the ten years I've lived in NC... Mother Of Four Oct 2013 #30

You do realize an awful lot of blacks and latinos live in the South, right? Lex Oct 2013 #46

Psstt... it auto corrects on some devices. Fawke Em Oct 2013 #63

Um... in 1860s, only 47 percent of Southerners wanted to secede. Fawke Em Oct 2013 #38

There you go, injecting some historical evidence and logic... YoungDemCA Oct 2013 #83

The legislature in Arkansas pretty much ignored Art_from_Ark Oct 2013 #86

Bless your heart! Fumesucker Oct 2013 #16

That's a good point about the Midwest wanting to secede instead. kentauros Oct 2013 #60

Call Them On It. emanymton Oct 2013 #17

I am from Montana and I wish people would stop bashing the South. LiberalLoner Oct 2013 #18

if they openly advocated eliminating most black Americans, half the Hispanics, and most of the poor carolinayellowdog Oct 2013 #24

This. cordelia Oct 2013 #26

Do we really need another poverty-stricken, Third-world country on our southern border? baldguy Oct 2013 #19

I AM NOT advocating for secession. Are_grits_groceries Oct 2013 #22

I have lived in the Deep South my whole life. renie408 Oct 2013 #21

I hear more about the Confederacy and the Civil War on DU Fawke Em Oct 2013 #39

This! Ishoutandscream2 Oct 2013 #54

Yes, indeed! cordelia Oct 2013 #62

^^^^THIS! Jamastiene Oct 2013 #76

Yep. And I can't remember the last time I saw a Confederate flag... renie408 Oct 2013 #77

As a life long citizen of the South, I believe that your short simple post most accurately describes ladjf Oct 2013 #55

The South is seceding? cynatnite Oct 2013 #25

You may wish to brush up on your history. former9thward Oct 2013 #57

My bad. Thanks for correcting me. n/t cynatnite Oct 2013 #71

You are right, grits. brer cat Oct 2013 #28

In Missouri there is a strong sucessionist faction in the Republican Senate. gordianot Oct 2013 #29

People who are for seceding and those who address the topic at all... NCTraveler Oct 2013 #31

Really? Are_grits_groceries Oct 2013 #35

You read it properly. NCTraveler Oct 2013 #36

Not sure I'd call you fringe but as renie says above... Phentex Oct 2013 #41

As I said, Are_grits_groceries Oct 2013 #44

A unicorn is also an idea! Phentex Oct 2013 #48

I have seen many threads about secession. Are_grits_groceries Oct 2013 #49

SEC Football get the red out Oct 2013 #34

LOL... You just made a point for me. Fawke Em Oct 2013 #40

East Temmessee was also Union-friendly. Fawke Em Oct 2013 #37

I must disagree with you. Sissyk Oct 2013 #43

Yup. Fawke Em Oct 2013 #66

TELL ME YOU JUST DID NOT CALL THEM Are_grits_groceries Oct 2013 #47

My apologies! Fawke Em Oct 2013 #64

Apology accepted! Are_grits_groceries Oct 2013 #68

I'd love to tell you about the T-shirt I saw at a party this weekend. Fawke Em Oct 2013 #82

Also, this, too (in Palin vernacular), your in-state rival is Fawke Em Oct 2013 #84

You get my rec Stinky The Clown Oct 2013 #42

Nothing goes against our founding principles more than secession. BluegrassStateBlues Oct 2013 #45

People move, the demographics change in many places IronLionZion Oct 2013 #50

black migration to VA, NC, GA, FL is crucial to turning them "blue" carolinayellowdog Oct 2013 #79

Less about "the south" seceding.. karadax Oct 2013 #51

It would be messy. I live in New Orleans and we unwillingly support the rest of the State Katashi_itto Oct 2013 #52

Please call Randy Hultgren, R-IL, 202-225-2976. raging moderate Oct 2013 #53

The South can't afford to secede. They need Federal dollars to survive. TeamPooka Oct 2013 #65

The stupid teabggers and racists are controlling PA; the governor is a teabagger, they control the AlinPA Oct 2013 #69

Book recomendation nadinbrzezinski Oct 2013 #70

When I was growing up here in the South, I NEVER heard about the Confederacy steve2470 Oct 2013 #72

K&R Jamastiene Oct 2013 #73

This is for all of those that have stated kentauros Oct 2013 #74

Better idea - let's ship 'em all to Somalia instead. Initech Oct 2013 #78

The Presidential map showed significant Blue in Alabama. The state went for Romney, but not bluestate10 Oct 2013 #80

Kicked and recommended. Uncle Joe Oct 2013 #85