Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
General Discussion
Showing Original Post only (View all)Owner Attacked by Dog and Loses Arms: Was it Provoked or Out of the Blue? [View all]
Short answer: Probably not out of the blue:
While most dog attacks are not intentionally provoked, in some cases the dogs are intentionally trained. And in the case where a tough-breed of dog is owned by a violent criminal that cause is higher on the list.
A far more frequent cause of aggression, though, is that humans generally have inadvertently triggered the behavior or accidentally reinforced behaviors that can eventually lead to aggression. For instance, the most common cause of aggression to unfamiliar people is fear, and especially fear brought on when people approach and overwhelm a dog in an accidentally threatening way. They fail to recognize signs that the dog is fearful and they stare at, lean towards and reach out to the dog, often with friendly intentions. To the fearful dog, it looks like human is homing in on them with an intent to harm. For months the dog may cope with this type of greeting by backing away or freezing but it can just be a matter of time before they realize that the response of barking, lunging and even biting works better for keeping people away. For the humans, who do not know how to recognize the signs of fear and anxiety, the defensive attack does truly appear out of the blue.
But even non-fearful animals can become aggressive if certain types of behaviors are reinforced. What behaviors would these be? The ones that encourage impulsivity, over-arousal and encourage the dog to just react out of excitement rather than exercising self-control. For instance, puppies love to grab and chew any object they can get in their mouth. If you accidentally reward grabbing or chewing of your clothing or arms or jumping all over you in excitement, then you can be creating a serious problem for yourself down the road. By reward, I mean if you wave your arms around and squeal in surprise or pain, you sound and look like a human squeaky toy and you end up training the dog to grab you more. Even if you shout at the puppy in reprimand, often this causes these dogs to become more excited and to grab, jump and pull harder.
More:
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/sophia-yin/owner-attacked-by-dog-and_b_4293988.html
A far more frequent cause of aggression, though, is that humans generally have inadvertently triggered the behavior or accidentally reinforced behaviors that can eventually lead to aggression. For instance, the most common cause of aggression to unfamiliar people is fear, and especially fear brought on when people approach and overwhelm a dog in an accidentally threatening way. They fail to recognize signs that the dog is fearful and they stare at, lean towards and reach out to the dog, often with friendly intentions. To the fearful dog, it looks like human is homing in on them with an intent to harm. For months the dog may cope with this type of greeting by backing away or freezing but it can just be a matter of time before they realize that the response of barking, lunging and even biting works better for keeping people away. For the humans, who do not know how to recognize the signs of fear and anxiety, the defensive attack does truly appear out of the blue.
But even non-fearful animals can become aggressive if certain types of behaviors are reinforced. What behaviors would these be? The ones that encourage impulsivity, over-arousal and encourage the dog to just react out of excitement rather than exercising self-control. For instance, puppies love to grab and chew any object they can get in their mouth. If you accidentally reward grabbing or chewing of your clothing or arms or jumping all over you in excitement, then you can be creating a serious problem for yourself down the road. By reward, I mean if you wave your arms around and squeal in surprise or pain, you sound and look like a human squeaky toy and you end up training the dog to grab you more. Even if you shout at the puppy in reprimand, often this causes these dogs to become more excited and to grab, jump and pull harder.
More:
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/sophia-yin/owner-attacked-by-dog-and_b_4293988.html
If a dog is trained by humans to attack other humans - the dog isn't to blame.
If a dog is abused or neglected by humans & responds in fear to human contact - the dog isn't to blame.
If a dog is not trained & socialized properly and inadvertently harms a human - the dog isn't to blame.
And more importantly: if a dog does any of these things THE MILLIONS OF DOGS WHO DON'T DO THESE THINGS AREN'T TO BLAME EITHER!
So, let's stop blaming dogs for the actions of humans, shall we?

151 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Owner Attacked by Dog and Loses Arms: Was it Provoked or Out of the Blue? [View all]
baldguy
Nov 2013
OP
We don't have malicious propaganda saying Pit Bulls are useful to reach items at great height.
baldguy
Nov 2013
#17
Headline: Boy, 3, left with horrific facial injuries as Labrador savages him at ...
jazzimov
Nov 2013
#6
News reports are notoriously innaccurate whan it comes to ID'ing the breed in fatal dog attacks.
baldguy
Nov 2013
#26
Be that as it may you don't see poodle or chihuahua on that list very often
Major Nikon
Nov 2013
#30
Dogs are carnivores. They are ALL equipped to kill things & eat what they kill.
baldguy
Nov 2013
#21
I hope they charge the son with neglecting, training & harboring a dangerous animal.
baldguy
Nov 2013
#23
yes that is a rabies tag & the dog was only 2 yrs old, so he was vaccinated at least once.
Sunlei
Nov 2013
#141
An aggressive dog is more dangerous than a docile dog, no matter what the size.
baldguy
Nov 2013
#34
Yeah, well. You're the one who thinks dachshunds are more dangerous than pit bulls
Orrex
Nov 2013
#41
The little ankle snapper that chewed off my hands when I was trying to rescue it with nothing to get
lonestarnot
Nov 2013
#32
I'm just glad that so many folks with genuine, ongoing real world experience checked in here.
flvegan
Nov 2013
#44
The most flagrant anti-Pit Bull dog-hating poster on DU only posts lies about Pit Bulls.
baldguy
Nov 2013
#52
99.9999999% of Pit Bulls were bred, traind & raise to be companions & members of human families.
baldguy
Nov 2013
#59
And you're letting the real culprit - the son who neglected & abused the dog - off scot-free.
baldguy
Nov 2013
#67
So every pit bull who attacked a small child did so because it was afraid of the child?
XemaSab
Nov 2013
#135
How polite should one be when dealing with people who want to murder a member of your family?
baldguy
Nov 2013
#103
No, clueless would be someone that thinks pitbulls and labradors have equal temperament. nt
Bonobo
Nov 2013
#85
Another false equivalency...I think, I might be confusing my logical fallacies...
renie408
Nov 2013
#130
How sad for the Mother, not out of the blue. "everyone gets the dog they deserve"
Sunlei
Sep 2015
#151