Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
General Discussion
In reply to the discussion: Iditarod Musher Dramatically Revives Fallen Dog [View all]jsmirman
(4,507 posts)90. Defenders of the Iditarod - how do you respond
to even some of the claims from the front page of this site: http://www.helpsleddogs.org/default.htm
You extoll the virtues of the race itself, but it is very hard not to be concerned about the breeding practices and the kennel operations - in all my experience with *similar* operations, the conditions for cruelty are rife and very likely to occur.
It's nice that you provide a much rosier picture than what is outlined by stories like this one:
Dogs beating left me appalled, sick and shocked (Letter to the Editor, Whitehorse Star, February 23, 2011)
"It is around one year ago today as I write this, fewer than two weeks before the legendary 2011 Iditarod race start, that, as a dog handler at a private kennel location in Alaska, I witnessed the extremely violent beating of an Iditarod racing dog by one of the racing industrys most high-profile top 10 mushers.
Be assured the beating was clearly not within an 'acceptable range' of 'discipline'.
Indeed, the scene left me appalled, sick and shocked.
After viewing an individual sled dog repeatedly booted with full force, the male person doing the beating jumping back and forth like a pendulum with his full body weight to gain full momentum and impact.
He then alternated his beating technique with full-ranging, hard and fast, closed-fist punches like a piston to the dog as it was held by its harness splayed onto the ground.
He then staggeringly lifted the dog by the harness with two arms above waist height, then slammed the dog into the ground with full force, again repeatedly, all of this repeatedly.
The other dogs harnessed into the team were barking loudly and excitedly, jumping and running around frenzied in their harnesses.
The attack was sustained, continuing for several minutes perhaps over four minutes, within view at least, until the all-terrain vehicle I was a passenger on turned a curve on the converging trails, and the scene disappeared from view.
This particular dog was just under 10 days out from commencing racing in the long distance Iditarod race. It was later seen to have survived the attack, although bloodied as a result.
Personally, I have never witnessed such a violent attack on a living creature before. The image of that explosion of anger and physical force of one man on a smaller animal is burnt to my memory."
- Jane Stevens, Australia
How do you respond to this stuff. You're presenting what we are being asked to accept as a wholly sanitized version. Is the truth as clean as you are insisting it is?
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
Recommendations
0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):
127 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
no one outside who hates it gets ir or ever saw it. They don't know about the dogs and
roguevalley
Mar 2012
#22
Have I ever seen it live? No. Have I followed it since Susan Butcher started dominating?
jsmirman
Mar 2012
#27
I have been gone for about five years, so I do not follow it as closely as I did.
Drahthaardogs
Mar 2012
#115
I've done a 180 on that race & I no longer think it's a good thing for the dogs.
xchrom
Mar 2012
#10
For some reason this was alerted on. I have no idea where else it would belong.
HopeHoops
Mar 2012
#14
Yeah, that's why I wouldn't have locked it even if I didn't like it. Good story though.
HopeHoops
Mar 2012
#18
Gee, maybe being committed to your dog means not making it run 1,000 miles.
Arugula Latte
Mar 2012
#16
you never saw it or are around these dogs. I can't tell you how different they are than ordinary
roguevalley
Mar 2012
#21
I know, Blue. I try anyway. :) They are so wonderful. Lucky you to go to Nome. Hugs, honey
roguevalley
Mar 2012
#119
and you don't know crap. Philly burbs. Come here and see for yourself. Oh wait. That would be
roguevalley
Mar 2012
#120
And people die of heart attacks after leaving the Dr.'s office and getting an EKG.
hobbit709
Mar 2012
#76