General Discussion
In reply to the discussion: Is there anyone here who is good with Symbolic Logic? Here's a challenge.. [View all]Cleita
(75,480 posts)The first premise is false. No one can prove that Jesus existed let alone that he was either good or bad. I mean according to the gospels, the Romans thought he was a bad man. That's why they crucified him. Also there are a few more premises missing as to what one would consider a god. Your whole argument is a proof worthy of Sarah Palin.
Actually there is a far more elegant argument on I believe eight proofs of the existence of god. There is an equally elegant argument of eight proofs against the existence of god? take your pick. If you pick the argument for the existence of god, then you have a premise.
You can say god is all seeing, all present immortal etc. Then if you can say that Jesus is all seeing, all present, immortal etc. then you can say, therefore Jesus is God.
But the rub is proving the existence of god and his attributes and the existence of Jesus and his attributes before you can reach a logical conclusion.