General Discussion
In reply to the discussion: Colorado School Shooter Legally Purchased 12-Gauge Shotgun [View all]eqfan592
(5,963 posts)And your last post was very much in that category.
As to your argument, it is based entirely on a logical fallacy, unless you honestly think there is no middle ground between "doing nothing when a teen threatens somebody with bodily harm" and "locking any such person away in a cell to be submitted to testing."
And can I say more robust laws could have, for certain, not prevented the shooting? No, I can't, because I don't deal in absolutes when it comes to hypothetical situations. But do I think the laws you're proposing would have had a high probability of preventing it? No, I don't. An apparently intelligent and determined young man would have had little difficulty in coming up with a reason for wishing to purchase a firearm that didn't involve a crime. And that's assuming that a law requiring an answer to that question would survive the constitutional challenge it would face.