Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
General Discussion
In reply to the discussion: Whos is the best lead singer in Rock history? [View all]Initech
(109,219 posts)159. I want to agree with you but Geoff Tate turned out to be a huge douchebag.
I love Queensryche, Iron Maiden, Judas Priest, and Dio, but read this:
In a band meeting on April 12, 2012,[47] which Tate did not attend, the band fired Tate's stepdaughter, Miranda, from running the band's fan club,[16] and also fired the band manager, Susan Tate, because of ongoing "arguments and division" over decisions and "feelings that Susan Tate was not working on the behalf of the band as a whole."[16] Wilton would later justify the firings by saying: "the last 3 years, basically it just came to a point that we didnt have a voice in the band anymore. It was all run by the singer and his manager, the wife."[48] On April 14, 2012, before the soundcheck for a show in São Paulo, Brazil, Tate had an argument with his bandmates about the firing of his family.[12] It became heated, leading to Tate retaliating by throwing over the drum kit,[49] throwing several punches and physically assaulting[50] and spitting on Rockenfield and Wilton.[46]
Over the course of the band's next shows, Wilton, Rockenfield, and Jackson debated whether it was still possible to continue working with Tate.[16] The other band members felt that Tate continued to misbehave, leading Wilton, Rockenfield, and Jackson to "come to the conclusion that they can no longer work or perform with Mr. Tate,"[51] as they felt he "proved many times he was not working as part of a group, but as an individual. He was actively damaging the brand."[16] They called a band meeting on June 5[51] (some sources say June 6[16]). Tate withdrew from this conference call, after which the other band members voted to "[c]onsider Geoff Tate expelled from the band" and "continue to use the Queensrÿche name with a new lead singer".[52]
On June 12, Tate and his wife filed a lawsuit in a Seattle court against his former bandmates, claiming that he was illegally fired from the band.[50] They also sought a preliminary injunction to prevent both the plaintiffs and the defendants from using the Queensrÿche name. On July 13, 2012, the Washington state superior court defeated this motion, as well as a motion for a preliminary summary judgment filed by the defendants. The court ruled that both parties may use the brand Queensrÿche until the next court date. As a result of the judge's preliminary verdict, there are currently two versions of Queensrÿche until the court date or until a settlement determines who officially owns the name and imagery.[3] This court date was originally planned for November 18, 2013, but on August 9, 2013, the Tates filed a motion for continuance, requesting "a minimum 180-day continuance to provide sufficient time for the parties to continue active settlement negotiations without incurring substantial trial preparation costs and, if such efforts fail, to provide sufficient time to complete discovery and properly prepare for what will be a very lengthy trial."[53] The judge granted them two months instead, postponing the court date to January 27, 2014.[2]
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Queensryche#Queensr.C3.BFche_split_and_legal_proceedings_.282012.29
Over the course of the band's next shows, Wilton, Rockenfield, and Jackson debated whether it was still possible to continue working with Tate.[16] The other band members felt that Tate continued to misbehave, leading Wilton, Rockenfield, and Jackson to "come to the conclusion that they can no longer work or perform with Mr. Tate,"[51] as they felt he "proved many times he was not working as part of a group, but as an individual. He was actively damaging the brand."[16] They called a band meeting on June 5[51] (some sources say June 6[16]). Tate withdrew from this conference call, after which the other band members voted to "[c]onsider Geoff Tate expelled from the band" and "continue to use the Queensrÿche name with a new lead singer".[52]
On June 12, Tate and his wife filed a lawsuit in a Seattle court against his former bandmates, claiming that he was illegally fired from the band.[50] They also sought a preliminary injunction to prevent both the plaintiffs and the defendants from using the Queensrÿche name. On July 13, 2012, the Washington state superior court defeated this motion, as well as a motion for a preliminary summary judgment filed by the defendants. The court ruled that both parties may use the brand Queensrÿche until the next court date. As a result of the judge's preliminary verdict, there are currently two versions of Queensrÿche until the court date or until a settlement determines who officially owns the name and imagery.[3] This court date was originally planned for November 18, 2013, but on August 9, 2013, the Tates filed a motion for continuance, requesting "a minimum 180-day continuance to provide sufficient time for the parties to continue active settlement negotiations without incurring substantial trial preparation costs and, if such efforts fail, to provide sufficient time to complete discovery and properly prepare for what will be a very lengthy trial."[53] The judge granted them two months instead, postponing the court date to January 27, 2014.[2]
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Queensryche#Queensr.C3.BFche_split_and_legal_proceedings_.282012.29
I'll still listen to O:M as it's one of my favorite albums but I can't support Geoff Tate projects from here on out.
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
Recommendations
0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):
195 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
I'd say Freddie takes the all around rock musician too, if not all-time musician.
brewens
Jan 2014
#32
I was fixing to throw Dickinson out. Super underrated though Mercury is more than worthy
TheKentuckian
Jan 2014
#145
Hubs and I play the "make up a Rock Band" game when traveling/driving a long way
mtnester
Jan 2014
#8
Lindsey Buchingham is awesome. I just recently became a fan after watching a live concert
sabrina 1
Jan 2014
#75
Most rock singers have no vocal instrument .... it wasn't the point of rock singing.
kwassa
Jan 2014
#48
You're not missing anything. Roger Daltry is definitely in the top echelon of lead singers.
gtar100
Jan 2014
#128
I think we're all arguing over #2. I'd say Mercury is far ahead of #2 Joan Jett
lumberjack_jeff
Jan 2014
#25
I was considering him, incredible singer, but I think Plant had more MAGIC. nt
Demo_Chris
Jan 2014
#69
Going with Freddie, but Rob Halford and Chris Cornell should be on the list as well. n/t
sweetloukillbot
Jan 2014
#56
There's no who didn't at least start in the 70's that I'd put in contention...
Hippo_Tron
Jan 2014
#106
Well, since Chad Kroeger isn't on the list I'll have to choose Freddie Mercury.
Liberal Veteran
Jan 2014
#66
Way too many .. of course Mercury was way ahead of his time but just one of the greatest
YOHABLO
Jan 2014
#81
Peter Case, Dave Swanson, Steve Allen, John Doe, Ben Orr, Robin Zander, Dave Hidalgo...
Tikki
Jan 2014
#90
And even in his advancing years, while he has definitely lost some of his range and oomph,
Common Sense Party
Jan 2014
#191
Freddie Mercury, but this list is ridiculous without Robert Plant and several others in contention
Hippo_Tron
Jan 2014
#99
Yup...any doubters can listen to Truth/Beck to hear how good Stewart was from the get-go
BeyondGeography
Jan 2014
#176
You list Burton Cummings, Chuck Negron, & Freddy Mercury and add a choice disparaging old people?
Egalitarian Thug
Jan 2014
#123
Interesting. Given all day I wouldn't have considered him for best lead singer but best performers,
TheKentuckian
Jan 2014
#146