General Discussion
In reply to the discussion: Starfish dying in the NW Pacific [View all]Yo_Mama
(8,303 posts)There really is a point to the old "It's impossible to prove a negative" adage. Scientifically, that is.
If radiation were a factor, then we would be picking up the radiation in other lifeforms from the ocean in the west coast - and we aren't:
http://losangeles.cbslocal.com/2014/01/08/no-danger-in-eating-pacific-ocean-fish-despite-fukushima-disaster-usc-professor-says/
And believe it or not, yes, the US government has been checking and still checks. Here's an oldie but still relevant news release from the FDA:
http://www.fda.gov/downloads/Food/RecallsOutbreaksEmergencies/Emergencies/UCM253896.pdf
Here's a recent (this January) Scientific American article:
http://www.scientificamerican.com/article/what-to-worry-about-after-fukushima-nuclear-disaster/
...
Marine scientists have calculated that, based on all the radioactive particles released (or leaking) from Fukushima, a dose due to this most recent nuclear accident would add up to a total of roughly one microsievert (a unit of radiation exposure) of extra radiationroughly one tenth the average daily dose most Americans experience, one fortieth the amount from a crossNorth America flight and one one-hundredth the exposure from a dental x-ray.
Here's the thing - scientists and the already-extant nuclear monitoring programs in the US and other countries were checking on all this at the time of the accident and have been since. The reason there is no scientific concern over this is because in this case, they have proved the negative in so far as breaking the potential causal chain. You would have to be able to detect higher radiation levels in these waters before radiation could be a factor.
Close to Japan some of the fish are contaminated, most specifically those that live in the near-coastal waters, rivers and lakes near Fukushima and slightly north. As the run-off from land contamination washing into the waterways filters down into the sediments in these waters, contamination in some of these species could continue to rise for a few years yet. But that is thousands of miles from these dying starfish.