General Discussion

Chiyo-chichi

(3,979 posts)

53. I'm curious to know the other story.

Sat Feb 8, 2014, 11:05 AM

Feb 2014

Does it have to do with art theft again? Napoleon took the one from the cathedral to Paris & it wasn't returned to Antwerp until 1815. That doesn't address your clue about whether the entire picture is in a frame.

This Wikimedia page http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Peter_Paul_Rubens/1609%E2%80%931612 shows both the sketch and the painting if you scroll down. It says the sketch is at the Louvre.

According to this 1904 book-- http://books.google.com/books?id=Y-9ZAAAAYAAJ&dq=rubens%20rooses&pg=PP14#v=onepage&q&f=false -- (page 130), he first did the sketch that is in the Louvre, then he did a painted sketch, which at the time of this book was privately owned, then another (?) sketch that sold at Christie's in 1901. So there are three versions in addition to the one in Antwerp?

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

57 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

The Friday Afternoon Challenge Returns...again! Today�s puzzler: What�s going on here? [View all] CTyankee Feb 2014 OP

I just wanted to get in the first rec. Tansy_Gold Feb 2014 #1

Aw, I thought you were going to mow them down! CTyankee Feb 2014 #2

The first one depicts Ruby the Liberal Feb 2014 #3

and why is it a subject of interest, apart from the subject matter...? CTyankee Feb 2014 #4

Oh - I do not know Ruby the Liberal Feb 2014 #5

It's interesting... CTyankee Feb 2014 #6

On the right, who's the guy with the horse's head fadedrose Feb 2014 #15

"On the right, a Roman officer watches on horseback while soldiers in the background... pinboy3niner Feb 2014 #18

From the third panel of #1 TBF Feb 2014 #24

Welcome back CTyankee! longship Feb 2014 #7

well, thanks, longship! Nice to see you too here! CTyankee Feb 2014 #8

I got shots a couple of weeks ago fadedrose Feb 2014 #19

Yes, I am getting the shot later this month! I am going on an art expedition to eastern Tuscany CTyankee Feb 2014 #25

By the time it's readily available in MI, fadedrose Feb 2014 #29

Oh, you have touched my hear, dear rose! CTyankee Feb 2014 #38

The longest lasting shots I got was with a radiologist who had my elfin Feb 2014 #30

I got my shots with X-rays too fadedrose Feb 2014 #34

I will try to find a heated pool for therapy. I'm ready to look for anything that will help... CTyankee Feb 2014 #47

me too skipper fadedrose Feb 2014 #20

thank you. What great support you all give me...it is so nice and makes me feel so much better! CTyankee Feb 2014 #32

#1 is Reubens' The Elevation of the Cross pinboy3niner Feb 2014 #9

Yes! But what is different about this one? CTyankee Feb 2014 #10

For one thing, the same subject is spread across the three panels pinboy3niner Feb 2014 #11

but this is not what is different. Do you see the entire picture in a frame? CTyankee Feb 2014 #12

The diagonal aspect of the central panel with its foreshortening of the figures? pinboy3niner Feb 2014 #13

I see what you are saying! It wasn't what I was meaning, but I do get it... CTyankee Feb 2014 #14

The Rubens is a sketch of The Raising of the Cross, done before he made the painting. Chiyo-chichi Feb 2014 #35

I have been in that cathedral and its companion, The Descent from the Cross, is huge... CTyankee Feb 2014 #46

I'm curious to know the other story. Chiyo-chichi Feb 2014 #53

This one was "orphaned." It was originally stolen by the Germans right before WW2 and CTyankee Feb 2014 #55

Figure 3 mythical animals fadedrose Feb 2014 #16

they are but they have a back story in where they ended up...and it is right here in the U.S.A... CTyankee Feb 2014 #17

Those are griffins! countryjake Feb 2014 #21

OF COURSE they are griffins...but where are they? why are they there? CTyankee Feb 2014 #28

I believe it may be back in CA, now, but antiquities theft was the story... countryjake Feb 2014 #40

They are quite beautiful...fantastical animals... CTyankee Feb 2014 #45

#5: I read the story! Porno Georgian tiles recently found: WinkyDink Feb 2014 #22

TA-DA! Congrats WinkyDink, you GOT IT! Yay!!! CTyankee Feb 2014 #26

I remembered reading the story earlier (I like the UK papers on-line)! WinkyDink Feb 2014 #44

We've all heard and said... fadedrose Feb 2014 #36

That school magazine...?? title fadedrose Feb 2014 #23

I'm sorry, I'm not understanding what you are saying about a "school magazine" CTyankee Feb 2014 #27

Just remembered! HIGHLIGHTS fadedrose Feb 2014 #31

OK, so I get it now...sorry, I'm a bit tired... CTyankee Feb 2014 #33

I think #2... jberryhill Feb 2014 #37

I've always wondered about griffin meat...is it tough? does it taste like chicken? CTyankee Feb 2014 #39

I gotta rec this because I love your challenges. panader0 Feb 2014 #41

#6: The �12.5m selfie (Anthony van Dyck self-portrait) pinboy3niner Feb 2014 #42

Aaahhh! countryjake Feb 2014 #43

good for you! Only 3 and 4 left to guess... CTyankee Feb 2014 #48

HINT! CTyankee Feb 2014 #49

I've given up on #3, but #4 is portrait of St. Catherine by Rubens... countryjake Feb 2014 #50

The interesting thing here is that this painting was stolen by an American G.I. during WWII... CTyankee Feb 2014 #51

Yeah, I knew that it had to be about WWII art theft... countryjake Feb 2014 #52

Have you read any of the several books on this subject? CTyankee Feb 2014 #54

Answer to #3. CTyankee Feb 2014 #56

Thank you for the OP Ruby the Liberal Feb 2014 #57