General Discussion
In reply to the discussion: What the critics wrote about the Beatles in 1964 [View all]LiberalElite
(14,691 posts)"...The autocratic but not by any means ungrammatical attitude to tonality (closer to, say, Peter Maxwell Davies's carols in O Magnum Mysterium than to Gershwin or Loewe or even Lionel Bart); the exhilarating and often quasi-instrumental vocal duetting, sometimes in scat or in falsetto, behind the melodic line; the melismas with altered vowels (I saw her yesterday-ee-ay) which have not quite become mannered, and the discreet, sometimes subtle, varieties of instrumentation - a suspicion of piano or organ, a few bars of mouth-organ obbligato, an excursion on the claves or maraccas; the translation of African Blues or American western idioms (in Baby, it's you, the Magyar 8/8 metre, too) into tough, sensitive Merseyside. "
is not a sentence.