Ryan’s plan: Take from the poor, give to the rich [View all]
Ryans plan: Take from the poor, give to the rich
Appeared in print: Thursday, March 22, 2012, page A7
http://special.registerguard.com/web/opinion/27801233-47/ryan-budget-poor-programs-cuts.html.csp
Paul Ryan, outlining his latest budget proposal in the House TV studio Tuesday morning, said the policies of the Republican presidential nominees perfectly jibe with his plan, which slashes the safety net to pay for tax cuts mostly for wealthy Americans.
Do you wholeheartedly believe they will accept your budget? NBCs Luke Russert called from the audience.
Absolutely, the House Budget Committee chairman replied without hesitation. Im confident.
Makes perfect sense, in a way. Mitt Romney, the likely Republican nominee, is on record as saying, Im not concerned about the very poor. And Ryan has just written a budget that supports Romneys boast.
Ryan would cut $770 billion over 10 years from Medicaid and other health programs for the poor, compared with President Obamas budget. He takes an additional $205 billion from Medicare, $1.6 trillion from the Obama health care legislation and $1.9 trillion from a category simply labeled other mandatory.
Pressed to explain this magic asterisk, Ryan allowed that the bulk of those other mandatory cuts come from food stamps, welfare, federal employee pensions and support for farmers.
Taken together, Ryan would cut spending on such programs by $5.3 trillion, much of which currently goes to the have-nots. He would then give that money to Americas haves: some $4.3 trillion in tax cuts, compared with current policies, according to Citizens for Tax Justice.
Ryans justification was straight out of Charles Dickens. He wants to improve the moral fiber of the poor. There is, he told the audience at the conservative American Enterprise Institute later Tuesday, an insidious moral tipping point, and I think the president is accelerating this. Too many Americans, he said, are receiving more from the government than they pay in taxes.
<<snip>>