Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

CTyankee

(68,218 posts)
23. Mal, we do not "know it all." That has been our problem all along. We think we "got it right,"
Sat Mar 24, 2012, 07:49 PM
Mar 2012

just like that, snap, done! But we really didn't. I'm not saying some people didn't try. God knows, they did. Many good people. Many still do. And they are losing. Losing to corruption and lots of money in politics and the derision of RW republicans to distort and defame real reformers in our society. But you know this.

I just really want us to stop with the "American exceptionalism" stuff. We can do this, but we don't have the political will and the Constitution doesn't do much to require that we do, nor does it provide much flexibility. So we ARE left with a "piece of paper." "Adumbrate" means to "give a sketchy outline." Great. That and 50 cents used to get you a ride on the BMT line in the NYC subway.

When I see that women and children in Scandinavian countries have a constitutional right to the care and services they and their families need (and their countries rely on for their economic progress!) I wonder, what happened to us? Why aren't we doing this? When I see that gun deaths on a U.S. scale are vastly above what they are in France and Belgium, I wonder what happened to us? When I see that Ruth Bader Ginsburg would prefer the Constitution of South Africa (as noted in the NYT article) I wonder, what happened to us?

These other countries don't just "adumbrate." They DO. To quote Yoda: "Do or not. There is no try."





Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

The Founders did not hate government. HubertHeaver Mar 2012 #1
Can we stop with making the U.S. Constitution a sacramental doctrine? CTyankee Mar 2012 #2
NO !!! - And, Yes... WillyT Mar 2012 #11
I don't want to get into a long rant on this except to say that what you are saying strikes CTyankee Mar 2012 #17
You Make Great Points... But I Don't See A Solution Here... WillyT Mar 2012 #19
You know, I'm frustrated! I'm just at complete odds with a U.S. Constitution that just doesn't CTyankee Mar 2012 #20
Yep, your frustration is pretty clear malthaussen Mar 2012 #22
Mal, we do not "know it all." That has been our problem all along. We think we "got it right," CTyankee Mar 2012 #23
Also means "to bring out of shadow," malthaussen Mar 2012 #26
Very good analysis. I would like to know more from Con Law experts who I admire and respect, CTyankee Mar 2012 #27
Sounds good to me malthaussen Mar 2012 #28
glad you looked it up. I'm going to do so this afternoon. But I had a question for you. CTyankee Mar 2012 #29
Wasn't claiming "fatal" ambiguities malthaussen Mar 2012 #34
You make a point about "discrimination" and I would wonder further about what Justice Ginsburg CTyankee Mar 2012 #35
The idea of a constitutional convention in this day and age would be terrifying Posteritatis Mar 2012 #30
some of us would say we don't like living under the current "result" of our current Constitution. CTyankee Mar 2012 #32
They hated their ultra-conservative Monarchy "govt", but chose to love Democracy. FarLeftFist Mar 2012 #3
Then why didn't they make us a Democracy? Ter Mar 2012 #6
They hated democracy mackattack Mar 2012 #7
You're applying todays standards of democracy to the idea of democracy over 200 years ago. FarLeftFist Mar 2012 #12
No, Im not mackattack Mar 2012 #13
Well, true only to the extent that Madison and others did not like Greek style direct democracy. CTyankee Mar 2012 #18
The founders did not hate government but they did distrust it. former9thward Mar 2012 #4
It baffles me that people have so much trouble with the distinction you just noted Posteritatis Mar 2012 #31
Wow....no mackattack Mar 2012 #5
Hard to imagine Canuckistanian Mar 2012 #8
They would have asked "What's a bathtub?" malthaussen Mar 2012 #14
Yep, they did/do. Just finished CARO's LBJ bio: Senate is a BLOCKAGE (kill PROGRESS) n/t UTUSN Mar 2012 #9
This message was self-deleted by its author Herlong Mar 2012 #10
Which Founders? malthaussen Mar 2012 #15
If America today tried to form a United States chnoutte Mar 2012 #16
Not sure the FFs would even recognize a multicultural society such as the U.S. CTyankee Mar 2012 #25
Hamilton, Washington, & Madison built an activist federal government Bucky Mar 2012 #21
Apparently they hated government so much Shankapotomus Mar 2012 #24
Clearly not. They did have a clear suspicion of concentration of power that TheKentuckian Mar 2012 #33
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Did the Founders Hate Gov...»Reply #23