General Discussion
In reply to the discussion: No Republican president since Eisenhower has been legitimately elected, says Thom Hartmann [View all]BeyondGeography
(41,106 posts)His approval ratings were in the 30s throughout the campaign and he was underwater with Democrats. The last debate was a week before the election and Reagan blew him away. Carter's strategy hinged largely on scaring people about Reagan but the latter was cool as a cucumber in that last debate (and the two before them, one of which Carter missed) getting off his zingers while Carter appeared tense and irritable and failed to land any of the many punches he threw.
Watch the debates. Reagan won; not only that, Iran hardly comes up. People were much more freaked out about the economy than they were about Iran.
The Iran dirty tricks happened, but they aimed as much as getting Reagan's presidency off to a triumphal start as they were at denying Carter one last hope at re-election. You don't lose 44 states over what was then an old crisis.