General Discussion
In reply to the discussion: Amanda Knox should surrender to Italian authorities, The EVIDENCE Is Clear Enough- SHE DID IT. [View all]corpus_vile
(29 posts)He even said at the start of the appeal that the only thing anyone knew for certain was that Meredith had been murdered, which was utter rubbish as both defendants had already been convicted.
Yes there was (and is) lots of evidence against both defendants, hence the reason the Galati appeal was successful and Hellman's ruling annulled. This means that citing Hellman is actually meaningless.
No the entire house was the crime scene with five samples of Knox's dna mixed in with Meredith's blood in three separate areas of the house including Filomena Romanelli's bedroom where the staged burglary (which Knox was also convicted of) took place.
No it wasn't meaningless as Knox had testified that the bathroom was clean the day before. Which means that the blood got there due to Meredith's murder. Which means that in order for Knox's dna to mix with Meredith's blood innocuously, Meredith's blood would have had to have spilled/fallen/spattered in the exact precise same areas of the house where Knox's dna already was and sorry, I'm not buying that.
To clarify, investigating a crime scene would be "A ridiculous waste of time" for you?
No I'm actually informed about this case and I'm not the one making flalse statements that there's "no evidence" or that the crime scene was only Meredith's bedroom or that Mignini was a whacky Satanic conspiracy theorist, you are.
And if their supporters have to continuously make false statements, well, that says it all about their innocence and about the strength of the case against them, doesn't it?
And the dna evidence used to convict Guede lay in the same sealed crime area for the same amount of time as the bra clasp which convicted Sollecito. yet all the dna evidence against Guede is totally spot on, textbook correct, but the dna against Knox & Sollecito is suspect? Really?
Yes Guede would have gotten that fast track trial, as would you or I if we ever were up on trial in Italy as yet again anyone can choose for a fast track trial in Italy. Look it up.
Yes they did as again Guede was tried Separately in his fast track trial which again, Knox & Solelcito could have availed of only they didn't, so it's a it rich complaining about such things now.
No, she was treated more fairly than she would have been in the US as I doubt she would have been even given an appeal based non the strength of the case against her. But in Italy her appeal was automatic.
Again, Knox's supporters attack one of the prosecutors, the country of Italy, the victim's family, an entire judicial system and everything else they can think of to distract attention away from the abundance of evidence against her.
Again, such tactics says it all about their innocence.
Now if you're so sure that this is such a miscarriage of justice, then you've nothing to worry about as they're STILL allowed a final appeal, which is sure to exonerate them as the case is of course so weak against them. So everything will work out fine.
Court of cassation awaits, so I reckon we'll just have to wait and see what happens won't we? Personally, I reckon they're screwed, but again we'll see who's right come their appeal